Legacy Exteriors, LLC

4.29 |41 Verified Ratings
Write a Review

Legacy Exteriors, LLC

4.29 | 41 Verified Ratings
Write a Review


4125 Terminal Drive
McFarland, WI 53558
Your use of our services is governed by our Terms & Conditions

Legacy Exteriors, LLC

Legacy Exteriors, LLC, is a family owned and operated business with 35 years experience in the home improvement industry. We continue to b a Top 500 Remodeling Company in the nation as well as a Top 200 Exterior Remodeling company since 2011. We are Members of Nari, MBA and MABA. Our goal is to provide our customers with the best services and products available supplemented with the best education.


Learn how HomeAdvisor screens and approves their pros.

Service Area

  • Madison
  • Janesville
  • Sun Prairie
  • Middleton
  • Watertown
  • Verona
  • Waunakee
  • Poynette
  • Evansville
  • Oregon
  • Lodi
  • Cottage Grove
  • Stoughton
  • Jefferson
  • Columbus
  • Cross Plains
  • Milton
  • Beloit
  • DeForest
  • Dane
  • See All >

Services Offered

  • Asphalt Shingle Roof Install
  • Metal Roof Install

Areas of Expertise

  • Gutter Covers and Accessories
  • Seamless Metal Gutters (5" Only)
  • GAF Roofing

Product Brands Used

  • GAF
  • James Hardie
  • LP

Quick Facts

Business Hours
8:00 AM to 4:00 PM
8:00 AM to 4:00 PM
8:00 AM to 4:00 PM
8:00 AM to 4:00 PM
8:00 AM to 4:00 PM
12:00 AM to 12:00 AM
(Please call to confirm)
  • Small Jobs Welcome
  • Warranty Description: 100% Money Back Guarantee
  • Warranty Offered
  • Free Estimates
  • Materials
  • Credit Cards Accepted


In Business Since: 2005
Memberships & Affiliations
  • GAF
State Licensing
Trade: Dwelling Contractor Qualifier
License #: 1110435
Expiration: 07-06-2019
Trade: Dwelling Contractor
License #: 1113007
Expiration: 07-22-2019
  • Top 500 Qualified Remodeler Magazine 2007, 2011
  • Remodeler's Choice 100 Products 2008
  • Dealer Of The Year 2005-2008
  • Platinum Dealer 2004-2008
  • Top 200 Qualified Exterior Remoldeler 2011
HomeAdvisor Screened. View Details

HomeAdvisor allows Service Professionals to post information about themselves and their business on their profile. HomeAdvisor does not review or verify the information or representations set forth in those profiles, as they are self-reported by the Service Professional.

HomeAdvisor verifies state-level licensing where applicable - note: some states require local or county level licensing and you should verify whether or not your pro is properly licensed.

Business Overview

Community Involvement

McFarland Chamber of Commerce

Spring Brat BBQ


Legacy Exteriors, LLC

My Work
1 Projects
HomeAdvisor: The nation's largest network of screened and rated pros.

Ratings & Reviews
Legacy Exteriors, LLC

Real feedback from real homeowners.
Learn more about this pro by reading the ratings and reviews below.
Write a Review
Showing 1-10 of 41
  Page 1 of 5
Sort by newest   Date ▼   Rating  
3.0   |  
Cannot suggest using them. We hired the company to replace our roof and they ended up doing significant damage to our gutters. I will give them full credit they did replace the most damaged portion of gutter as well as reimbursing for other damages done to our property. However, the damages never should of happened and were easily avoidable with some common sense. The sloppiness of the entire job has me worried about the roof in its entirety.
Was this review helpful?  
5.0   |  
A fantastic company. I interviewed 4 companies for the project. I hired Legacy Exteriors for a number of reasons, starting with their sales rep Brock. Brock did a better job than the other reps did explaining what Legacy Exteriors would do and how they would do it. He also did a better job asking questions to identify and understand our concerns, so he could address them in the context of what Legacy Exteriors does when replacing a roof. The contract Brock provided was easy to understand and provided the level of detail I often require to avoid confusion. I requested and got some changes made to the contact, to reflect items I had discussed with Brock, but that were not included in the first contract we received. Legacy Exteriors A+ rating with the BBB, the positive reviews on the Home Advisor website, as well as the fact that they were only 1 of 2 companies I interviewed that are also members of the GAF Master Elite installers group were all big pluses and additional reasons to hire Legacy Exteriors. In addition to all these things, during the interviews Brock was the only rep who asked what we consider to be a critically important cost question. Once the project started, the team was very professional and did everything they were supposed to do. A day or two after the roof was installed, John the project manager stopped by to discuss the project, and to let us know that he would be doing a walk around our house with a metal detector to find nails, etc that the crew might have missed. I am totally satisfied with the work Legacy Exteriors did and their people. I am equally glad that we hired them.
Was this review helpful?  
5.0   |  
Review by in Madison, WI
Very professional. Did the job in one day. Left my property in great shape
Was this review helpful?  
2.5   |  
Review by in Sun Prairie, WI
Do a nice jod to
Was this review helpful?  
5.0   |  
Review by in Middleton, WI
Legacy Exteriors renewed our dated porch, replaced several broken doors and windows, removed the ineffective gutter system, and installed new vinyl siding. Our 60+ year old property looks like it was rebuilt yesterday, and the former eyesore that was our house has been metamorphosed into one of the most appealing homes in the neighborhood. The price was competitive with the various other proposals we received, and the new exterior is maintenance free. They guarantee their work and genuinely care about the total satisfaction of their customers, which is why they deserve the most serious consideration for any plans to upgrade your home's exterior.

1 of 1 users found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful?  
5.0   |  
Very professional throughout the process. Quick to inform me of any issues and then to resolve those issues.
Was this review helpful?  
3.0   |  
Review by in De Forest, WI
have some issue with siding that inspector chose to ignore...inexperienced help throughout job...still picking up nails as soon as snow melts...did not nail into studs on one side of house. siding bulging behind garage... job took over 3 weeks and according to onsite workers it should have taken 1 week to 10days. they seem to have improved since my siding was put on, repaired errors in a timely manner....was told they no longer sub-contract to builder used on my house..thankfully...my ratings would be higher if an experienced sub-contracter was used initially.
Was this review helpful?  
1.5   |  
Not real pleased with them. I was told that the job would be done in one day. At the end of day one it was nowhere near done. They didn't even have the old roof off. Also, had a big trailer parked in my drive so I couldn't even get my car in the garage. The price and quality of the product was just fine but the customer service left a lot to be desired.
Response by Legacy Exteriors, LLC: Most re-roofs do take one day but several factors attributed to yours going an extra day. This time of year our day light our are cut short, and we were training some new people on your roof. As far as the dumpster being in your drive way, this happens during a re roof, but we apologize for the inconvenience. You did receive however what you wanted and paid for, a quality product at a fair price. Your roof looks great and we our glad you are happy with the end result, which is the most important thing. Again we do apologize for it taking an extra day, but we thank you for your understanding and your business.

1 of 1 users found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful?  
2.0   |  
Review by in Madison, WI
Project: New Windows - 6 +
Three times they have scheduled with me to return and finish the trim. Each time they were a no show! The trim is a mess. I still have only paid half because the job was never finished. Very frustrating.I found screws all over my driveway and yard. I'm really glad I haven't had a flat tire yet.

2 of 2 users found this review helpful.

Was this review helpful?  
5.0   |  
Review by in Beloit, WI
Was this review helpful?  
Showing 1-10 of 41
  Page 1 of 5

Seal of Approval

What is the screening process that Service Professionals go through in order to become members of the HomeAdvisor network?

  1. Verify Trade License
    HomeAdvisor checks to see if the business carries the appropriate state-level license.
  2. Verify Insurance
    As a part of our screening process, we encourage professionals to carry general liability insurance. We require coverage for hundreds of services.
  3. Verification of State Business Filings
    For business types that require a Secretary of State filing, we confirm that the business is in good standing in the state in which it is located.
  4. Criminal Records Search
    HomeAdvisor uses 3rd party data sources to conduct a criminal search for any relevant criminal activity associated with the owner/principal of the business.
  5. Sex Offender Search
    We confirm that the owner/principal is not listed on the official state Sex Offender web site in the state in which the owner/principal of the company is located.
  6. Bankruptcy Search
    We use 3rd party data sources to check the history of the principal/owner of the business for bankruptcy filings by or against them.
  7. Legal Search for Civil Judgments
    We use 3rd party data sources to check the principal/owner of the business for state level civil legal judgments entered against them.
  8. Liens Search
    We use 3rd party data sources to check the principal/owner of the business for liens placed against them.
  9. Identity Verification (SSN)
    HomeAdvisor verifies the social security number(s) of the owner/principal for identity check purposes. This check applies primarily to smaller business entities.
  10. Identity Verification (Reverse Phone Lookup)
    We conduct a reverse business phone lookup to identify records matching the phone number information provided by the business.

NOTE: Member service professional information confirmed as described above may change or expire over time; while HomeAdvisor attempts to maintain accurate and up-to-date information, and confirms changes when notified, we cannot guarantee that profile and screening information is accurate. Therefore, we recommend that before working with a service professional you verify that information presented is still current and/or acceptable to you.
Please see HomeAdvisor's Terms and Conditions for a full description of how we screen Service Professionals

**Only for U.S. service professionals

Final Step - Confirm Your Appointment:

Confirm your appointment with on , - Change