Bought a ca 1938 house with original rumford style brick and mortar fireplace. MH did the inspection during buying process that noted it to be not functional due to cracked, missing mortar and allowing gases to leak through. Provided estimate of 3600$ to replace with stainless steel flue liner, new flue dampener, and tuckpoint firebox, sealing with chamber tech material. Initial work was done in one day, however when we we later tried our first fire, we noted soot coming through an electrical outlet above the mantel (very concerning). Joe arrived to inspect, and noted that the chamber tech sealant had "missed a spot" and the outlet box could be seen through a hole (showed me a picture). He arrived prepared, sealed the area and given OK. Well, on next attempt we had significant back flow of smoke into house. I called, he asked a few questions, mostly confirming fire type and flue dampener was open. But was disastrous, (eye stinging smoke) like a campfire in a closet. Joe arrived promptly again, this time with camera to inspect entire work done. Became very concerned that liner placed was too narrow and that prior tile was not removed as intended. He honestly explained the lead employee on the job prior was no longer with company and he was very disatisfied with work done. He took ownership and promptly (weather was rough) had his best crew come and remove the old liner, remove the old tiles, and replace everything. Took 2-3 days I think, two man job. He additionally hired a machine lift to save time of building scaffolding to get it done quicker. The initial crew i never got a chance to meet or supervise, but these guys were polite, knowledgable and professional. Joe was always reachable easily by phone and followed the work closely. Following everything, the fireplace worked great. <br /> It was disappointing to see the first go-round done carelessly, but Joe was very up front about everything, apologized and to his credit, made it right. Thats why they're deserving of an A rating. At no time, was there ever a hint that he wasn't going to do everything he could to make it right. The final work was also very well done and we're having no problems what so ever. Theres not a hint of smoke in the home anymore, it drafts perfectly as its specific architecture intended, the Joe knew well. recommended. <br />