Top-rated second story addition builders.

Get matched with top second story addition builders in Fishers, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Second story addition builders in Fishers

Avatar for Noble Home Improvement and Handyman Services

Noble Home Improvement and Handyman Services

176 W Logan St
4.68(
53
)
Approved Pro

Noble Home Improvement and Handyman Services

176 W Logan St
4.68(
53
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Terrific value
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers
188 local quotes requested

Noble Home Improvement and Handyman Services is a locally-owned business since 2015 that takes great pride in building custom decks, finishing and remodeling basements and larger handyman projects that homeowners will enjoy for years. As our name suggests, “Noble”, describes the fine qualities and high moral principles that are part of our product – building quality structures for families. You can expect expert staff and skilled craftsmanship, clean, tidy and courteous staff, jobs will be completed on time and on budget and satisfaction is guaranteed. Visit us at www.NobleHandymanLLC.com for more information or Facebook at NobleHandymanServices.

"Doug and his team have done several projects in/around our homes. We have used this team for many years. They are trustworthy and reliable. Doug and his team are friendly, respectful and professional. They take care while working in and around your home and clean up when they are finished. I would highly recommend Doug and his team!!!!"

Cathy S on May 2025

Noble Home Improvement and Handyman Services is a locally-owned business since 2015 that takes great pride in building custom decks, finishing and remodeling basements and larger handyman projects that homeowners will enjoy for years. As our name suggests, “Noble”, describes the fine qualities and high moral principles that are part of our product – building quality structures for families. You can expect expert staff and skilled craftsmanship, clean, tidy and courteous staff, jobs will be completed on time and on budget and satisfaction is guaranteed. Visit us at www.NobleHandymanLLC.com for more information or Facebook at NobleHandymanServices.

"Doug and his team have done several projects in/around our homes. We have used this team for many years. They are trustworthy and reliable. Doug and his team are friendly, respectful and professional. They take care while working in and around your home and clean up when they are finished. I would highly recommend Doug and his team!!!!"

Cathy S on May 2025


Avatar for Surroundings By Natureworks+

Surroundings By Natureworks+

200 South Rangeline Road #129
4.47(
516
)
Approved Pro

Surroundings By Natureworks+

200 South Rangeline Road #129
4.47(
516
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
212 local quotes requested
32 years of experience

Since 1993, Surroundings by Natureworks+ has been creating unique, custom outdoor and indoor living spaces. From luxurious decks, patios, and pergolas to custom kitchens and spa-like bathrooms. Surroundings by Natureworks+ has been the choice for thousands of homeowners throughout Central Indiana.

"It went really well. They were there when they said they were going to be. They left an accurate time line for how long the job is going to take and completed it within that estimated amount of time. They basically listened to everything I said that I wanted and it came out perfectly and as we expected. We're really happy with them taking what we anted and what we said we wanted and actually making it happen. Our Sales person, Ben Brown, did a really good job leasing between the workers. He's very attentive, listened to everything that we wanted and oversaw the job very well."

Jessica M on October 2022

Since 1993, Surroundings by Natureworks+ has been creating unique, custom outdoor and indoor living spaces. From luxurious decks, patios, and pergolas to custom kitchens and spa-like bathrooms. Surroundings by Natureworks+ has been the choice for thousands of homeowners throughout Central Indiana.

"It went really well. They were there when they said they were going to be. They left an accurate time line for how long the job is going to take and completed it within that estimated amount of time. They basically listened to everything I said that I wanted and it came out perfectly and as we expected. We're really happy with them taking what we anted and what we said we wanted and actually making it happen. Our Sales person, Ben Brown, did a really good job leasing between the workers. He's very attentive, listened to everything that we wanted and oversaw the job very well."

Jessica M on October 2022


Bowden Ceramic Tile

743 W. 236th St.
4.94(
256
)
Approved Pro

Bowden Ceramic Tile

743 W. 236th St.
4.94(
256
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers
152 local quotes requested

Won Angie's List SUPER SERVICE AWARD every single year since 1999 ! The Angie of Angie's List loved the shower and bathroom work we did in her personal home!! Our bathrooms and showers are built to last a lifetime. LEAK-PROOF showers GUARANTEED. Please call Wayne at 317-627-6838 to schedule.

"Wayne was punctual arriving exactly on time. He made helpful suggestions about the install, and did a beautiful/perfect installation. The attention to detail was excellent, and cleanup was immaculate. I couldn’t be more satisfied with the new backsplash. I would recommend Bowden Tile to everyone."

Stephen P on September 2020

Won Angie's List SUPER SERVICE AWARD every single year since 1999 ! The Angie of Angie's List loved the shower and bathroom work we did in her personal home!! Our bathrooms and showers are built to last a lifetime. LEAK-PROOF showers GUARANTEED. Please call Wayne at 317-627-6838 to schedule.

"Wayne was punctual arriving exactly on time. He made helpful suggestions about the install, and did a beautiful/perfect installation. The attention to detail was excellent, and cleanup was immaculate. I couldn’t be more satisfied with the new backsplash. I would recommend Bowden Tile to everyone."

Stephen P on September 2020


Avatar for Aventus Group LLC

Aventus Group LLC

8459 Castlewood Drive Ste D
4.97(
30
)
Approved Pro

Aventus Group LLC

8459 Castlewood Drive Ste D
4.97(
30
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
360 local quotes requested

At Aventus Builders we pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We believe in making our customers dreams come to a reality in every project. We look forward to earning your business! WE SPECIALIZE IN GENERAL REMODELING, KITCHEN AND BATH REMODELS, ADDITIONS, ROOFING AND GUTTERS. CALL US TODAY!!! 317-373-2980

"It was great, and we are so happy with our new addition! It took about a year from hiring them to completion, longer than I hoped but it was worth the wait. There were a few minor bumps along the way, but the crew resolved each issue promptly. The crew leader Saul was so helpful and knowledgeable, answering our many questions and making sure the final product was exactly what we wanted. The bedroom, bathroom and closet are all fantastic and we appreciate the care and attention to detail that went into the work."

Cheryl P on April 2025

At Aventus Builders we pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We believe in making our customers dreams come to a reality in every project. We look forward to earning your business! WE SPECIALIZE IN GENERAL REMODELING, KITCHEN AND BATH REMODELS, ADDITIONS, ROOFING AND GUTTERS. CALL US TODAY!!! 317-373-2980

"It was great, and we are so happy with our new addition! It took about a year from hiring them to completion, longer than I hoped but it was worth the wait. There were a few minor bumps along the way, but the crew resolved each issue promptly. The crew leader Saul was so helpful and knowledgeable, answering our many questions and making sure the final product was exactly what we wanted. The bedroom, bathroom and closet are all fantastic and we appreciate the care and attention to detail that went into the work."

Cheryl P on April 2025


Avatar for Centennial Construction & Remodeling Services, Inc

Centennial Construction & Remodeling Services, Inc

17265 Harger Ct Ste 113
4.42(
341
)
Approved Pro

Centennial Construction & Remodeling Services, Inc

17265 Harger Ct Ste 113
4.42(
341
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
597 local quotes requested
32 years of experience

Centennial Construction & Remodeling Services, Inc. is a professional company whose mission is to be the most honest, quality-oriented, full-service remodeling contractor in the northside of Indianapolis. We offer home improvements and remodeling throughout Carmel, Westfield, Noblesville, Fishers, and Zionsville. Centennial Construction & Remodeling Services, Inc. specializes in home construction, remodeling, renovation, and improvement in the Indianapolis area. Contact us today at (317) 848-7634.

"Centennial Construction did a fantastic job adding a small front porch to our home. They replaced our steps, put up a covered porch structure, and painted. Fast response times, quick turn around, and great service."

Callie Z on May 2025

Centennial Construction & Remodeling Services, Inc. is a professional company whose mission is to be the most honest, quality-oriented, full-service remodeling contractor in the northside of Indianapolis. We offer home improvements and remodeling throughout Carmel, Westfield, Noblesville, Fishers, and Zionsville. Centennial Construction & Remodeling Services, Inc. specializes in home construction, remodeling, renovation, and improvement in the Indianapolis area. Contact us today at (317) 848-7634.

"Centennial Construction did a fantastic job adding a small front porch to our home. They replaced our steps, put up a covered porch structure, and painted. Fast response times, quick turn around, and great service."

Callie Z on May 2025


Avatar for Phelps & Sons Construction

Phelps & Sons Construction

22 Sherry Ct
4.80(
64
)
Approved Pro

Phelps & Sons Construction

22 Sherry Ct
4.80(
64
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
445 local quotes requested

Welcome to Phelps & Sons Construction. We select quality materials to make whatever you dream up. We are a family-owned and operated home improvement company specializing in remodeling, including but not limited to room additions, kitchens, and bathrooms. We are known to pay exquisite attention to detail while making customer satisfaction our top priority. Call today for a free estimate!

"At the beginning the work started well but by the end the quality of work especially the drywall was subpar. Tom is slow in getting a quote to you but does respond. Tom is very nice but his staff is not professional especially Dave. I thought with Tom being in business as long as he has would be able to provide in a professional manner quality work. It is not true. Tom asked if I wanted his guys to take up the carpet. I thought ok. However, they tore up to 10 inches of drywall off many of the walls. They attempted to repair them but the work was subpar. I thought they were winding up work so I contacted the painters. The painters came in. There was tension between the paint foreman and Tom's crew. They were squabbling like elementary children on the playground. (I am not happy with the painters either but this is a separate matter) The walls unfortunately got painted with the poor drywall job. The painter did provide a drywall person to repair the worse spots. There are still poor spots on the walls but I wanted Tom and his crew out of my space. Each of the respective parties were blaming each other. This behavior is so unprofessional. On Friday last week, Dave was yelling at me over errors I did in trying to improperly apply color to the walls so I could see what it looked like (I applied the paint way before any drywall began). Again, because of poor communication the painters just painted over the poor drywall job. I did agree to pay for it since it was my mistake that should have been brought to my attention long before it was even painted over. Dave did such a bad job that there were air bubbles in the drywall because he did not let it set before he painted over it. Tom did have his other guy fix it. It looks better but not perfect. I had Tom put two new toilets in the space. There is now a big gash in the brand new floor where the floor doe not meet the toilet. There was not even going to be an attempt on Tom's part to fix this. In my opinion, all of the unnecessary drywall could have been avoided by properly having his guys take up the carpet right to begin with. I paid over $8,000 for unnecessary drywall, If you only have Tom's crew do the bare minimum that you need done for your project, then you are in good shape but BEWARE of them doing anything extra as it will cost you!"

Julie C on August 2020

Welcome to Phelps & Sons Construction. We select quality materials to make whatever you dream up. We are a family-owned and operated home improvement company specializing in remodeling, including but not limited to room additions, kitchens, and bathrooms. We are known to pay exquisite attention to detail while making customer satisfaction our top priority. Call today for a free estimate!

"At the beginning the work started well but by the end the quality of work especially the drywall was subpar. Tom is slow in getting a quote to you but does respond. Tom is very nice but his staff is not professional especially Dave. I thought with Tom being in business as long as he has would be able to provide in a professional manner quality work. It is not true. Tom asked if I wanted his guys to take up the carpet. I thought ok. However, they tore up to 10 inches of drywall off many of the walls. They attempted to repair them but the work was subpar. I thought they were winding up work so I contacted the painters. The painters came in. There was tension between the paint foreman and Tom's crew. They were squabbling like elementary children on the playground. (I am not happy with the painters either but this is a separate matter) The walls unfortunately got painted with the poor drywall job. The painter did provide a drywall person to repair the worse spots. There are still poor spots on the walls but I wanted Tom and his crew out of my space. Each of the respective parties were blaming each other. This behavior is so unprofessional. On Friday last week, Dave was yelling at me over errors I did in trying to improperly apply color to the walls so I could see what it looked like (I applied the paint way before any drywall began). Again, because of poor communication the painters just painted over the poor drywall job. I did agree to pay for it since it was my mistake that should have been brought to my attention long before it was even painted over. Dave did such a bad job that there were air bubbles in the drywall because he did not let it set before he painted over it. Tom did have his other guy fix it. It looks better but not perfect. I had Tom put two new toilets in the space. There is now a big gash in the brand new floor where the floor doe not meet the toilet. There was not even going to be an attempt on Tom's part to fix this. In my opinion, all of the unnecessary drywall could have been avoided by properly having his guys take up the carpet right to begin with. I paid over $8,000 for unnecessary drywall, If you only have Tom's crew do the bare minimum that you need done for your project, then you are in good shape but BEWARE of them doing anything extra as it will cost you!"

Julie C on August 2020


Zo Construction and Handyman

1505 Hoefgen Street
4.26(
295
)
Approved Pro

Zo Construction and Handyman

1505 Hoefgen Street
4.26(
295
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Terrific value
565 local quotes requested
45 years of experience

A Super Service Award Winner in multiple categories since 2014, Zo Construction is a family owned and operated local contractor, specializing in Painting, Roofing, and Remodeling jobs. As the owner of Zo Construction, Jeff McGaha will be your contact throughout your entire project. Jeff has years of contracting experience, with a tremendous array of skills and talent to tackle all of your home improvement needs. Jeff can also handle all of your window, siding, and wood/carpentry repair associated with your home improvement needs. It is the goal of Jeff’s to build a relationship with his clients that will last a lifetime. Zo Construction guarantees you will receive first class workmanship at a fair price. We would love the opportunity to partner with you and all of your home improvement needs.

"Jeff came out in timely manner and completed the work. Very down to earth and knowledgeable. The price and the quality of the work was great."

Myrick L on July 2024

A Super Service Award Winner in multiple categories since 2014, Zo Construction is a family owned and operated local contractor, specializing in Painting, Roofing, and Remodeling jobs. As the owner of Zo Construction, Jeff McGaha will be your contact throughout your entire project. Jeff has years of contracting experience, with a tremendous array of skills and talent to tackle all of your home improvement needs. Jeff can also handle all of your window, siding, and wood/carpentry repair associated with your home improvement needs. It is the goal of Jeff’s to build a relationship with his clients that will last a lifetime. Zo Construction guarantees you will receive first class workmanship at a fair price. We would love the opportunity to partner with you and all of your home improvement needs.

"Jeff came out in timely manner and completed the work. Very down to earth and knowledgeable. The price and the quality of the work was great."

Myrick L on July 2024


Avatar for Construction Services of Indianapolis

Construction Services of Indianapolis

6333 Allisonville Rd
4.80(
140
)
Approved Pro

Construction Services of Indianapolis

6333 Allisonville Rd
4.80(
140
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
402 local quotes requested

Up to 50% off on all materials including toilets, vanities, sinks, tubs, faucets, etc.. You pay only our suppliers cost. If you want a detailed and accurate estimate to save you money, please call John at 317-590-8620 to discuss your job. Multiple Angie's List Super Service Awards in 2008, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016,and a stunning total of 8 category Super Service Awards in 2017! Please call before emailing. When contacting by email, please leave phone number for response. Visit us at constructionservicesofindpls.com

"I was in desperate need of a full kitchen remodel, from my floor to the drywall to the ceiling, the whole kitchen sink of you will ( pun intended) I contacted CSI and spoke with owner John, after a pleasant conversation he directed me to a veteran contractor of his, Cuban. Now im not a expert by any means, but Ruban was able to concisely explain clearly all that was recommended, and needed, done after his walk through and estimate. To include honest and accurate pricing ( i did my research after), to say I felt comfortable moving forward is a surety. Ruban came in on time and was diligent in all expectations moving through the remodel. New flooring, sub floor, tile, drywall, paint, a luxurious island, new plumbing installed, new lighting, cabinets.... everything, and I tell you, worth every penny. I am so glad I found CSI, I appreciate y'all so much. It's no wonder Mr. Whitmoyer and his company have been around almost as long I have LOL. I recommend them to anyone who asks, and I suggest you do the same!"

deborah m on September 2025

Up to 50% off on all materials including toilets, vanities, sinks, tubs, faucets, etc.. You pay only our suppliers cost. If you want a detailed and accurate estimate to save you money, please call John at 317-590-8620 to discuss your job. Multiple Angie's List Super Service Awards in 2008, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016,and a stunning total of 8 category Super Service Awards in 2017! Please call before emailing. When contacting by email, please leave phone number for response. Visit us at constructionservicesofindpls.com

"I was in desperate need of a full kitchen remodel, from my floor to the drywall to the ceiling, the whole kitchen sink of you will ( pun intended) I contacted CSI and spoke with owner John, after a pleasant conversation he directed me to a veteran contractor of his, Cuban. Now im not a expert by any means, but Ruban was able to concisely explain clearly all that was recommended, and needed, done after his walk through and estimate. To include honest and accurate pricing ( i did my research after), to say I felt comfortable moving forward is a surety. Ruban came in on time and was diligent in all expectations moving through the remodel. New flooring, sub floor, tile, drywall, paint, a luxurious island, new plumbing installed, new lighting, cabinets.... everything, and I tell you, worth every penny. I am so glad I found CSI, I appreciate y'all so much. It's no wonder Mr. Whitmoyer and his company have been around almost as long I have LOL. I recommend them to anyone who asks, and I suggest you do the same!"

deborah m on September 2025


Avatar for Superior Bath System

Superior Bath System

10089 Allisonville Rd., Suite C
4.43(
54
)
Approved Pro

Superior Bath System

10089 Allisonville Rd., Suite C
4.43(
54
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
953 local quotes requested
23 years of experience

Ask about our Payback Program, up to 100% of your project can be paid back with our energy saving system. Dreaming of a bathroom that blends beauty with innovative efficiency? Since 2007, Superior Bath System has transformed ordinary bathrooms into extraordinary spaces. Specializing in complete bathroom remodeling, we offer expert tub-to-shower conversions, luxurious hydrotherapy walk-in tub installations, stylish walk-in shower remodels, and seamless bathtub replacements. Let us create a sanctuary that reflects your style and enhances your well-being. As a division of Energy Smart Inc., we bring energy-saving solutions to your home.

"We are very pleased with our entire project with Superior Bath. John took a lot of time with us in the planning and selecting phase. Work was completed in less than the time specified and the installer, Aaron was great to work with. Had a problem with the toilet after three months and they were great about coming back to fix it. The fix didn’t work though and instead of messing with another repair, they just replaced it with a brand new one. We would definitely recommend this company."

Deb M on May 2025

Ask about our Payback Program, up to 100% of your project can be paid back with our energy saving system. Dreaming of a bathroom that blends beauty with innovative efficiency? Since 2007, Superior Bath System has transformed ordinary bathrooms into extraordinary spaces. Specializing in complete bathroom remodeling, we offer expert tub-to-shower conversions, luxurious hydrotherapy walk-in tub installations, stylish walk-in shower remodels, and seamless bathtub replacements. Let us create a sanctuary that reflects your style and enhances your well-being. As a division of Energy Smart Inc., we bring energy-saving solutions to your home.

"We are very pleased with our entire project with Superior Bath. John took a lot of time with us in the planning and selecting phase. Work was completed in less than the time specified and the installer, Aaron was great to work with. Had a problem with the toilet after three months and they were great about coming back to fix it. The fix didn’t work though and instead of messing with another repair, they just replaced it with a brand new one. We would definitely recommend this company."

Deb M on May 2025


Avatar for D R J Construction LLC

D R J Construction LLC

204 37th Ave N, PMB 463
4.58(
19
)
Approved Pro

D R J Construction LLC

204 37th Ave N, PMB 463
4.58(
19
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
637 local quotes requested
30 years of experience

D R J Construction is locally owned and operated and has a reputation for superior quality and excellent customer service. We will provide you with superior products and service while making sure your home makes a striking impression. Attention to detail, quality products and quality workmanship are key.

"They repaired water damage in a bedroom and a bathroom. Did a fabulous job in doing a through and complete repair of the two rooms. John the project manager walked my wife I through planning, selecting materials, fixtures and all the countless things we never thought of. The final result is stunning. Beautiful craftsmanship and work. On final walk through I pointed out a couple minor things I noticed that needed attention. Very nitpicking of me. Those couple of items were addressed quickly and better than I expected or asked for. I recommend working with D R J Construction for quality and stunning workmanship."

Robert B on May 2025

D R J Construction is locally owned and operated and has a reputation for superior quality and excellent customer service. We will provide you with superior products and service while making sure your home makes a striking impression. Attention to detail, quality products and quality workmanship are key.

"They repaired water damage in a bedroom and a bathroom. Did a fabulous job in doing a through and complete repair of the two rooms. John the project manager walked my wife I through planning, selecting materials, fixtures and all the countless things we never thought of. The final result is stunning. Beautiful craftsmanship and work. On final walk through I pointed out a couple minor things I noticed that needed attention. Very nitpicking of me. Those couple of items were addressed quickly and better than I expected or asked for. I recommend working with D R J Construction for quality and stunning workmanship."

Robert B on May 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 940
FAQs for second story addition building service projects in Fishers, IN

For many homeowners, building up is worth the expense because it provides the extra bedrooms or living areas that can’t be accommodated within the existing footprint. A larger, updated home often commands a higher resale price, recouping a sizable share of the project cost while allowing you to stay in the neighborhood you love. Run the numbers with a real estate agent and contractor to ensure the expected return and day-to-day benefits align with your goals.

Whether it makes more sense to build up or out depends on your lot, budget, and local code. Building up preserves yard space and involves less foundation work, but you may need to vacate the home during construction. Building out avoids staircases and can proceed while you stay put; however, it encroaches on the yard and may face setback limits. Compare both options with your contractor before making a decision.

A structural engineer will first inspect the existing foundation for cracks, footings, and load capacity. Depending on the findings, the crew may pour new concrete footings, install steel or concrete piers, add reinforced beams, or tie additional rebar into the slab. These upgrades redistribute the weight of the new floor and bring the structure up to code. Your contractor will outline the specific reinforcement plan and timeline once the engineering report is complete.

The Fishers, IN homeowners’ guide to second story addition building services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

  • A renovated kitchen with a waterfall island

    HomeAdvisor’s DIY Kitchen Remodel Cost Guide looks at the cost of buying supplies and doing the work yourself. Find the key cost factors and how to cut expenses.

  • Secret room within bookcase

    HomeAdvisor's expert guide walks you through the cost to build a secret room, whether you're creating a safe room for security or a fun space to fulfil your childhood fantasies. Use this guide to help plan your secret room project and explore room, concea

  • outdoor patio bar

    Explore the cost to build a bar in your home and learn how materials, wet vs. dry bars, and labor costs influence the total price of your project.