Getting it Done with Dave: Hire Yourself, Hire Trouble!

On-the-level advice from David Lupberger, HomeAdvisor's home improvement expert.

Answer:
It's been said that a lawyer who represents himself has a fool for a client. The same can be said of many homeowners who take on do-it-yourself projects.

Most people have good intentions when it comes to taking on their own home improvement projects. Some think they'll save time and money. Some view carpentry, painting and other home remodeling activities as hobbies. And some simply enjoy the satisfaction of improving their property with their own hands.

But many do-it-yourselfers—even the handiest—underestimate the difficulty of doing projects right. They also underestimate the learning curve, especially when doing something for the first time, whether it's tiling, wiring or something else where experience really counts.

You've been there. You've probably started a project only to find yourself making a second trip to the hardware store sooner than you expected for additional materials and answers to questions. And then another trip. And another.

In my years of experience as a home improvement contractor and adviser, I've learned that doing it right boils down to cost vs. time. If your time is more important, always hire a professional. If cost is more important, well?understand the learning curve may be fairly steep, no matter how confident you are. Generally, you won't save time or money by doing it yourself.

You should especially think twice about serving as your own general contractor on a larger project where you'll need carpenters, electricians, plumbers or other subcontractors.

Do you really have the desire and ability to coordinate all those people? Are you sure they'll want to work with you—especially if each has to teach you about their role?

Most projects will take twice as long as you think and cost more, too. You could save yourself a lot of trouble in the first place by hiring a contractor who has experience completing projects just like yours on budget, on schedule and on target.

Dave's spring tips
If you're like me, you have an unwritten list of things to accomplish around the house this spring. Where to begin?

My own list includes expanding and organizing garage storage, touching up interior and exterior paint, and cleaning the carpets. If you think you'll need help from one or more contractors, list your needs on paper so you can group tasks and get estimates in an organized way.

Your home to-do list can seem overwhelming in any season. My strategy is to do the simplest project first, then go on to the next one, and so on. That way, you quickly gain a sense of accomplishment— and clear the deck for next season's projects!

Send your questions to asktheexpert@homeadvisor.com. Responses may appear in future editions of Contractor Files.