Top-rated natural slate roofing installers and replacers.

Get matched with top natural slate roofing installers and replacers in Bayville, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Natural slate roofing installers and replacers in Bayville

Avatar for Four Seasons Roofing
Four Seasons Roofing
4.6(
150
)

Serving Bayville, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1983

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"We live in a house that has a flat roof. It's also down a hill so you look down at my roof as you approachmy home. That's why the appearance is so important to us. I had several "flat roof experts" come look at the job and walk away. Bill (the son) didn't even blink. He immediately gave us the confidence needed to know these guys are the real deal. They took two layers of tar & gravel roof off my house and installed a high tech membrane and insulation. They had to drop the old roof down to the ground then hump it up the stairs into the dumpster. They came with 9 guys, Antonio was the crew chief. The nicest guys. And when they left, my property looked clean, without a single shrub or flower out of place. And the new roof is beautiful. Bill (the father) was here to supervise and really added to our confidence and satisfaction. I don't write a lot of reviews, but these guys deserve the shout out."
GAF Preferred Contractor Badge
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+19

Response time2 days
8 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by96%of homeowners
Avatar for Pinnacle Roofing 786
Pinnacle Roofing 786
5.0(
19
)

Serving Bayville, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

Warranties offered

"Working with Pinnacle Roofing 786 was a pleasure. The owner is very responsive, pays attention to all details and aspects of the job process, and communicative. The workers that showed up arrived on time and worked quickly. We reached out to Pinnacle Roofing to inspect my roof and they pointed out some areas that needed major attention and provided options of repair versus full roof replacement. We decided to go with the full roof replacement and could not be happier. So far no issues and we already have tested the roof with snowy and wet weather. Customer service has been excellent. Contacted Pinnacle Roofing to come by and check something months after the job was complete, and had someone at my door a couple of days later. Would not hesitate to recommend or work with Pinnacle Roofing again."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+39

Response time9 hrs
5 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by61%of homeowners
Avatar for Royal Roofing & Siding
Royal Roofing & Siding
4.5(
116
)

Serving Bayville, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 1993

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"This was a large job which required removal of the old roof - multiple layers of asphalt shingle and cedar shake down to rafters. The house is a large old Victorian with multiple angles and outcroppings, and very steep. There was also a one car garage. As promised, Royal arrived on day 1 - a Monday in 12 degree weather - with 3 dump trucks, several other trucks with men and equipment and over 30 workers. They swarmed over the house and by 10 AM the roof was stripped to the rafters and by the end of the day new plywood, underlayment and shingles had been installed on more than 3/4 of the roof. All work was completed in 4 days. Every night the property was thoroughly cleaned up. Progress was provided during the entire job by sending photos taken with a drone - terrific! Overall we were impressed and pleased with the work and the fact that it truly took 4 days. We had seen other jobs in the neighborhood take 3 weeks or more to complete. You pay for this kind of service - it is not cheap - but it is totally worth it. In addition, all of the workers and the project managers are very professional and attentive to your needs. I'll never have to use them again for this job, but I would recommend them in a heartbeat if you need a roof, gutters etc."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+41

Response time1 day
Response rate93%
17 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Brothers Aluminum Corp
Brothers Aluminum Corp
4.4(
202
)

Serving Bayville, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1980

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Everything about Brothers Aluminum far exceeded our expectations. They were simply excellent from start to finish - great service, quality, professionalism, pricing. They are some of the nicest, most professional, personable and customer-focused company's we've ever hired. We're so happy we selected them to handle our window and siding project. They replaced 27 windows and 5 patio doors and removed and replaced all of our siding and gutters. Teddy, the CEO, came to discuss the project with us on a few occasions, helped us make the right choices in terms of window models/styles and siding types, laid out everything as far timing, costs, financing options, etc. and were a delight to work with throughout the entirety of the project. They executed each phase of the project flawlessly, coordinated deliveries, communicated every step of the way, and conducted everything on time and on budget as promised. Their crews - both the window crew led by Gino; and their siding crew led by Manuel - were some of the best crews I've ever had work in/on our home. They showed up on time every day, were supremely competent in their duties, maintained a clean job site and were a delight to be around. Brothers Aluminum is the only option you should be considering for your home improvement needs. They were so wonderful to work with, I wish I had more work to give them. We're 1000% satisfied and am sure you will be too."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+16

Response time1 day
6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by87%of homeowners
Avatar for Best job construction
Best job construction
4.9(
17
)

Serving Bayville, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2017

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Mario and his crew did an amazing job replacing my roof and siding on the front of the house. The work quality was above my expectations. He was always responsive to my inquiries and completed the project on time."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+72

Response time7 hrs
Response rate99%
3 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for O'Brien Brothers Contracting, Inc.
O'Brien Brothers Contracting, Inc.
4.9(
209
)

Serving Bayville, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2015

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"The two brothers were great. Very business - like and friendly. They put new copper around my chimney and also replaced slates on the roof. I am very happy and would recommend them highly."
Copper flashings
Plywood
G.A.F Architectural shingles
Only the best materials
Chimney flashing and roof repairs

+53

Response time9 hrs
Response rate94%
146 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Power Home Remodeling
Power Home Remodeling
4.1(
288
)

Serving Bayville, NY and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

In business since 1992

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Noah and his crew were super clean and efficent, covered all working areas. Were super careful in there prep, making sure nothing got damaged. Replaced 11 windows. They had a crew of five people who each had a specific task. Finished whole project in one day. Windows look great and were installed perfectly. Finish work was fantastic."
A Makeover to Match
Full Home Remodel - Siding, Windows, and a Roofing system
A Makeover to Match
Full Home Remodel - Siding, Windows, and a Roofing system
A Makeover to Match

+32

15 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by84%of homeowners
Avatar for D & S Roofing Corp
D & S Roofing Corp
4.8(
174
)

Serving Bayville, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1939

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Dominick and his crew was there on time to install new roof skylight and gutters on 3/25/24 everything went well from beginning to end D&S had foreman on the job the all time they cleaned everything up and Dominick checked in during the day I would recommend them to any one looking to get a new roof or any other services they offer"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+2

Recommended by98%of homeowners
...
Showing 1-10 of 330
FAQs for natural slate roofing installation and replacement projects in Bayville, NY

A slate roof features thin tiles of natural stone installed over a solid deck and underlayment. Formed under intense heat and pressure, slate is exceptionally durable and delivers a distinctive, high-end look. Because the material weighs far more than asphalt, most homes need added structural support before installation. 

While upfront costs are higher and routine inspections are a must, many homeowners choose slate for its unmatched longevity and curb appeal.

Slate stands out for its 50- to 200-year life span, low maintenance, and classic aesthetic. It’s fire-resistant, energy-efficient, and often boosts resale value. 

On the flip side, slate runs far more per square foot than asphalt, weighs up to four times as much, and demands a contractor who specializes in the material. Tiles can crack on impact, and repairs cost more because the work is slow and precise. If your budget and structure can handle it, slate delivers top-tier performance for generations.

Natural and synthetic slate aim for a premium, stone-like appearance, whereas asphalt focuses on affordability. Real slate runs $10 to $30 per square foot installed and lasts up to 200 years; synthetic slate costs $10 to $15 and tops out at 50 to 100 years. 

Standard asphalt averages $3 to $8 per square foot and needs replacement every 20 to 30 years. If you want the slate look without the full price tag—or extra roof weight—synthetic is a solid middle ground.

With routine inspections and prompt repairs, a natural slate roof can last well beyond 100 years; some hard-slate installations reach the 200-year mark. Soft slate falls in the 50- to 125-year range, and synthetic products last 50 to 100 years. 

Remember, flashing, fasteners, and the underlying structure may need attention sooner than the stone itself. Severe hail or fallen limbs can also shorten life span, so schedule periodic checkups with a slate-qualified roofer.

If you plan to stay in your home long term—or want a standout selling point—slate delivers strong value. Although installation costs are high, owners often recoup 60% to 70% at resale and enjoy lower replacement cycles than asphalt. The stone’s durability, energy efficiency, and timeless curb appeal also appeal to eco-conscious buyers because fewer roofs end up in landfills. Just be sure your framing can handle the weight and that you budget for occasional specialty repairs.

Skip the DIY climb if you have a slate roof. Slate may be tough against the weather, but a single misplaced step can crack a tile and create a leak path. The surface also turns slick when wet, upping the risk of injury. Professional crews use staging and hook ladders that spread weight across multiple slates, protecting both the roof and the worker. To inspect or repair slate, call a roofer who specializes in the material.

The Bayville, NY homeowners’ guide to natural slate roofing installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.