Top-rated sump pump repair or replacers.

Get matched with top sump pump repair or replacers in Greencastle, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Top-Rated Sump pump repair or replacers in Greencastle - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for C&J Well Drilling and Pump Co
C&J Well Drilling and Pump Co
4.8(
390
)
Sump Pump - Repair or Replace

Serving Greencastle, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1996

Emergency services offered

Warranties offered

"We were in need of pressure tank replacement and since the pump was almost 30 years old we decided to replace it also. It was amazing to watch them flush out the gunk that was in the well and install the new pump. It made a great difference in the water quality after they flushed out the well. Pretty certain that was not something the last installer did. However, the constant pressure system they installed is to die for! After living here for 40+ years and dealing with low pressure problems it was just something we felt we had to live with. Well, I am here to write you that they fixed that problem and we still are not believing the difference! Not only that but a lifetime guarantee included. All at a price we considered very reasonable. Really nice guys! Did a great job, as scheduled, and you wouldn't know they had even been here. High fives!"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+89

Response time10 hrs
Response rate100%
Recommended by95%of homeowners
Avatar for 2nd Generation Plumbing LLC
2nd Generation Plumbing LLC
5.0(
5
)
Sump Pump - Repair or Replace

Serving Greencastle, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2021

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

\nYour Trusted Local Plumbing Experts – 2nd Generation Plumbing!\n\nAt 2nd Generation Plumbing, we believe great service goes beyond fixing pipes — it’s about building lasting relationships and earning your trust. As a family-owned business, we take pride in delivering dependable, high-quality plumbing solutions with honest communication, fair pricing, and exceptional customer care.\n\nFrom small repairs and water heaters to drain cleaning, sewer inspections, and major plumbing projects, no job is too big or too small!\n\nExperience the difference of a plumbing company that puts YOU first! Contact us today and let our family take care of yours. We look forward to earning your business!

Plumbing
6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Braxton Kortz
Braxton Kortz
New to Angi
Sump Pump - Repair or Replace

Serving Greencastle, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

Free estimates

Small jobs welcome

Hello,\nMy name is Braxton Kortz and I am a young man of 32 years old that is a jack of all trades and have over 20 years of experience in asphalt roofing, multiple years of experience in HVAC repair, minor electrical repairs, and plumbing repairs. I do have a full time position and am only able to work weekends (apologies). I offer quality work with integrity and a cheerful attitude. If I cannot perform a task, I have referrals to help you get to your end goal! Thank you and have a blessed day!

Avatar for Grace Management LLC
Grace Management LLC
New to Angi
Sump Pump - Repair or Replace

Serving Greencastle, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

Emergency services offered

Warranties offered

Small jobs welcome

Grace Management: Enhancing Your Living Environment.\n\nAt Grace Management, our core mission is to deliver dependable and professional home repair, remodeling, and upgrade services that are universally accessible. We are committed to ensuring that every homeowner has access to a secure, functional, and aesthetically pleasing residence. By integrating superior craftsmanship with a dedication to cost-effectiveness, we render essential home improvements attainable across all budgetary considerations. Our team is devoted to supporting our community through meticulous repairs, guaranteeing expert maintenance. Consider Grace Management for all your home repair requirements today.

Pantry remodel.
Laundry room
Home remodel
Bedroom remodel
Bathroom remodel

+15

Avatar for Advanced Restoration & Waterproofing, LLC
Advanced Restoration & Waterproofing, LLC
4.7(
109
)
Sump Pump - Repair or Replace

Serving Greencastle, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1994

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Work performed as stated, on time and budget. Josh was very helpful with figuring out the scope of work that was compatible with our budget and achieve the desired results. No more standing water in our craw space. Sump pump replaced and reconfigured. Below grade drains placed at foundation with 4à ¢à  à  drain tubes with silt socks going to sump. Trench filled with pea gravel. Also placed around furnace platform area draining under foundation. Excellent service for a fair price. Their staff were very helpful and courteous. Kudos to Advanced for a job well done."
French drains
Drainage
Finished Basement
Interior Basement
Large Drainage Project

+16

Response time11 hrs
Recommended by93%of homeowners
Avatar for Indiana Well Company
Indiana Well Company
4.7(
7
)
Sump Pump - Repair or Replace

Serving Greencastle, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 2024

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"My sump pump was stuck on and running so I called the plumbers. They had it turned off and replaced the switch or wiring in the one day they were here. They were quick polite and well rounded. 5 out of 5 service all around."
Response time6 hrs
Response rate92%
Avatar for Max Haas Septic Sewer Grease
Max Haas Septic Sewer Grease
4.5(
71
)
Sump Pump - Repair or Replace

Serving Greencastle, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1923

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"We had been in our new home about a week and with the strong rains our septic system was flooded. We were new in the area and did not have Angie's list at the time. We called this company to see if we could get the tank pumped out and get an inspection done on the system since we had no idea what condition it was really in. When I placed the call I was told they would pump the tank out for $250 and do the inspection for another $250. I asked what was included in the inspection when they came out. I was told that the field would be located and that the distribution tank would be opened to make sure all of the fingers were working properly. If one or two of them were not working properly it would cut down substantially on the absorption rate. When the men arrived they were very courteous and worked extremely fast in locating and probing the septic field and pumping out the tank. They said the tank was in good shape and from the runback that it sounded okay. It didn't occur to me immediatly that the distribution tank was not opened to get a better idea of the condition of the fingers. I even purchased some of their chemical to keep it operating properly. I called back several days later and asked why this was not done. I was told that when they probed the field, if no water came to the surface, that there was no need to open the distribution tank. The 15 minutes and $250 for probing the ground really did not give me any more insight to the condition of the system than I had before. I felt that the money was not well spent since they did not do what they had promised to give me some assurance that everything was working properly."
Recommended by89%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 33
FAQs for sump pump repair or replace projects in Greencastle, IN

Sump pumps last about 10 years with proper maintenance and prompt repairs. Several factors can influence your sump pump’s lifespan, such as usage, environmental conditions, and installation. Premium sump pumps with heavy-duty motors and quality components tend to last longer than lower-cost models. Pedestal sump pumps usually last longer than submersible models since they’re not constantly exposed to water.

A basement French drain is a drainage system installed in basements or around a building’s foundation to redirect water and prevent flooding. This system features a trench with a perforated pipe that catches and transports water away. These systems can crack, freeze, or clog, potentially resulting in flooding or strain on your sump pump.

You can use a sump pump in your yard to minimize pooling water and landscape damage, but it’s best used in conjunction with other drainage systems. This can include French drains, trench drains, underground downspouts, and other equipment. Proper lawn care, such as soil aeration and native plants, also aids with drainage.

The Greencastle, IN homeowners’ guide to sump pump repair or replaces

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.