Get matched with top asphalt shingle roofing installers and replacers in Spencerport, NY

"Hired them based on recommendations and was pleasantly surprised. Melissa was such a big help with remodeling a 40 year old kitchen. They were here to do the job everyday until it was finished. The crew were all great. They did their job and did extra to help an old lady with little things not in their job description, I am sure. Jason was here to answer any questions I might have had. I was so glad that I chose them to do the job. Would recommend them to anyone."

"My consultation with Stellar was scheduled within a day, met with Patrick on 5/1/25. Time was taken to understand the process, everything that is involved and what my options were. Time was taken to listen to what we wanted/didn’t want and thorough explanation given of the entire process. On 5/2/25 Stellar contracting called to review details and confirm our choices. On 5/5/25 Stellar scheduling called and full installation scheduled for 5/9/25, completed 1 day! The crew and project manager, Cisco, were fabulous to deal with on the install day and even after. A link was provided where we could see pictures of the whole project as it happened. Cisco was readily available on install day and even after with questions and concerns. It was obvious that Cisco did care about the roof we were getting and took pride in the quality of the job that was done. The crew paid good attention to the clean up, there was a lot of debris all over the place. Looking forward to future business with them!"

"Everything went very well. Drew was great to work with and kept us informed every step of the way. Very clear communication, and was always checking in to be sure that the work being done was to our liking. He also followed up after the project was complete and sent the crew out to make some final adjustments and repairs when we saw something that needed to be fixed."

"We hired Buffalo’s Best Roofing for a full shingle roof replacement, and the experience was excellent from start to finish. The crew was professional, on time, and worked efficiently. They explained the process clearly, answered all our questions, and delivered exactly what was promised. The workmanship is top-notch, the cleanup was thorough, and the new roof looks great. Fair pricing and honest service—highly recommend Buffalo’s Best Roofing."

"Efficient, responsive and professional. Very good experience. Highly recommend."

"We had a leak in our basement that we thought was coming from our chimney. Marshalls came and determined that it wasn't the chimney, but a plumbing problem. They were prompt, professional, courteous and knowledgeable. We will definitely be using them again."

"Crew that did metal roof on garage left cigarette buts in yard and dog run. Branches were not cleaned up."

"He was orderly, clean and did excellent roof work and explained everything to me and answered any questions I had, I am very pleased with him. I would hire him again."

"Most overpriced roofing company around. It's laughable the quotes I was given by these guys vs. the other roofers I spoke with. Combine that with the fact I was warned about how they are quick to go the half-a** route when encountering a problem vs. actually doing the right thing and solving the problem. I've heard many accounts of this company just throwing up flashing and tar over a problem area of a roof instead of taking off the bad old roof and fixing it the correct way. People please get MANY MANY quotes for MANY different companies and you will quickly see that Proctor is a rip-off artist."

"Work was done professionally and efficiently, and the clean up was thorough. Would recommend."