Top-rated natural slate roofing installers and replacers.

Get matched with top natural slate roofing installers and replacers in Fishers Island, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Natural slate roofing installers and replacers in Fishers Island

Avatar for Four Seasons Roofing
Four Seasons Roofing
4.6(
150
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1983

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Bill Taylor, the President of the company, carefully surveyed the condition of the roof. His detailed, clear estimate addressed all of my concerns. The crew assigned to the project was efficient and courteous. The company is GAF certified, ensuring the warranty will be honored. I highly recommend Four Seasons Roofing."
GAF Preferred Contractor Badge
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+19

Response time2 days
Response rate100%
17 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for King Quality Roofing and Siding
King Quality Roofing and Siding
4.5(
20
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1988

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

King Quality Roofing and Siding is proud to be a locally owned and operated business that has been serving the community since 1988! With years of experience and unmatched expertise, we can help with any and all of your roofing and siding needs. Since opening our doors we have built our business on providing customers with the highest quality products and craftsmanship, at a fair price. You can count on our team to be timely, tidy, and when the job is done, that you will be 100% satisfied with the work completed. Let us show you the King Quality difference, get in touch today!

North Babylon Home After
North Babylon Home Before
Jeff and Crew
Beach house Shake Shingles
Beach house Shake Shingles

+1

Response time1 day
1148 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by80%of homeowners
Avatar for D & S Roofing Corp
D & S Roofing Corp
4.8(
174
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1939

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Dominick and his crew was there on time to install new roof skylight and gutters on 3/25/24 everything went well from beginning to end D&S had foreman on the job the all time they cleaned everything up and Dominick checked in during the day I would recommend them to any one looking to get a new roof or any other services they offer"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+2

Recommended by98%of homeowners
Avatar for Royal Roofing & Siding Brooklyn
Royal Roofing & Siding Brooklyn
4.7(
211
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1993

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I recently had my shingle roof replaced by Royal Roofing & Siding, and I couldn’t be happier with the results. The team was professional, courteous, and completed the project on schedule. They took the time to explain the different shingle options and made sure everything was installed properly. The new roof looks fantastic and has completely improved the appearance of my home. The crew cleaned up thoroughly after the job, and the entire experience was stress-free. If you’re looking for a trustworthy roofing company for a shingle roof replacement, I highly recommend Royal Roofing & Siding."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+41

Response time1 day
Response rate100%
6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Vandelay Contracting Corp.
Vandelay Contracting Corp.
4.3(
101
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2005

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"To many other roofers in the NYC Greater region- take note, Vandelay has you beat by quite a bit in terms of understanding a client and the particular needs of the job.  I went through a half dozen estimates and site visits; Vandelay and one other contractor where the only ones who were able to produce a timely, considered estimate.  And this was in the down season!
Regarding the job itself.  It presented several unknowns that Bob and his crew were able to work through and develop solutions to in a timely manner.  The demo went smoothly as well as the new installs and final flashing and chalking details.  At this point, the new roof has been through several storms and seems to be doing quite well.  If there is a problem, Bob seems more that capable to address per the contract, which I certainly appreciate.
Its clear he has a lot of experience doing what he knows, and doing it well.  He has good intuition and understanding of a job and the individuals and characters that might be involved, and how to work with them effectively (including myself likely :)
I've been through a couple of roof jobs at this point on various structures, and felt confident with Bob throughout the job; there were no instances that I felt were be minimized or neglected.  And importantly for a Condo building in NYC, Bob's crew made sure that they premise was CLEANER than when they left which is often a big deal with testy unit owners.
Overall, very pleased with both the estimation process, keeping on budget and timeframe and delivering a sound roof in material and craftmanship.  Highly recommended.


"
30 Year Timberline
30 Year Timberline
30 Year Timberline
Recommended by93%of homeowners
Avatar for County Roofing Systems
County Roofing Systems
4.6(
19
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1987

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"PHENOMENAL! I wanted to have a new layer of shingles placed on my roof because I had a leak and only one layer on my roof and I was told I could have up to three layers. I was only having the problem with a leak on my roof during the winter. County Roofing Systems inspected my home and said they would not recommend doing another layer. They recommended striping the roof so they could install ice shield and inspect the plywood panels on my roof. It turned out to be the best advice, because I did not have ice shield on my existing roof and two of my panels needed to be replaced. If I had just done another layer I would have had the same leaking problem. I appreciate the good advice. My roof looks great and is leak free. County Roofing Systems did a great job. Very Clean & Neat! Very Professional!"
Additional Photos
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Thermosidingcorp
5.0(
20
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Fishers Island, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1977

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Unbelievably well...the crew was so tedious about the job and neat as well. When the old roof came off and they left for the day you would have never known they were here except for their equipment in the yard. They actually cleaned the roof dust off of my neighbors houses before they left for the day. And Pete the owner never took a dollare until the work was done. That is Confidence in your work!!!! And trust in people...The finished product looks magnificent! I have already referred him to 3 people and will continue to sing the praises of Thermo Siding Corp. Thank you! Also, the best price around for such exceptional work!"
Recommended by100%of homeowners
...
Showing 1-10 of 205
FAQs for natural slate roofing installation and replacement projects in Fishers Island, NY

A slate roof features thin tiles of natural stone installed over a solid deck and underlayment. Formed under intense heat and pressure, slate is exceptionally durable and delivers a distinctive, high-end look. Because the material weighs far more than asphalt, most homes need added structural support before installation. 

While upfront costs are higher and routine inspections are a must, many homeowners choose slate for its unmatched longevity and curb appeal.

Slate stands out for its 50- to 200-year life span, low maintenance, and classic aesthetic. It’s fire-resistant, energy-efficient, and often boosts resale value. 

On the flip side, slate runs far more per square foot than asphalt, weighs up to four times as much, and demands a contractor who specializes in the material. Tiles can crack on impact, and repairs cost more because the work is slow and precise. If your budget and structure can handle it, slate delivers top-tier performance for generations.

Natural and synthetic slate aim for a premium, stone-like appearance, whereas asphalt focuses on affordability. Real slate runs $10 to $30 per square foot installed and lasts up to 200 years; synthetic slate costs $10 to $15 and tops out at 50 to 100 years. 

Standard asphalt averages $3 to $8 per square foot and needs replacement every 20 to 30 years. If you want the slate look without the full price tag—or extra roof weight—synthetic is a solid middle ground.

With routine inspections and prompt repairs, a natural slate roof can last well beyond 100 years; some hard-slate installations reach the 200-year mark. Soft slate falls in the 50- to 125-year range, and synthetic products last 50 to 100 years. 

Remember, flashing, fasteners, and the underlying structure may need attention sooner than the stone itself. Severe hail or fallen limbs can also shorten life span, so schedule periodic checkups with a slate-qualified roofer.

If you plan to stay in your home long term—or want a standout selling point—slate delivers strong value. Although installation costs are high, owners often recoup 60% to 70% at resale and enjoy lower replacement cycles than asphalt. The stone’s durability, energy efficiency, and timeless curb appeal also appeal to eco-conscious buyers because fewer roofs end up in landfills. Just be sure your framing can handle the weight and that you budget for occasional specialty repairs.

Skip the DIY climb if you have a slate roof. Slate may be tough against the weather, but a single misplaced step can crack a tile and create a leak path. The surface also turns slick when wet, upping the risk of injury. Professional crews use staging and hook ladders that spread weight across multiple slates, protecting both the roof and the worker. To inspect or repair slate, call a roofer who specializes in the material.

The Fishers Island, NY homeowners’ guide to natural slate roofing installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.