Top-rated small animal pest control pros.

Get matched with top small animal pest control pros in New Buffalo, MI

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Small animal pest control pros in New Buffalo

Avatar for Lakeshore Wildlife

Lakeshore Wildlife

231 S. Taylor St.
5.00(
8
)
•Approved Pro

Lakeshore Wildlife

231 S. Taylor St.
5.00(
8
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
82 local quotes requested
3 years of experience

We are a locally owned and operated Nuisance Wildlife Control Company that values honesty and integrity, and treats your home as if it were our own. We offer a variety of services that are customization to each individual project. You will find us to be competitively priced, paying close attention to the details of each and every project that we are involved with. We look forward to building lasting relationships, and guarantee your satisfaction!

"They were very helpful and persistent."

Marjorie R on July 2025

We are a locally owned and operated Nuisance Wildlife Control Company that values honesty and integrity, and treats your home as if it were our own. We offer a variety of services that are customization to each individual project. You will find us to be competitively priced, paying close attention to the details of each and every project that we are involved with. We look forward to building lasting relationships, and guarantee your satisfaction!

"They were very helpful and persistent."

Marjorie R on July 2025

Varment Guard Wildlife Services

271 S CROSS ST
4.80(
639
)

Varment Guard Wildlife Services

271 S CROSS ST
4.80(
639
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers

If you’re looking for humane and efficient wild animal removal services, you’ve come to the right place. Varment Guard Wildlife Services was founded in 1983 and has been passionate about delivering environmentally conscious and safe wildlife pest removal services ever since. From rowdy raccoons to ornery opossums to damaging deer, bats, moles, or groundhogs, we have experience solving and preventing many types of wildlife challenges. We offer wild animal removal services to Minnesota, Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and parts of Kentucky and Wisconsin. So, if you’re wondering, where can I find quality wildlife services near me? Look no further. Varment Guard has you covered.

"ABSOLUTELY WORTHLESS! Spent $500 to have raccoons captured and removed from the attic at one of our rentals. Mama decided to next and give birth to three young predators. Technician set 3 traps, for 3 weeks. Nada. We show up at 8p on a Friday night. Set one trap that we brought and viola' by 5a the next morning...a raccoon. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY!"

Melissa R on August 2022

If you’re looking for humane and efficient wild animal removal services, you’ve come to the right place. Varment Guard Wildlife Services was founded in 1983 and has been passionate about delivering environmentally conscious and safe wildlife pest removal services ever since. From rowdy raccoons to ornery opossums to damaging deer, bats, moles, or groundhogs, we have experience solving and preventing many types of wildlife challenges. We offer wild animal removal services to Minnesota, Michigan, Indiana, Illinois, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and parts of Kentucky and Wisconsin. So, if you’re wondering, where can I find quality wildlife services near me? Look no further. Varment Guard has you covered.

"ABSOLUTELY WORTHLESS! Spent $500 to have raccoons captured and removed from the attic at one of our rentals. Mama decided to next and give birth to three young predators. Technician set 3 traps, for 3 weeks. Nada. We show up at 8p on a Friday night. Set one trap that we brought and viola' by 5a the next morning...a raccoon. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY!"

Melissa R on August 2022

Michigan Animal Control LLC

4210 E Hayes Rd
No reviews yet

Michigan Animal Control LLC

4210 E Hayes Rd
No reviews yet
30 years of experience

We have up to 9 people that can respond to an sized animal emergency, from bats to buffalo- we have experience in any regional or exitic wildlife. We work with insurance companies and can even work out a payment plan if needed. No reasonable or rational proposals are generally refused.

We have up to 9 people that can respond to an sized animal emergency, from bats to buffalo- we have experience in any regional or exitic wildlife. We work with insurance companies and can even work out a payment plan if needed. No reasonable or rational proposals are generally refused.

Eco Pest Control

3560 Pine Grove
4.00(
1
)

Eco Pest Control

3560 Pine Grove
4.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Our mission is to exceed customer expectations by providing exceptional pest control service at an affordable price using the latest and safest technology in an environmentally responsible way.

Our mission is to exceed customer expectations by providing exceptional pest control service at an affordable price using the latest and safest technology in an environmentally responsible way.

Master Wildlife Control

69121 Gateway Dr
No reviews yet

Master Wildlife Control

69121 Gateway Dr
No reviews yet

Welcome to Master Wildlife Control. We are licensed and specialize in the humane removal of all nuisance animals. Such as, raccoons, groundhogs, beavers, rats, coyotes, squirrels, skunks, and much more. Master Wildlife Control also performs emergency services, and remediation services. It is our responsibility to not only eliminate the unwanted pest, but restore and fix any damage they have caused! Master Wildlife Control looks forward to earning your business!

Welcome to Master Wildlife Control. We are licensed and specialize in the humane removal of all nuisance animals. Such as, raccoons, groundhogs, beavers, rats, coyotes, squirrels, skunks, and much more. Master Wildlife Control also performs emergency services, and remediation services. It is our responsibility to not only eliminate the unwanted pest, but restore and fix any damage they have caused! Master Wildlife Control looks forward to earning your business!

CLASSIC CARPET CARE AND RESTORATION

101 W C St
No reviews yet

CLASSIC CARPET CARE AND RESTORATION

101 W C St
No reviews yet
37 years of experience

Water Damage,Flood Damage, Fire Damage,Mold remediation, Carpet cleaning

Water Damage,Flood Damage, Fire Damage,Mold remediation, Carpet cleaning

Aaron's Nuisance Animal Control

P.O. Box 644
4.89(
28
)

Aaron's Nuisance Animal Control

P.O. Box 644
4.89(
28
)
Customers say: Quick response
26 years of experience

We are available after hours and weekends for emergencies and appointments. We are a family owned and operated company since 1999 serving Michigan. We handle all wildlife issues including repairing damage they cause.

"During the night we heard a scratching/clawing sound on exterior of house. In morning we saw obvious claw marks and part of the soffit torn. W called Aaron's and they said they would be over that afternoon. When tey arrived they surveyed the damage and made other observations and concluded that the intruder was a racoon. They proceeded to set a baited trap and told us to call them - even in the middle of the night - if we heard more noises or the trap was tripped. In the morning we saw that the trap had captured the racoon but he was still alive. We contacted Aaron's and they came out promptly to remove a very LARGE male racoon who put up quite a fight while he was being snared. This was a very positive experience dealing with Aaron's - from time to our initial call to removal of animal was just over 24 hours. These people are very knowledgeable about what type of trap to use and the appropriate bait and very professional. I highly recommend them."

Lawrence C on May 2018

We are available after hours and weekends for emergencies and appointments. We are a family owned and operated company since 1999 serving Michigan. We handle all wildlife issues including repairing damage they cause.

"During the night we heard a scratching/clawing sound on exterior of house. In morning we saw obvious claw marks and part of the soffit torn. W called Aaron's and they said they would be over that afternoon. When tey arrived they surveyed the damage and made other observations and concluded that the intruder was a racoon. They proceeded to set a baited trap and told us to call them - even in the middle of the night - if we heard more noises or the trap was tripped. In the morning we saw that the trap had captured the racoon but he was still alive. We contacted Aaron's and they came out promptly to remove a very LARGE male racoon who put up quite a fight while he was being snared. This was a very positive experience dealing with Aaron's - from time to our initial call to removal of animal was just over 24 hours. These people are very knowledgeable about what type of trap to use and the appropriate bait and very professional. I highly recommend them."

Lawrence C on May 2018

City Woods Wildlife Removal

12867 Horning Rd
No reviews yet

City Woods Wildlife Removal

12867 Horning Rd
No reviews yet
2 years of experience

The Best Owner Operated Wildlife Removal Company Serving Pure Michigan. Call us today to discuss your wildlife problems at 586-300-3222 We are open 24 hours a day 7 days a week and offer emergency services 4pm-8am. Schedule an appointment by texting our live office members 24/7 or give us a call and we will send a seasoned wildlife removal operator to inspect and propose a plan to fix your problems, possibly same day! At City Woods Wildlife Removal your not just another invoice number. We provide world class customer service around the clock to better serve you in protecting your home or property. We are passionate about what we do and would love to work for you.

The Best Owner Operated Wildlife Removal Company Serving Pure Michigan. Call us today to discuss your wildlife problems at 586-300-3222 We are open 24 hours a day 7 days a week and offer emergency services 4pm-8am. Schedule an appointment by texting our live office members 24/7 or give us a call and we will send a seasoned wildlife removal operator to inspect and propose a plan to fix your problems, possibly same day! At City Woods Wildlife Removal your not just another invoice number. We provide world class customer service around the clock to better serve you in protecting your home or property. We are passionate about what we do and would love to work for you.

Arrow Services Inc

211 S Dixie Way
4.65(
31
)

Arrow Services Inc

211 S Dixie Way
4.65(
31
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

More than 50 years of Dedicated Pest Management Service Arrow Services, Inc. was founded in October of 1958 by Everett D. Colvin. Arrow Services is a family owned company that started in a small local town in Plymouth, Indiana and now has grown into one of the largest pest control agencies in the Midwest. Today Arrow is currently serving the level of operations in Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Illinois with conveniently located offices in each district. Arrow Services strives to provide professionalism in all aspects of the pest control industry. All of Arrow personnel are trained and equipped with the newest and most up to date equipment and control techniques available by keeping the environment in mind. Arrow has implemented a continuous employee learning program designed to educate the entire staff. Direct contact with universities, leading state agencies, chemical companies, pest control suppliers, plus seminars and conventions are combined with the single Arrow goal; to provide the best possible pest control management available at a fair price. Check out our website for special offers and promotions: www.arrowpestcontrol.com

More than 50 years of Dedicated Pest Management Service Arrow Services, Inc. was founded in October of 1958 by Everett D. Colvin. Arrow Services is a family owned company that started in a small local town in Plymouth, Indiana and now has grown into one of the largest pest control agencies in the Midwest. Today Arrow is currently serving the level of operations in Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Illinois with conveniently located offices in each district. Arrow Services strives to provide professionalism in all aspects of the pest control industry. All of Arrow personnel are trained and equipped with the newest and most up to date equipment and control techniques available by keeping the environment in mind. Arrow has implemented a continuous employee learning program designed to educate the entire staff. Direct contact with universities, leading state agencies, chemical companies, pest control suppliers, plus seminars and conventions are combined with the single Arrow goal; to provide the best possible pest control management available at a fair price. Check out our website for special offers and promotions: www.arrowpestcontrol.com

Constant Pest Management

123 E Lima St
No reviews yet

Constant Pest Management

123 E Lima St
No reviews yet

Constant Pest Management exists to serve others. It is our priority to meet the pest control needs of the community in a financially reasonable and effective manner. We utilize research backed, state of the art, Eco-Friendly methods to treat homes, apartments and hotels for Bed Bugs in half the time and at half the price of traditional heat treatment methods. Constant Pest Management technicians receive the most comprehensive, up-to-date training and are state licensed to perform pest control. Our technicians have the knowledge and expertise to rid your home of over 100 common household pests. We can exterminate your pests with discretion and efficiency. If you feel embarrassed about having an exterminator van in your driveway, our unmarked vehicles can save you from worrying about others knowing that you have a pest problem, while still getting you the pest control you need.

Constant Pest Management exists to serve others. It is our priority to meet the pest control needs of the community in a financially reasonable and effective manner. We utilize research backed, state of the art, Eco-Friendly methods to treat homes, apartments and hotels for Bed Bugs in half the time and at half the price of traditional heat treatment methods. Constant Pest Management technicians receive the most comprehensive, up-to-date training and are state licensed to perform pest control. Our technicians have the knowledge and expertise to rid your home of over 100 common household pests. We can exterminate your pests with discretion and efficiency. If you feel embarrassed about having an exterminator van in your driveway, our unmarked vehicles can save you from worrying about others knowing that you have a pest problem, while still getting you the pest control you need.

Showing 1-10 of 25
FAQs for small animal pest control service projects in New Buffalo, MI

Self-removal attempts using store-bought traps can cost $50, but require personal time investment and knowledge of proper handling techniques. While DIY methods might work for isolated cases, professionals bring expertise in identifying all entry points, implementing effective deterrents, and safely handling wildlife. 

Consider your comfort level with wildlife management and the potential health risks—armadillos can carry disease—before deciding between professional services or personal intervention.

Most homeowners see initial results within two to five days after professional trap placement, particularly with single-animal situations. However, multiple factors can extend this timeline, including the number of animals present, weather conditions affecting activity patterns, and the complexity of your property layout. 

Properties with established armadillo populations might require one to two weeks of active trapping. Discuss realistic timeframes with your wildlife specialist during the initial consultation to set appropriate expectations.

Filling and repairing burrows adds $75 to $110 per hole to your total project cost. While some comprehensive service packages include minor repairs, extensive landscape restoration requires a separate payment. 

These repair costs cover materials like topsoil, sod, or concrete patching compounds, plus the labor to properly restore the damaged areas. Before finalizing any service agreement, clarify exactly which repair services are included and which will incur additional charges.

While armadillos remain active throughout the year in many regions, scheduling removal during less busy seasons for wildlife control companies might secure slightly better rates. Fall and winter months often see reduced demand for these services, potentially offering more scheduling flexibility and competitive pricing. 

However, the most cost-effective approach is addressing armadillo issues promptly when first noticed, regardless of season, as delaying can lead to more extensive damage and higher ultimate costs.

The New Buffalo, MI homeowners’ guide to small animal pest control services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles
  • Wasp nest hanging under roof

    Professional wasp nest removal ensures safe and effective treatment, reducing the risk of stings. Costs vary based on factors like nest size, location, and accessibility, with harder-to-reach nests often requiring specialized removal.

  • mosquito control professional spraying grass in protective suit

    Discover how much mosquito control costs based on key factors such as yard size, service frequency, treatment method, and more with our detailed guide.

  • A person sprays pesticide on a carpet

    HomeAdvisor's expert guide to the cost of carpet beetle extermination ensures you know how much you'll pay based on area, treatment frequency, method, and more.