Top-rated asphalt shingle roofing repairers.

Get matched with top asphalt shingle roofing repairers in Paoli, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Asphalt shingle roofing repairers in Paoli

Avatar for McCarty Roofing & Restoration

McCarty Roofing & Restoration

4.93(
14
)
•Approved Pro

McCarty Roofing & Restoration

4.93(
14
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
26 local quotes requested

With over 25 years of experience McCarty Roofing & Restoration is a locally owned & operated company in Lawrence County, Indiana. We specialize in roofing, siding, & gutter installation, along with a wide variety of other services. •Serving South Central Indiana •Fully Insured

"Everything went great and I absolutely recommend this company!!"

Dennis J on January 2023

With over 25 years of experience McCarty Roofing & Restoration is a locally owned & operated company in Lawrence County, Indiana. We specialize in roofing, siding, & gutter installation, along with a wide variety of other services. •Serving South Central Indiana •Fully Insured

"Everything went great and I absolutely recommend this company!!"

Dennis J on January 2023

Avatar for Golden Nails Construction General Contractor

Golden Nails Construction General Contractor

20299 George Lane
3.87(
30
)
•Approved Pro

Golden Nails Construction General Contractor

20299 George Lane
3.87(
30
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
28 local quotes requested
24 years of experience

Golden Nails Construction General Contractor brings an unmatched commitment to excellence to your Yard and landscaping projects. We have over 10 years experience delivering unsurpassed professionalism, expertise, and value. We take pride in providing our customers with personalized customer service, the highest industry standards, and top quality workmanship. References available upon request. Give us a call today!

"I hired Golden Nails to add 600 sq. feet to my house including a complete bathroom addition and kitchen remodel/redo. They did a great job and were extremely thorough!! The end result was absolutely stunning - and I definitely appreciate that Golden Nails stayed in touch throughout the project to ensure things were getting done completely and accurately. Great job!!! "

Carey A on July 2025

Golden Nails Construction General Contractor brings an unmatched commitment to excellence to your Yard and landscaping projects. We have over 10 years experience delivering unsurpassed professionalism, expertise, and value. We take pride in providing our customers with personalized customer service, the highest industry standards, and top quality workmanship. References available upon request. Give us a call today!

"I hired Golden Nails to add 600 sq. feet to my house including a complete bathroom addition and kitchen remodel/redo. They did a great job and were extremely thorough!! The end result was absolutely stunning - and I definitely appreciate that Golden Nails stayed in touch throughout the project to ensure things were getting done completely and accurately. Great job!!! "

Carey A on July 2025

Magnus Builders

1914 Palatka Road
New on HomeAdvisorNew on HomeAdvisor
•Approved Pro

Magnus Builders

1914 Palatka Road
New on HomeAdvisorNew on HomeAdvisor
•Approved Pro
2025 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Magnus Builders, LLC is a full-service residential remodeling company based in Louisville, Kentucky. Specializing in a wide range of home improvement services, including kitchen and bathroom remodeling, home additions, roofing, siding replacement and repair, gutter installation and repair, and interior/exterior painting. With a focus on quality craftsmanship and customer satisfaction, Magnus Builders, LLC helps homeowners transform their living spaces, from minor updates to major renovations.

Magnus Builders, LLC is a full-service residential remodeling company based in Louisville, Kentucky. Specializing in a wide range of home improvement services, including kitchen and bathroom remodeling, home additions, roofing, siding replacement and repair, gutter installation and repair, and interior/exterior painting. With a focus on quality craftsmanship and customer satisfaction, Magnus Builders, LLC helps homeowners transform their living spaces, from minor updates to major renovations.

Avatar for The KING's Mitigator

The KING's Mitigator

1255 Country Side Lane
4.97(
33
)
•Approved Pro

The KING's Mitigator

1255 Country Side Lane
4.97(
33
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
1479 local quotes requested

Welcome to The KING's Mitigator, where the protection and enhancement of your home reign supreme. Specializing in roofing, siding, gutters, and remediation services, we are dedicated to preserving the integrity and beauty of your residence. At The KING's Mitigator, we understand that your home is your castle. That’s why we offer comprehensive solutions tailored to withstand the elements and the test of time. Whether you're in need of a sturdy new roof, stylish siding, reliable gutters, or expert remediation services, our skilled team is equipped to deliver top-quality craftsmanship and unparalleled customer service. Trust us to mitigate any challenge with royal precision and make your home a fortress of comfort and safety. Choose The KING's Mitigator—where quality meets royalty.

"Needed to get some damaged vinyl siding replaced after a bad hail storm. Sam came out literally 25 minutes after my initial post on Angie's. After hearing sam say that they are here to help me and not to earn some ridiculous huge margin like the other guys, that really swayed my choice on who to go with. The price and quality of work definitely reflected that. All the pieces were replaced and they even took care of some extra pieces that had holes in it from the previous home owner. I will be calling this company back to do more work on my home in the future. Highly recommend using them for your exterior needs. They have gained my business!"

Daniel M on August 2025

Welcome to The KING's Mitigator, where the protection and enhancement of your home reign supreme. Specializing in roofing, siding, gutters, and remediation services, we are dedicated to preserving the integrity and beauty of your residence. At The KING's Mitigator, we understand that your home is your castle. That’s why we offer comprehensive solutions tailored to withstand the elements and the test of time. Whether you're in need of a sturdy new roof, stylish siding, reliable gutters, or expert remediation services, our skilled team is equipped to deliver top-quality craftsmanship and unparalleled customer service. Trust us to mitigate any challenge with royal precision and make your home a fortress of comfort and safety. Choose The KING's Mitigator—where quality meets royalty.

"Needed to get some damaged vinyl siding replaced after a bad hail storm. Sam came out literally 25 minutes after my initial post on Angie's. After hearing sam say that they are here to help me and not to earn some ridiculous huge margin like the other guys, that really swayed my choice on who to go with. The price and quality of work definitely reflected that. All the pieces were replaced and they even took care of some extra pieces that had holes in it from the previous home owner. I will be calling this company back to do more work on my home in the future. Highly recommend using them for your exterior needs. They have gained my business!"

Daniel M on August 2025

Two Brothers Construction

No reviews yet

Two Brothers Construction

No reviews yet

Leave It To Beaver Roofing

No reviews yet

Leave It To Beaver Roofing

No reviews yet

We specialize in both commercial and residential roofing, small local owned and operated company. We have been in business for 3 years, but our owner has over 10 years experience in the roofing industry! Asphalt shingles TPO

We specialize in both commercial and residential roofing, small local owned and operated company. We have been in business for 3 years, but our owner has over 10 years experience in the roofing industry! Asphalt shingles TPO

Brave Restoration

205 N Main Street
5.00(
4
)

Brave Restoration

205 N Main Street
5.00(
4
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Brave Restoration is a small company located in Southern Indiana specializing in Water Damage, Roofing, Storm Damage, Mold Restoration, Foundation Repair, Siding Repair and more. We work with Insurance adjusters to try to cover the majority of your repair costs and we also offer 100% financing when insurance isn't involved. Reach out to us today.

"Well done...thank u"

Diana L on April 2024

Brave Restoration is a small company located in Southern Indiana specializing in Water Damage, Roofing, Storm Damage, Mold Restoration, Foundation Repair, Siding Repair and more. We work with Insurance adjusters to try to cover the majority of your repair costs and we also offer 100% financing when insurance isn't involved. Reach out to us today.

"Well done...thank u"

Diana L on April 2024

Randy Devary

1205 S East St
1.00(
2
)

Randy Devary

1205 S East St
1.00(
2
)
Free onsite estimate

Owner operated. No subs. Charges determined by the job. No travel charges.

Owner operated. No subs. Charges determined by the job. No travel charges.

Cote Construction

1435 W. Main St.
No reviews yet

Cote Construction

1435 W. Main St.
No reviews yet
21 years of experience

Full service General Contractor with a focus on Insurance Restoration services. Preferred contractor of most major insurance companies. Certified Water Restoration contractor.

Full service General Contractor with a focus on Insurance Restoration services. Preferred contractor of most major insurance companies. Certified Water Restoration contractor.

Equity Builders Roofing

3211 N Obrien Pl
3.33(
3
)

Equity Builders Roofing

3211 N Obrien Pl
3.33(
3
)
41 years of experience

Call us for your storm damage needs. We offer free estimates and will work directly with your insurance company.

"It was a very bad experience. The work took 16 months to complete. There was almost no communication. No answer to phone messages, emails or texts. Final invoice was much greater than original estimate. The additional work was completed without any communication to me ( the homeowner)."

Ruth Ann M on November 2022

Call us for your storm damage needs. We offer free estimates and will work directly with your insurance company.

"It was a very bad experience. The work took 16 months to complete. There was almost no communication. No answer to phone messages, emails or texts. Final invoice was much greater than original estimate. The additional work was completed without any communication to me ( the homeowner)."

Ruth Ann M on November 2022

...
Showing 1-10 of 112
FAQs for asphalt shingle roofing repair projects in Paoli, IN

Asphalt shingles last 15 to 30 years, although premium products can reach the 50-year mark. The actual lifespan hinges on climate, material quality, proper installation, ventilation, and consistent maintenance. Scheduling annual inspections, replacing damaged shingles promptly, and keeping gutters clear all extend service life and help your roof protect the rest of the house.

Repairing your asphalt shingles preserves the integrity of your roof by addressing minor, localized damage. In cases where damage is confined, applying roofing sealant beneath and over the affected area restores performance and prevents further issues. Maintaining these repairs upholds durability and forestalls deterioration. When damage is extensive or persistent, full roof replacement becomes necessary. A professional inspection confirms the ideal course of action.

Replacing individual shingles is a valid solution when only isolated sections of the roof are damaged. Asphalt shingles, as well as wooden shakes, slate, or clay roofing tiles, are engineered for individual replacement, which can be achieved by applying roofing sealant beneath and over the damaged section to restore functionality. When damage extends over a larger area or many shingles are compromised, complete roof replacement becomes necessary. A professional roofer will assess the situation and confirm the optimal repair method.

The Paoli, IN homeowners’ guide to asphalt shingle roofing repairs

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles
  • A farmhouse in Autumn

    Discover how much roof replacement costs in Michigan based on the price of materials, labor, permits, and inspections with our comprehensive cost guide.

  • Roofing contractor replacing the old shingles

    Discover how roof pitch, shape, labor, and materials influence roof replacement costs with our guide to roof replacement costs in New Jersey.

  • Two workers replacing broken tiles

    HomeAdvisor's Texas roof replacement guide explores how much it costs to replace a roof in Texas. Find out how much you'll spend to replace your roof by type, pitch, and location.

  • roof view of residential home in California

    HomeAdvisor’s California Roof Cost Guide covers the cost of a new roof in California, based on the city, roof size, and material. Use our guide to estimate your roof replacement cost in California.

  • roof view of residential home in florida

    HomeAdvisor’s Florida Roof Cost Guide covers the average roof replacement cost in Florida, based on the city, roof size, and material. Use our guide to estimate your Florida roof replacement cost

  • asphalt shingle roof on house

    Explore shingle roof replacement costs and how key factors like roof size, shingle type, and labor impact the total cost of your roofing project.