Top-rated wood shake or composite roofing installers and replacers.

Get matched with top wood shake or composite roofing installers and replacers in Poynette, WI

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Top-Rated Wood shake or composite roofing installers and replacers in Poynette - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Frey Construction & Home Improvement, LLC
Frey Construction & Home Improvement, LLC
4.6(
209
)
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 1995

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"We needed to replace our home roof & used Frey Construction, because of their reputation. We were very pleased. So pleased, that we used them again for several large projects with our rental properties. Scott & his employees are very respectful & professional. Excellent communication & great response time to any of our questions or concerns. We would highly recommend Frey Construction!"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+15

Response time1 day
Response rate100%
6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Metal Roofs Direct
Metal Roofs Direct
5.0(
12
)
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

In business since 2010

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Chad and his crew were absolutely amazing. From the first sales call, until the last nail of completion, I knew we could count on him. He had been referred, and we immediately felt comfortable with Chad, as he patiently explained the value in a significant undertaking - this roof will be there another 200 years, the quality is just that good! The work was on-time, professional, and the crew did a great job of cleaning up when they are done. We plan to use Metal Roofs Direct for other roofs when the time comes!"
Door County Roofs
Randolph Church
Door County Roofs
Door County Roofs
Door County Roofs

+16

6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by85%of homeowners
Avatar for Diaz Roofing Co LLC
Diaz Roofing Co LLC
4.6(
45
)
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1994

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Amazing! He said they could do our project in 3 weeks, and 2 1/2 weeks later, he called and said we are expecting rain the next week, and they could get our roof done that weekend, so they delivered the shingles on Saturday, and tore off the old roof on Sunday and replace it that same day. We weren't even home. When we got home, you couldn't even tell that anyone had been there, except that we had our new roof. Mr. Diaz was extremely professional!"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Response time10 mins
Response rate100%
5 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Overhead Solutions
Overhead Solutions
4.5(
38
)
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

In business since 2010

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"After talking to my furnace/heating Company, I decided that my idea to have the chimney taken out and roof patched was overkill ---not going with Overhead Solutions had nothing to do with the quote or speed of their response. They were very good at both !!"
Paul Collins - Owner
Paul Collins and family
Lisa Bauer  - Accounts Manager
Dustin Marks - New Business Manager
Paul Collins - Owner

+20

Response time6 hrs
Recommended by96%of homeowners
Infinity Exteriors
New to Angi
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

In business since 1997

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

At Infinity Exteriors, we set ourselves apart through our unwavering commitment to quality, craftsmanship, and customer satisfaction. Our comprehensive services include roofing, siding, windows, and gutters, all delivered with meticulous attention to detail. Our team consists of seasoned Project Advisors, Managers, and Installers who bring years of industry experience, training, and a dedication to high standards, ensuring every project meets our strict quality guidelines. \n

6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for RMZ Enterprises, LLC
RMZ Enterprises, LLC
4.8(
27
)
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

In business since 1988

"It went very well. We had some issues with our roof leaking and couldn't find the source or correct the problem. It is an older roof with a few layers of shingles, but we can't afford to replace it quite yet. The owner and one of his employees stopped by and did a thorough inspection of the roof for us and found the main problem. They suggested a quick and dirty fix to immediately remedy the problem until we could afford to replace the roofing. Overall, helpful advice and a great job finding the issue.
"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+100

Recommended by90%of homeowners
Avatar for Metal Roofing Systems
Metal Roofing Systems
4.5(
53
)
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

In business since 1990

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Again, this is in reference to the quote process. We have gone with another vendor for the roof replacement. Salesman was knowledgeable, prompt, and courteous. I think the information he gave about his product to be correct, and I believe his product is very good. The only information I might question is that he claimed his aluminum shingles have the highest fire rating, but this usually isn't the case since aluminum softens starting about 400F. None-the-less, I'm certain it is much more fire resistant than any conventional shingle. But the sales was low-key, high pressure. Very slick presentation. Stressed all the things wrong with the roof (said it needed replacement very soon and had lots of problems) as well as being complex. Multiple times talked about how heavy the existing shingles were (as if the roof wasn't designed for asphalt shingles). Gave a quote of about $60+K, but immediately offered 10% off if we maintain a sign on our front lawn for several weeks and another 10% if they could do the roof at their convenience, bring the cost to $50+K. If decking needed to be replaced, they'd do it for $75 per sheet in addition to the contract price. Finally, said the discounts were only good about 3 days. Seems like the $50K price is the real price, with a 10% extra for rush jobs. The salesman job seems to want to make an offer and try to get you to commit quick. At the beginning of the presentation, he even asked if we had already talked to other companies (we hadn't). Possibly if we had, he might have taken a different tact. Their web site has a "Sign up for a chance for a free roof". People that buy a roof from this company, are not only paying for their own roof, but for the company's PR as well. Bringing in other companies for quotes, we were told the roof is in good shape (should be replaced in the next few years), and that it would be simple installation. Other quotes came in at the $29K to $31K. Decking sheets were priced at $45 to $60. I seriously think Metal Roofing Systems will provide a good product, and professional installation. But be certain to do your own research and get a few quotes for your job."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+14

Recommended by90%of homeowners
Avatar for Watry Homes LLC
Watry Homes LLC
4.8(
403
)
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

In business since 1994

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"

After reading Watry Homes reviews on this site, we contacted them in March. I had reached the point where I no longer wanted to maintain the house, and after researching siding options and speaking to other home owners, was seeking a contractor to install what I believed was the best siding solution, Hardy Plank. It was our intention to have the work done before the summer months, to avoid the disruption and scheduling conflicts which inevitably happen in high season.

Scott Watry came out and inspected/measured the house on March 17, presented window options and gave an overview of the process. Within a week we had an estimate and we gave him the commitment assuming the work would begin as soon as materials were received within a few weeks. The project did not get underway, however, until June 4th, the day I was leaving for two weeks of travel. My wife provided daily updates in my absence, and glowing reviews of Scott's workers, specifically, Paul and Rob who came in and installed the windows and doors. I met these guys later and they are true professionals who pay close attention to detail. The siders were also efficient and meticulous in their work, and cleaned up every day. The crew had a few guys, but Roberto, who appeared to be their lead, was very responsive to every question or request, and went out of his way to be accommodating. Splattered paint on a portion of our patio and sill appeared to be their only misstep.

In the end, we have a job that met our expectations in terms of quality, fit and finish. It was the punch list of several small items and requests which was emailed to Scott in mid-June that made the final conclusion of the project a little rocky. It turned out that part of the roof over our den did not receive adequate flashing necessary to prevent a leak that ensued after five days of rain. Scott insisted that it was the result of layers of caulk installed by someone else, inadequately sealing an inside corner of the roof. Dan, who was sent out later to make the repair, said the caulk and sealing had been done by their siders, and was still wet. Scott agreed to place a drywall patch in the interior ceiling where there was water damage, but I spent the better part of a day painting the ceiling, trim and walls to original condition once this was done. This put a damper on an otherwise great experience with Watry.

We totally respect Watry's workers and the diligence they exemplified every day. My feelings about Scott with him not taking ownership of the leak and the damage it caused was unfortunate because it would have been so easy to simply do so without casting blame on others. I also feel it would have been appropriate to personally stop by at the project's conclusion (today), to ensure he had a satisfied customer. As it was, he called and asked me to give a check for final payment to his worker before he left, without asking me if I was completely satisfied. In my view, the size and scope of our project would dictate that he do so. 

However, I would not be hesitant to recommend them as a reference primarily because of his crews.




"
Additional Photos
HardiPlank and Hardie Shakes
All Hardie Shakes
HardiPlank and Hardie Shakes
HardiPlank Siding

+14

Recommended by95%of homeowners
Avatar for VM Contracting LLC
VM Contracting LLC
4.6(
16
)
Wood Shake or Composite Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

"In short order it was obvious that they knew what they were doing. They replaced the damaged wood. Sealed the opening and reinstalled the skylight. They then further sealed the skylight and replaced the shingles. I feel very confident that it will not leak again. Besides their excellent work, they showed up when they said they would and kept me informed about scheduling. I highly recommend them and I'm getting my list ready for them to do next spring."
Additional Photos
Recommended by92%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 35
FAQs for wood shake or composite roofing installation and replacement projects in Poynette, WI

Cedar shakes and wood shingles might seem similar, but they have some important differences. Cedar shakes are hand-split, giving them a unique, textured appearance that adds rustic charm to your roof. They're great for homeowners who want a distinctive look. Wood shingles, conversely, are machine-made, providing a smooth, uniform appearance for a more modern look. Shakes tend to be more expensive due to the craftsmanship involved but offer exceptional beauty and resilience.

A well-maintained cedar shake roof can last up to 60 years. However, factors like severe weather and improper ventilation can reduce its lifespan. You should consider replacing your roof if you notice persistent leaks, visible water damage, curling or splitting shakes, moss growth, rot, or missing shakes. Regular inspections can help you determine when it's time for a replacement.

When hiring a roofing contractor for your cedar shake roof, asking the right questions is important. Make sure they are fully certified and have extensive experience with cedar installations. Verify that their team is licensed, bonded, and insured. Ask for details about the materials they use, such as the type of underlayment and fasteners, and how they ensure proper ventilation. Getting multiple written estimates can help you compare options and choose a contractor who offers quality workmanship at a fair price.

The Poynette, WI homeowners’ guide to wood shake or composite roofing installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.