Get matched with top metal roofing installers and replacers in Sidney, OH

"I am so disappointed. This company did a bait and switch and I ended up cancelling the order because they wanted $2,000 more! One month into the project--- financing processed, windows measured and ordered, and just awaiting notice of installation date--- they called me to say that they made a mistake and they could not do project for the agreed upon, signed contract. At that point I saw lots of red flags and did some more research on company. I discovered a F RATING from Better Business Bureau. Needless to say, I saw this as a sign from God that I should NOT use this company!!!!!"

"Mike and thomas were very helpful and top of everything related to the project. The crew was done quickly and did great cleaning up. 10/10 recommend to friend or family "

"New Perfection Metal Roofing transformed our 50 year old log home into a beautiful log structure. The team of workers were very professional and efficient while applying the colorful new roof. They did a great job cleaning up upon completion of the job. The new roof is so attractive. We're still getting compliments from neighbors and visitors each week. We feel very satisfied about our choice of Perfection Metal Roofing and would recommend them to anyone searching for a new metal roof."

"HIred them after a big fancy sales pitch, needed a door and some siding fixed. It took them 3+ months longer to do the work than expected. Once they started the work it was great though."

"I would never use this company. They use subs that scratched up my new roof and then you spray paint to try to cover it up. And then we had leaks, and they would never come out. And take care of it after I called them. Multiple times again, this is the worst company that I've ever dealt with. And I would never use them"

"By far a great contractor to experience. They have a great team. We should all be happy in this age, companies like this still exist"

"The quality of work was excellent. I was very pleased. The owner was very detailed and his crew did a really good job. They would be the first one I'll call if I needed another service like this."

"I ordered all new windows from Mike Murnane upon returning home from deployment on June 17, 2024. Mike never ordered the windows. He stole a $5,000 down payment and strung me along for almost a year. Toward the end of November 2024, mike admitted the windows hadn’t been ordered but he was working on other jobs and would pay me back in a week. This continued for months. Filing a lawsuit. These guys are absolute crooks, do not trust them with anything. Update as of 04/22/2025 In regards to the review below, you guys are comical liars. Numerous calls were placed to your office in the early months. You guys sure knew mike then. You guys were able to get ahold of him a few times I couldn't. Your business has atlas exteriors listed as a DBA. All of this has been recorded, pictures saved, and the old "oh we don't know that employee" does not work when I have called your office for him and your secretaries get ahold of him for us. Months later you switched to suddenly not knowing a person using a listed DBA you have given business cards to? Same address? It'll get sorted in court unless money is returned."

"It went great. There was one snafu because a subcontractor’s extruding and bending machine was on the fritz. However buckeye construction got it done in one day on a very tight schedule—that is before the next big storm supposedly arriving early tomorrow morning. They even went the extra mile and attached a chimney a previous contractor left unattached, and put several screws in the roofing on corners at opposite ends of the house a previous roofing company failed to install even though there were holes already there."

"Clear description of need and repair process. Workers were professional."