Top-rated small animal pest control pros.

Get matched with top small animal pest control pros in West Islip, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Small animal pest control pros in West Islip

Avatar for Homestead Wildlife Solutions, Inc.

Homestead Wildlife Solutions, Inc.

4.99(
44
)
•Approved Pro

Homestead Wildlife Solutions, Inc.

4.99(
44
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
7 years of experience

We are a family owned and operated, 3rd generation business with 15 years of experience. We are a full service company that values people, property, and peace of mind. Ask about our wholesale pest control options as well as our senior and military discounts! Call for a free estimate today, We Treat You Like Family!

"Daniel was great , he trapped about 10 squirrels for me and he kept his traps around my house for 2 weeks. And was great in answering any questions that l asked him. And when I contacted him about squirrels in the trap he came to remove them asap"

Hubert N on February 2023

We are a family owned and operated, 3rd generation business with 15 years of experience. We are a full service company that values people, property, and peace of mind. Ask about our wholesale pest control options as well as our senior and military discounts! Call for a free estimate today, We Treat You Like Family!

"Daniel was great , he trapped about 10 squirrels for me and he kept his traps around my house for 2 weeks. And was great in answering any questions that l asked him. And when I contacted him about squirrels in the trap he came to remove them asap"

Hubert N on February 2023

Avatar for Bug Johnson's Pest Services, LLC

Bug Johnson's Pest Services, LLC

4.54(
341
)
•Approved Pro

Bug Johnson's Pest Services, LLC

4.54(
341
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
19 years of experience
Emergency services offered

NO DOGS/ NO CATS: Bug Johnsons Pest Services delivers the best service for the best price, and is your number one pest control service and wildlife removal in New York. We take pride in the quality of our work and believe that customer service is what sets us apart from our competition. NO CATS/NO DOGS

"'m sorry, I didn't answer earlier; I did not see this email until last Thursday, although I was looking for it. When I first spoke to he told me he can only come tomorrow at 7:30 in the morning to see the job and to discuss what he will do and give me a contract. I was reluctant to have him come this early beacause my son and husband would not be available but i agreed because I figured he was just coming to look. He came early and looked only in one place instead of looking around the whole house and told me that he is sure that I have a raccoon problem because of the opening in the eaves. He told me he wants to cover the hole with chicken wire and a one-way door and the raccoons will leave through the exit. I tried disputing this idea, but before we drafted a contract he went to work patching up the hole. It probably took around 20 minutes and he claimed he was finished. I was all alone, early in the morning for me, when i couldn't think straight, so I just wanted to finish up with him. I said the job was guaranteed for a full year so I asked him hw much I owed him and I paid him $800 cash. And he gave me a receipt marked "raccoon" and charged me the full price for trapping a raccoon, which he never did. When my son, who lives with me appeared, he was furious. He said the problem stemmed from a different hole, and the hole that he patched up was originally a small hole which he may have enlarged to convince me that I have racoons. I undersood that ithe same treatment for racoons would also solve the sqirrel problem. My son called him and lost his temper while confronting him with accusations that he was scamming us. He got insulted and hug up on him. The next day I called him and told him there was another hole to tackle, so he agreed to come the next day. He did come, and I showed him where the hole is. He saw that it would be quite difficult to access it. In the meantime, my son came out and tried to talk to him. The conversation got rowdy, he got offended, and, in short, refused to deal with us and ran away. Nothing was accomplished and he refused to set up some traps, which he could have easily done inside my house because I have trap doors to the eaves. We have done it in the past and were successful. That took place last week, and since then, I am at my wits' end. We have several squirrels running around in the attic, and I cannot call a roofer until I get rid of them. They sound like they are damaging the house and we are getting very nervous. I would prefer to discuss this on the phone. My phone number is 929-302-1637. My home no is 718-871-2585."

CHAYA W on December 2025

NO DOGS/ NO CATS: Bug Johnsons Pest Services delivers the best service for the best price, and is your number one pest control service and wildlife removal in New York. We take pride in the quality of our work and believe that customer service is what sets us apart from our competition. NO CATS/NO DOGS

"'m sorry, I didn't answer earlier; I did not see this email until last Thursday, although I was looking for it. When I first spoke to he told me he can only come tomorrow at 7:30 in the morning to see the job and to discuss what he will do and give me a contract. I was reluctant to have him come this early beacause my son and husband would not be available but i agreed because I figured he was just coming to look. He came early and looked only in one place instead of looking around the whole house and told me that he is sure that I have a raccoon problem because of the opening in the eaves. He told me he wants to cover the hole with chicken wire and a one-way door and the raccoons will leave through the exit. I tried disputing this idea, but before we drafted a contract he went to work patching up the hole. It probably took around 20 minutes and he claimed he was finished. I was all alone, early in the morning for me, when i couldn't think straight, so I just wanted to finish up with him. I said the job was guaranteed for a full year so I asked him hw much I owed him and I paid him $800 cash. And he gave me a receipt marked "raccoon" and charged me the full price for trapping a raccoon, which he never did. When my son, who lives with me appeared, he was furious. He said the problem stemmed from a different hole, and the hole that he patched up was originally a small hole which he may have enlarged to convince me that I have racoons. I undersood that ithe same treatment for racoons would also solve the sqirrel problem. My son called him and lost his temper while confronting him with accusations that he was scamming us. He got insulted and hug up on him. The next day I called him and told him there was another hole to tackle, so he agreed to come the next day. He did come, and I showed him where the hole is. He saw that it would be quite difficult to access it. In the meantime, my son came out and tried to talk to him. The conversation got rowdy, he got offended, and, in short, refused to deal with us and ran away. Nothing was accomplished and he refused to set up some traps, which he could have easily done inside my house because I have trap doors to the eaves. We have done it in the past and were successful. That took place last week, and since then, I am at my wits' end. We have several squirrels running around in the attic, and I cannot call a roofer until I get rid of them. They sound like they are damaging the house and we are getting very nervous. I would prefer to discuss this on the phone. My phone number is 929-302-1637. My home no is 718-871-2585."

CHAYA W on December 2025

Avatar for E Z Pest Management Inc

E Z Pest Management Inc

4.90(
49
)
•Approved Pro

E Z Pest Management Inc

4.90(
49
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers
314 local quotes requested

Here at E Z Pest Management INC, we pride ourselves on professionalism, attention to detail, and a dedication to our clients wants and needs. As a locally owned and operated business we feel invested in our clients and constantly strive for customer satisfaction. We will not leave a project until you are 100 percent satisfied. Feel free to give us a call!

"The service was not good, and caused some damaged to my items. I paid a lot of money for this service."

MadelineHart H on November 2025

Here at E Z Pest Management INC, we pride ourselves on professionalism, attention to detail, and a dedication to our clients wants and needs. As a locally owned and operated business we feel invested in our clients and constantly strive for customer satisfaction. We will not leave a project until you are 100 percent satisfied. Feel free to give us a call!

"The service was not good, and caused some damaged to my items. I paid a lot of money for this service."

MadelineHart H on November 2025

Avatar for PESTIFY LLC

PESTIFY LLC

4.97(
20
)
•Approved Pro

PESTIFY LLC

4.97(
20
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
8 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Pestify is a family-owned, 5-star–rated pest control company serving homes and businesses. We’re fully licensed and insured, and we use pet- and kid-friendly products. Our specialties include rodent control, nuisance wildlife removal, mosquito & tick programs, and year-round protection against ants, spiders, crickets, wasps, and more. Fast scheduling, clear pricing, and service you can trust.

"They were good! "

Theresa Q on December 2025

Pestify is a family-owned, 5-star–rated pest control company serving homes and businesses. We’re fully licensed and insured, and we use pet- and kid-friendly products. Our specialties include rodent control, nuisance wildlife removal, mosquito & tick programs, and year-round protection against ants, spiders, crickets, wasps, and more. Fast scheduling, clear pricing, and service you can trust.

"They were good! "

Theresa Q on December 2025

Avatar for Exterminex Pest Control Inc

Exterminex Pest Control Inc

4.79(
300
)
•Approved Pro

Exterminex Pest Control Inc

4.79(
300
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers
216 local quotes requested

Residential & Commercial Pest Control. Exterminex Pest Control,Inc is your leading commercial/residential provider of pest management.From ants to raccoons we are your one stop shop.Our service area includes Nassau,Suffolk and the entire New York metro area. In addition to traditional chemical methods we offer a Go-Green Program which uses non-chemical approaches as the primary tool to control pests.

"They were fast and knowledgeable"

Robert O on May 2025

Residential & Commercial Pest Control. Exterminex Pest Control,Inc is your leading commercial/residential provider of pest management.From ants to raccoons we are your one stop shop.Our service area includes Nassau,Suffolk and the entire New York metro area. In addition to traditional chemical methods we offer a Go-Green Program which uses non-chemical approaches as the primary tool to control pests.

"They were fast and knowledgeable"

Robert O on May 2025

Avatar for Stateline Home Inspection

Stateline Home Inspection

4.77(
13
)

Stateline Home Inspection

4.77(
13
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 92% of Angi customers
Recommended by 92% of HomeAdvisor customers

My goal is to make you aware of costly defects and safety concerns for you and your family prior to your purchase. I do not sub out - I perform all inspections personally. I will email you a thorough, easy to read report with photos. If you wish I will also email report to your attorney and realtor. I am available 7 days a week.

My goal is to make you aware of costly defects and safety concerns for you and your family prior to your purchase. I do not sub out - I perform all inspections personally. I will email you a thorough, easy to read report with photos. If you wish I will also email report to your attorney and realtor. I am available 7 days a week.

angel morales

No reviews yet

angel morales

No reviews yet

Animal Busters

2.67(
3
)

Animal Busters

2.67(
3
)
53 years of experience

Owner operated. No subs. Cost is determined by the job. No travel charges. No extra charge for after hour services.

Owner operated. No subs. Cost is determined by the job. No travel charges. No extra charge for after hour services.

Avatar for Pest2kill Exterminating Co., Inc

Pest2kill Exterminating Co., Inc

5.00(
1
)

Pest2kill Exterminating Co., Inc

5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We are a family owned and operated company specializing in full pest control services for both residential and commercial properties. As a service company we are always committed to providing the best Integrated Pest Management (IPM) service and most effective solutions. It is our company goal to build strong relationships with our customers. We believe in customer service that will always exceed your expectations.We service all kind Pest Problem.Since certain pests may have a preference for a particular type of bait, we utilize a number of treatment options including gels, dust, granules and liquids. Pest2kill Exterminating Co, Inc. is New York’s, leading full-service pest management company and has been providing services in all phases of pest control to homes and businesses. Pest Control and Pest Prevention: The Best Business Decision restaurants, office buildings, hospitals, schools, retail shops and supermarkets all have one thing in common, a need for pest control. Rats, mice, birds, insects – they can affect your bottom line by bringing in disease, threatening health and safety, contaminating food, damaging your building, disrupting business and turning customers away. Pest2kill offers customized pest service programs designed with your unique business in mind. We use integrated pest management principles to prevent pest problems in and around your business while minimizing the impact to you, your employees and your customers. Our Commercial Pest Control Services Include: Scheduling. • Quick response times to problems or questions. • Weekend response team. • Regular quality control audits. • Specialists in a variety of fields. • Clear communications. • Trained office staff, not an answering service. • Elimination and prevention of all pests, including termites, birds and animals. • Pest prevention with structural improvements. • Professional services and certified technicians. • Flexible Hours We specialize in, Termites Carpenter Bees/Bees Wasp/Hornets Bed Bugs/Biting Insects Cockroaches Indian Meal Moth Carpenter Ants Fabric Pests Fleas & Ticks Fruit Flies/House Flies Pantry Pests Rodent Control Spiders Stinging Pests Pigeon Control Other Pests (beetles, crickets, Stink Bugs, millipedes, silverfish, etc.) Rats/Mice and Bird Proofing. We have retail space to sell products.

"My goodness Pest2Kill Exterminating. THANK YOU!!!! This summer I encountered so many termites in my home. Edwin and his apprentice came to my home, inspected, educated myself and husband and shared with me what the next steps were. I couldn't believe how patient he was with all of my 1.5 million questions :) This review is 1 month post treatment and I am termite free!! He even gave me a call last week just to see how my home and termite status was. Thank you Pest2Kill Exterminating!!!! HIGHLY recommend!"

Katherine L on July 2019

We are a family owned and operated company specializing in full pest control services for both residential and commercial properties. As a service company we are always committed to providing the best Integrated Pest Management (IPM) service and most effective solutions. It is our company goal to build strong relationships with our customers. We believe in customer service that will always exceed your expectations.We service all kind Pest Problem.Since certain pests may have a preference for a particular type of bait, we utilize a number of treatment options including gels, dust, granules and liquids. Pest2kill Exterminating Co, Inc. is New York’s, leading full-service pest management company and has been providing services in all phases of pest control to homes and businesses. Pest Control and Pest Prevention: The Best Business Decision restaurants, office buildings, hospitals, schools, retail shops and supermarkets all have one thing in common, a need for pest control. Rats, mice, birds, insects – they can affect your bottom line by bringing in disease, threatening health and safety, contaminating food, damaging your building, disrupting business and turning customers away. Pest2kill offers customized pest service programs designed with your unique business in mind. We use integrated pest management principles to prevent pest problems in and around your business while minimizing the impact to you, your employees and your customers. Our Commercial Pest Control Services Include: Scheduling. • Quick response times to problems or questions. • Weekend response team. • Regular quality control audits. • Specialists in a variety of fields. • Clear communications. • Trained office staff, not an answering service. • Elimination and prevention of all pests, including termites, birds and animals. • Pest prevention with structural improvements. • Professional services and certified technicians. • Flexible Hours We specialize in, Termites Carpenter Bees/Bees Wasp/Hornets Bed Bugs/Biting Insects Cockroaches Indian Meal Moth Carpenter Ants Fabric Pests Fleas & Ticks Fruit Flies/House Flies Pantry Pests Rodent Control Spiders Stinging Pests Pigeon Control Other Pests (beetles, crickets, Stink Bugs, millipedes, silverfish, etc.) Rats/Mice and Bird Proofing. We have retail space to sell products.

"My goodness Pest2Kill Exterminating. THANK YOU!!!! This summer I encountered so many termites in my home. Edwin and his apprentice came to my home, inspected, educated myself and husband and shared with me what the next steps were. I couldn't believe how patient he was with all of my 1.5 million questions :) This review is 1 month post treatment and I am termite free!! He even gave me a call last week just to see how my home and termite status was. Thank you Pest2Kill Exterminating!!!! HIGHLY recommend!"

Katherine L on July 2019

Avatar for Superior Environmental Pest Solutions

Superior Environmental Pest Solutions

No reviews yet

Superior Environmental Pest Solutions

No reviews yet
Free onsite estimate

Superior Environmental Pest Solutions provides pest control services in all five New York City boroughs, as well as Nassau & Suffolk Counties. Specializing in environmentally friendly pest solutions, Superior provides fast, safe and effective extermination services to eliminate pests including bed bugs, roaches, rodents, termites and more. Call us today for a free quote.

Superior Environmental Pest Solutions provides pest control services in all five New York City boroughs, as well as Nassau & Suffolk Counties. Specializing in environmentally friendly pest solutions, Superior provides fast, safe and effective extermination services to eliminate pests including bed bugs, roaches, rodents, termites and more. Call us today for a free quote.

...
Showing 1-10 of 404

The West Islip, NY homeowners’ guide to small animal pest control services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles