Get matched with top wood shake or composite roofing repairers in Lewiston, NY

"Buffalo?s Best Roofing review by Mary Corio On Monday, October 20th, 2025 ? I was abruptly awoken to the pinging of water drops bouncing off the pots and pans in my living room. They were there for issues I had been having when it rained, and on this particular morning, I hadn?t seen it was raining ? but I heard! I thought someone was breaking in, but it was the damn roof again!! Raining in my living room ? not good! I was crying as much as it was dripping! I was getting more and more frustrated, had many people coming to help and give me prices, but as the old saying goes: ?Action speaks louder than words?, and they just never really followed through or showed up. I was desperate. It just so happened, by some random stroke of luck, I had scheduled an appointment that very morning with Joe White, salesman for Buffalo?s Best. I was simply curious about them. Joe came in to see exactly what and where my issue was and knew it needed to be fixed sooner than later. Everyone told"

"Did more than just the siding and on the same day. It did take awhile to get him over to the house, but they did a quick and easy job"

"All went well I had an asphalt roof replacement done. The job went very well smoothly they showed on time for the job with a dumpster and enough crew to complete the job in an impressive one day and a cleanup. My contact was Matthew Gritzke and he was well versed in what needed to get done. And had a dumpster and all supplies needed to complete it"

"Buffalos Best Roofing = Shady Business! Breach of contract: Buffalos Best Roofing did not fulfil the original contract leaving me with exposed exterior walls at the beginning of winter. Abandoned Job: After the roofing was finished the siding was supposed to go up in no less than 3 weeks. All materials were supposed to have been ordered upon signing of the contract. When I enquired about the plan for the siding 2 days in to the roof job, I was told that the siding I ordered was discontinued 4 months prior and they did not have a suitable alternative. So, we discussed a new product all together. They assured me they would fallow threw so I paid them for the roof alone, trusting they would return. Then, they ghosted me and even abandoned some of their scaffolding. It is still attached to the third floor of my house and I am unable to remove it. They removed my shingles and the underlayment they installed has begun to blow off leaving my walls exposed to the winter elements. "

"Graves Brothers installed a metal roof on my home. Very professional, on time. All the workers are courteous. They construction manager made sure everything was done properly and my yard clean after the work was done. I would definitely consider them for future projects."

"The positive: Graves Brothers will provide a quote for PARTIAL Siding projects where most companies won't talk to you unless you need a FULL Siding project. The installation team was quick and did a nice job. The Cons: Deceptive Sales. Your Typical Residential Home Services contactor. I had a complete east side siding replacement quoted. There is a 24" "Jog wall" between the exterior garage wall and the living quarters wall. Their quote included photos that show this wall in one of the views. A second photo shows the entire length of the wall outlined that includes this jog wall, but they did not replace the siding on this wall. A conversation BEFORE the project work started questioned if I intended on having the wall replaced and it was agreed that it should have been part of the proposal. The installers DID NOT replace the siding on this wall. I asked for a simple $500 credit and was willing to settle for a $350 credit which was more than fair. The Salesman insisted that seeing the wall was not assigned a "wall number" therefore it was not included in their proposal. Graves Brothers displayed ZERO interest in coming to a mutual agreement on the discrepancy. Update 7/19/2024: After continued conversations, the Sales Rep finally conceded that after speaking with his installers, that the work WAS included in the initial estimate and should have been completed. I gave Graves Brothers the option of discounting the price or returning to finish the work. They chose to finish the work which is scheduled this week. IMO, Speaking to his installation team should have been done PRIOR to him taking a flat stance with me that they were right and I was wrong. Give Graves Brothers Home Improvements a 3-Star rating for (finally) doing what was right. The installation was done well and the installers were professional, courteous and cleaned up well. Just make sure you document all conversations and get them in writing up front."

"We will call this service pro again if we run into any further Home repair needs."

"I have Hal and the HomeTeck team out to do a few pieces of work: Garage roof, new gutters on house and garage, replacement of fascia and what not around the house, and installing gutter guards. The team is always professional, the work has always been quality, and they were extremely fair with their pricing. I have zero issue giving these folks a five star review and recommending their work whenever I see people ask."