Get matched with top asphalt shingle roofing installers and replacers in Mayville, WI

"They were very professional, they stripped the roof and shingled in one day, they cleaned the entire yard and the price was very reasonable."

"I saw their notice regarding free estimate for attic insulation at the  Home/Garden show.  I left my information and they contacted me about a week or two later.  We scheduled an appointment.   Jason came out and inspected everything, we discussed options and he gave me estimates for both.  I was going to be out of town for a while and he said he would extend the home show discount until after i got back.  I scheduled the installation with Tina - she checked back with me (both email and phone).   John and Nick showed up a little late on the install day, as their previous job ran longer than expected.  Both Nick and John were very professional and personable.  They explained what they were going to do and let me view the work in progress, as i was curious.  They answered all my questions and did a great job in cleanup - even vacuuming the grass :).   I am pleased with the work and am looking forward to the savings the added insulation will provide."

"We did not use Exterior Pros' services, but wanted to alert interested persons of our estimating experience. Peter, representing Exterior Pros, came by in response to our request for a proposal to re-roof our house and replace the fascia and soffit. Peter was very knowledgeable, personable, and emphasized his company is dedicated to doing things right; uses premium products; is honest; and provides quality to ensure their work lasts. He was very patient with answering our questions, and thoroughly inspected our attic and roof. He showed great care to protecting our house from his ladder while inside, and took action not to spread insulation through the house. He wanted to make sure we understood all facets of the job. All of these elements gave us great confidence in this company. However, the visit lasted five hours, and, although Peter went up on the roof, and measured things, I believe twice, he came up with a measure of squares 25% higher than three previous quotes from other contractors. The three previous quotes contained essentially equal measures of roofing squares. We questioned how Peter came up with so many squares, and he said he used a program. We were confused as to why he did not use manual measurements, since he went up on the roof and had a long tape measure. He said he took tape measurements from the ground to verify his initial program generated result. He said the other roofers used the wrong multiplier. After 4 1/2 hours, Peter gave us a quote based on the number of squares he came up with using what he said was the right multiplier, and, then, provided us a quote with the multiplier he said the other roofers used. His higher quote was almost triple, and his lower quote was almost double the average of the previous three quotes. Peter, then, offered us a price with a 15% discount on the lower quote. When we asked how much of the quote was roughly labor, materials, and the price for the extended warranty, Peter said he did not know. He said the pricing is based on the number of squares, and everything is bundled together. This pricing structure does not give us the option of eliminating the fascia and soffit job, or opting out of the warranty; or doing other things to bring a job within budget. Another thing that peaked our suspicions was Peter's mentioning they would have to replace four large areas of decking. One of the other contractors who looked in the attic said there were no signs of rot or other issues from below, but all roofers have a contingency for adding extra wood if required. However, they all contend that you have to remove the shingles to see the condition of the wood under them. We were not impressed that Peter was recommending replacing decking before the job even started. We were very disappointed to lose faith in this company's integrity. We felt the bundled pricing structure was suspect and not conducive to normal business practices in the home improvement industry."

"After talking to my furnace/heating Company, I decided that my idea to have the chimney taken out and roof patched was overkill ---not going with Overhead Solutions had nothing to do with the quote or speed of their response. They were very good at both !!"

South Central Wisconsin Roofing has been protecting homes and businesses since 1971, delivering unmatched craftsmanship and reliability for over five decades. Family-owned and operated, we’ve built our reputation on integrity, quality, and fair pricing. From asphalt shingles to flat and metal roofing, we handle everything — residential or commercial — with precision and care. Every project is completed with top-grade materials and time-tested techniques to ensure lasting results. Serving Madison, WI, and surrounding communities, we treat every roof like it’s our own. Whether you need a new installation, a full replacement, or a professional upgrade, we guarantee dependable service from the first call to the final nail. Your roof is your first line of defense — trust the team that’s been perfecting it for over 50 years.\n\n

"Professional customer service with integrity. Our 100-year-old house in Whitefish Bay looks fabulously updated, and its original character is still intact, thanks to the thoughtful/smart attention to detail and quality craftsmanship of Ridge Top's team in replacing our original woodfame siding with LP Smartside, and installing new gutters. I knew this was the right company to hire the first time Mitch Anderson stopped by to give us an estimate. Not only was he thorough, helpful, and patient as we decided which original wood trim to keep and the color of the new siding, he stuck with us throughout the project when questions came up. He was responsive and demonstrated integrity; the mark of strong customer service. Overall, the crew was fast, professional, did quality work/cleanup, and was a pleasure to have around. Thank you, Ridgetop Exteriors."

"Mateo did amazing job! Really happy with the roof. Manny kept in communication with me, and all my questions were answered."

"I’ve used RNR for several projects including roofing, carpentry, drywall, trim, etc. Always had good experiences and will continue to use them."

"Erik Pfarrer was our salesman and he was AWESOME!!!! Explained everything and went above and beyond I even expected him to do. Awesome person. Erik Alvarez The foreman on the job was wonderful too went above and beyond to help to make everything perfect. Any question I had was not pushed aside. It was addressed immediately and explained in detail. Everyone working on my house, roof, sightings, and gutters were professional and cleaned up wonderfully after they were done, including the guys who did the roof. They even cleaned off the top of the roof to make it look even better than it did. Would definitely recommend."

"These guys know what they are doing, I'd used cut-rate companies in the past, I am very happy with the roof Ext Pro's installed."