Top-rated sump pump repair or replacers.

Get matched with top sump pump repair or replacers in New City, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Sump pump repair or replacers in New City

Avatar for Old Faithful Pump Co

Old Faithful Pump Co

5.00(
39
)
•Approved Pro

Old Faithful Pump Co

5.00(
39
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
18 years of experience

We are an owner/operator company with 17 years of experience. We are committed to offering honest service and competitive prices. We use quality material and perform work to the highest standard to ensure longevity of the equipment you will rely on every day. We are a full service well pump & water treatment company offering 24 Hour Emergency Pump Service.We also offer water testing, water filtration, UV lights, water softeners and installation and service of water tanks.

"Joe is very experienced and very professional to replace my well pump, bring up the well cap to above ground level and installed house water filter. He discussed the job in detail and gave a fair quote. He came on time and did the job at high quality. He cleaned up everything before he finish. He took the 5% Angies list coupon as well. Will use him again and highly recommended if you need well pump service!"

Zeqiang G on September 2018

We are an owner/operator company with 17 years of experience. We are committed to offering honest service and competitive prices. We use quality material and perform work to the highest standard to ensure longevity of the equipment you will rely on every day. We are a full service well pump & water treatment company offering 24 Hour Emergency Pump Service.We also offer water testing, water filtration, UV lights, water softeners and installation and service of water tanks.

"Joe is very experienced and very professional to replace my well pump, bring up the well cap to above ground level and installed house water filter. He discussed the job in detail and gave a fair quote. He came on time and did the job at high quality. He cleaned up everything before he finish. He took the 5% Angies list coupon as well. Will use him again and highly recommended if you need well pump service!"

Zeqiang G on September 2018

Nonstop Plumbing

4.75(
8
)
•Approved Pro

Nonstop Plumbing

4.75(
8
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
6 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Nonstop Plumbing is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers interests, and make their concerns the basis of our business.

"Very nice gentleman"

Desorene P on June 2024

Nonstop Plumbing is committed to excellence in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity bound by fairness, honesty, and personal responsibility. Our distinction is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers interests, and make their concerns the basis of our business.

"Very nice gentleman"

Desorene P on June 2024

Avatar for All Plumb Rooter

All Plumb Rooter

5.00(
3
)
•Approved Pro

All Plumb Rooter

5.00(
3
)
•Approved Pro
4 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. If we don't make it for your emergency within 60 minutes, we offer a $25 discount! We look forward to earning your business!

"We had banging & whistling noise from steam radiator pipes and the very old (but good) oil boiler during very cold days. He diagnosed what needed to be done. It was a serious amount of work, replacing a very old, badly corroded pipes and regular cleaning of the boiler. We could have had serious flooding if this had not been noticed and replaced it. Unlike other person's diagnosis, he knew exactly what needed to be done. It took three days to finish everything. He was very professional, experienced and very thorough and we are so relieved to have oil boiler /steam radiator running smoothly. Keeping an old house is an on-going job and it was so nice to have someone work very professionally. He offered warranty as well, so we know he is there for us should there be any issues. Recommend him highly!"

Michael P on January 2026

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. If we don't make it for your emergency within 60 minutes, we offer a $25 discount! We look forward to earning your business!

"We had banging & whistling noise from steam radiator pipes and the very old (but good) oil boiler during very cold days. He diagnosed what needed to be done. It was a serious amount of work, replacing a very old, badly corroded pipes and regular cleaning of the boiler. We could have had serious flooding if this had not been noticed and replaced it. Unlike other person's diagnosis, he knew exactly what needed to be done. It took three days to finish everything. He was very professional, experienced and very thorough and we are so relieved to have oil boiler /steam radiator running smoothly. Keeping an old house is an on-going job and it was so nice to have someone work very professionally. He offered warranty as well, so we know he is there for us should there be any issues. Recommend him highly!"

Michael P on January 2026

Avatar for Above Grade Home Inspections Inc

Above Grade Home Inspections Inc

4.97(
287
)

Above Grade Home Inspections Inc

4.97(
287
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers

***2018 & 2019 Super Service Winner*** For over 21 years Above Grade has been providing New York State with the highest quality residential home inspections available. We don’t stop at a clip board and industry certifications, we combine our extensive knowledge of the inspection industry with the latest technology to create inspections with unsurpassed thoroughness and accuracy. Above Grade is Veteran owned and operated.Call us at 845-527-0111

"Chuck and Noah, are amazing to work with. They communicate extremely well and are honest. They did a home inspection Saturday morning for me. Thankfully I asked them to do a full septic inspection, not just a dye test. They found the septic system, needing major work. To the point, my bank won't approve the loan. the house failed before they even got inside it. When trying to explain to the home own, (who is also the listing agent) what was wrong, and why it needed to be fixed. All this lady did was rudely speaking over him, to the point she was mad at him for finding it. She would ask why it failed and as soon as chuck would begin to explain, she would start yelling over him, how it was fine. She must of ask half a dozen times for him to explain, for her to start arguing as soon as he spoke. I don't know how Chuck was able to be so calm and professional. I would have hit the lady, getting in my face like that. Chuck, was instead calm,kind and professional. "

Seraph M on November 2025

***2018 & 2019 Super Service Winner*** For over 21 years Above Grade has been providing New York State with the highest quality residential home inspections available. We don’t stop at a clip board and industry certifications, we combine our extensive knowledge of the inspection industry with the latest technology to create inspections with unsurpassed thoroughness and accuracy. Above Grade is Veteran owned and operated.Call us at 845-527-0111

"Chuck and Noah, are amazing to work with. They communicate extremely well and are honest. They did a home inspection Saturday morning for me. Thankfully I asked them to do a full septic inspection, not just a dye test. They found the septic system, needing major work. To the point, my bank won't approve the loan. the house failed before they even got inside it. When trying to explain to the home own, (who is also the listing agent) what was wrong, and why it needed to be fixed. All this lady did was rudely speaking over him, to the point she was mad at him for finding it. She would ask why it failed and as soon as chuck would begin to explain, she would start yelling over him, how it was fine. She must of ask half a dozen times for him to explain, for her to start arguing as soon as he spoke. I don't know how Chuck was able to be so calm and professional. I would have hit the lady, getting in my face like that. Chuck, was instead calm,kind and professional. "

Seraph M on November 2025

Avatar for Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories, Inc

Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories, Inc

4.85(
347
)

Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories, Inc

4.85(
347
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers

ETR Laboratories in an analytic laboratory with a broad range of commercial, industrial and individual clients. We provide analytic services using a wide variety of scientific methods including GC/MS, IC/MS, GIR, NMR and SEM equipment. We can do particle analysis, organic and inorganic chemical analysis and micro analysis on biological and other materials. Private water analysis is our specialty. Award winning. Additional DBA - Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories Inc, ETR Labs, ETR Laboratories.

"as advertised"

Nancy C on July 2018

ETR Laboratories in an analytic laboratory with a broad range of commercial, industrial and individual clients. We provide analytic services using a wide variety of scientific methods including GC/MS, IC/MS, GIR, NMR and SEM equipment. We can do particle analysis, organic and inorganic chemical analysis and micro analysis on biological and other materials. Private water analysis is our specialty. Award winning. Additional DBA - Environmental Testing & Research Laboratories Inc, ETR Labs, ETR Laboratories.

"as advertised"

Nancy C on July 2018

Avatar for Orange County Mechanical

Orange County Mechanical

4.98(
44
)

Orange County Mechanical

4.98(
44
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Air Conditioning, Plumbing,Heating And Complete Chimney Services. Sales, Service, Installations. 24/7 Emergency Service. Free Estimates. We Are A Family Owned And Operated Business. Owner/Operator. Over 100 Years Of Experience. All Work Is Warrantied. Our Products Are Hand Picked To Ensure Our Customers Only Have Worry Free products Installed In There homes. All Work Is Performed By Orange County Mechanical. There are no Subcontractors. All Of Our Employees Are Hand Picked To Perform The Higest Quality Of Work

"We called for an estimate and were texted almost immediately. We met with Ed, the owner and were very happy with the estimate and we scheduled the replacement right away. The employees that came to do the install were clean, professional and respectful. They explained the steps of the install and completed it in a few areas. They went as far as to put down tarps to protect our floors. The install went flawlessly and we were very happy. The new system is much quieter than the old one. We would recommend them to anyone."

Mary Ann B on October 2021

Air Conditioning, Plumbing,Heating And Complete Chimney Services. Sales, Service, Installations. 24/7 Emergency Service. Free Estimates. We Are A Family Owned And Operated Business. Owner/Operator. Over 100 Years Of Experience. All Work Is Warrantied. Our Products Are Hand Picked To Ensure Our Customers Only Have Worry Free products Installed In There homes. All Work Is Performed By Orange County Mechanical. There are no Subcontractors. All Of Our Employees Are Hand Picked To Perform The Higest Quality Of Work

"We called for an estimate and were texted almost immediately. We met with Ed, the owner and were very happy with the estimate and we scheduled the replacement right away. The employees that came to do the install were clean, professional and respectful. They explained the steps of the install and completed it in a few areas. They went as far as to put down tarps to protect our floors. The install went flawlessly and we were very happy. The new system is much quieter than the old one. We would recommend them to anyone."

Mary Ann B on October 2021

Avatar for Right One Plumbing & Heating LLC

Right One Plumbing & Heating LLC

4.91(
78
)

Right One Plumbing & Heating LLC

4.91(
78
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 98% of Angi customers
Recommended by 98% of HomeAdvisor customers

Repair, remodel, bathroom and kitchen renovations, boilers furnaces, air-conditioning systems, whole house water filtration systems. Thirty five years experience, bonded, insured, references available. All our technicians are state licensed master plumbers. WE ARE PROMPT, COURTEOUS AND WE CLEAN UP AFTER OURSELVES!

"It was an emergency call on Sunday. We had water dripping from the ceiling. Jason came in an hour, found and fixed the problem. Very professional."

Aleksandr S on June 2019

Repair, remodel, bathroom and kitchen renovations, boilers furnaces, air-conditioning systems, whole house water filtration systems. Thirty five years experience, bonded, insured, references available. All our technicians are state licensed master plumbers. WE ARE PROMPT, COURTEOUS AND WE CLEAN UP AFTER OURSELVES!

"It was an emergency call on Sunday. We had water dripping from the ceiling. Jason came in an hour, found and fixed the problem. Very professional."

Aleksandr S on June 2019

Avatar for Comfort Basement

Comfort Basement

4.69(
124
)

Comfort Basement

4.69(
124
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers

Comfort Basement is a family owned & operated business that specializes in basement and crawlspace waterproofing and foundation repairs of commercial and residential properties. We use the latest technologies available for repairing wet basements and problem foundations and we offer a wide range of interior & exterior water management solutions to address each customer’s specific waterproofing needs. Throughout the years our company has established an impeccable reputation for quality workmanship and excellent service at competitive rates. Headquartered in Hatfield, Pennsylvania, and offices in Philadelphia & Marlton New Jersey, Comfort Basement is known for its trustworthiness, reliability and its consistency in providing the highest level of service and quality in basement waterproofing and foundation repairs services. We service customers in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware and Maryland. Our core values reflect every aspect of the way we conduct our business with our customers. Our belief is to always do all things in good character, integrity and excellence. Award winning. Additional address - 525 Rt 73 N Ste 104 Marlton, NJ 08053.

Comfort Basement is a family owned & operated business that specializes in basement and crawlspace waterproofing and foundation repairs of commercial and residential properties. We use the latest technologies available for repairing wet basements and problem foundations and we offer a wide range of interior & exterior water management solutions to address each customer’s specific waterproofing needs. Throughout the years our company has established an impeccable reputation for quality workmanship and excellent service at competitive rates. Headquartered in Hatfield, Pennsylvania, and offices in Philadelphia & Marlton New Jersey, Comfort Basement is known for its trustworthiness, reliability and its consistency in providing the highest level of service and quality in basement waterproofing and foundation repairs services. We service customers in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware and Maryland. Our core values reflect every aspect of the way we conduct our business with our customers. Our belief is to always do all things in good character, integrity and excellence. Award winning. Additional address - 525 Rt 73 N Ste 104 Marlton, NJ 08053.

Avatar for American Plumber LLC

American Plumber LLC

4.71(
38
)

American Plumber LLC

4.71(
38
)
Customers say: Quick response
17 years of experience

American Plumber is a new up and coming plumbing business, which puts customers first. Our top priority is customer service and satisfaction. We strive to be your first choice for all of your plumbing and heating needs. All of our employees are trained professionals who always provide service with a smile. Our prices are competitive and we look forward to speaking and working with you soon.

"On April 21, 2018, Ernest Serghi of American Plumber, LLC gave an estimate to replace the existing 1.5” underground gas line from the gas meter to the pool heater. This line is buried 30”. I told him that I wanted a 1.5” poly gas pipe buried 18” which was specified by the Holmdel plumbing inspector. He agreed to this and I signed the contract. On May 9, 2018, Ernest came to do the job and dug a narrow trench with a small hand-operated trenching machine and rolled out the yellow poly gas line, I measured the depth immediately and told Ernest that it was only about 12” deep and I wanted it 18” deep as he had agreed to. Ernest said the Code only requires a 12” depth and refused to dig the trench deeper. Ernest did the job in just 2 hours since he did not dig the trench 18 inches as he had agreed to. I have photographic evidence that in one area the gas line is only 9 inches deep. This is a violation of NJ Fuel Gas Code 404.9 that specifies a minimum burial depth of 12”. On May 10, 2018, the Holmdel plumbing inspector looked at the job quickly and approved it. However, he failed to measure the depth of the gas line and did not realize that it did not meet the minimum burial depth required by the Code. In the contract job description, Ernest did not specify in writing the 18” burial depth of the gas line that he had agreed to. I should have required this wording since Ernest did not honor our verbal agreement. I have contacted American Plumber, LLC several times in an attempt to have them correct the code violation and adjust the contract price to reflect the work that was actually done. Instead of trying to correct their error, American Plumber, LLC is demanding payment in full and filed with the Clerk of Monmouth County a Notice of Unpaid Balance and Right to File Lien against my property. I have filed complaints about this unscrupulous and dishonest contractor Ernest Serghis of American Plumber, LLC with the NJ Department of Consumer Affairs and Better Business Bureau."

Ettore C on June 2018

American Plumber is a new up and coming plumbing business, which puts customers first. Our top priority is customer service and satisfaction. We strive to be your first choice for all of your plumbing and heating needs. All of our employees are trained professionals who always provide service with a smile. Our prices are competitive and we look forward to speaking and working with you soon.

"On April 21, 2018, Ernest Serghi of American Plumber, LLC gave an estimate to replace the existing 1.5” underground gas line from the gas meter to the pool heater. This line is buried 30”. I told him that I wanted a 1.5” poly gas pipe buried 18” which was specified by the Holmdel plumbing inspector. He agreed to this and I signed the contract. On May 9, 2018, Ernest came to do the job and dug a narrow trench with a small hand-operated trenching machine and rolled out the yellow poly gas line, I measured the depth immediately and told Ernest that it was only about 12” deep and I wanted it 18” deep as he had agreed to. Ernest said the Code only requires a 12” depth and refused to dig the trench deeper. Ernest did the job in just 2 hours since he did not dig the trench 18 inches as he had agreed to. I have photographic evidence that in one area the gas line is only 9 inches deep. This is a violation of NJ Fuel Gas Code 404.9 that specifies a minimum burial depth of 12”. On May 10, 2018, the Holmdel plumbing inspector looked at the job quickly and approved it. However, he failed to measure the depth of the gas line and did not realize that it did not meet the minimum burial depth required by the Code. In the contract job description, Ernest did not specify in writing the 18” burial depth of the gas line that he had agreed to. I should have required this wording since Ernest did not honor our verbal agreement. I have contacted American Plumber, LLC several times in an attempt to have them correct the code violation and adjust the contract price to reflect the work that was actually done. Instead of trying to correct their error, American Plumber, LLC is demanding payment in full and filed with the Clerk of Monmouth County a Notice of Unpaid Balance and Right to File Lien against my property. I have filed complaints about this unscrupulous and dishonest contractor Ernest Serghis of American Plumber, LLC with the NJ Department of Consumer Affairs and Better Business Bureau."

Ettore C on June 2018

Avatar for NY Finest Home Inspections LLC

NY Finest Home Inspections LLC

4.92(
13
)

NY Finest Home Inspections LLC

4.92(
13
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Purchasing a Home or Investment Property is a major investment and can affect you and your family for a lifetime. Having a professional, and high quality home inspection is an incredibly important part of the process that can help you make the most informed decision possible. At NY Finest Home Inspections, LLC we are on YOUR side, and we work for you to find every potential issue in a home that could lead to a future expense or hassle for you. We want to Protect and Serve you in Your Purchase of your Most Important Asset. --Services include-- Home Inspections Light Commercial Inspections Termite Inspections Radon in Air Testing Radon in Water Testing Infrared Imaging (Thermal) Lead Paint Testing Lead in Water Testing Well Water Testing City Water Testing Septic Testing Air Quality Testing

"Richard Baccello from New York Finest Inspections is an excellent inspector, very thorough and knowledgeable...and his demeanor is serious but friendly.The inspection report is very easy to understand with detailed pictures"

Kevin W on August 2018

Purchasing a Home or Investment Property is a major investment and can affect you and your family for a lifetime. Having a professional, and high quality home inspection is an incredibly important part of the process that can help you make the most informed decision possible. At NY Finest Home Inspections, LLC we are on YOUR side, and we work for you to find every potential issue in a home that could lead to a future expense or hassle for you. We want to Protect and Serve you in Your Purchase of your Most Important Asset. --Services include-- Home Inspections Light Commercial Inspections Termite Inspections Radon in Air Testing Radon in Water Testing Infrared Imaging (Thermal) Lead Paint Testing Lead in Water Testing Well Water Testing City Water Testing Septic Testing Air Quality Testing

"Richard Baccello from New York Finest Inspections is an excellent inspector, very thorough and knowledgeable...and his demeanor is serious but friendly.The inspection report is very easy to understand with detailed pictures"

Kevin W on August 2018

...
Showing 1-10 of 181
FAQs for sump pump repair or replace projects in New City, NY

Sump pumps last about 10 years with proper maintenance and prompt repairs. Several factors can influence your sump pump’s lifespan, such as usage, environmental conditions, and installation. Premium sump pumps with heavy-duty motors and quality components tend to last longer than lower-cost models. Pedestal sump pumps usually last longer than submersible models since they’re not constantly exposed to water.

A basement French drain is a drainage system installed in basements or around a building’s foundation to redirect water and prevent flooding. This system features a trench with a perforated pipe that catches and transports water away. These systems can crack, freeze, or clog, potentially resulting in flooding or strain on your sump pump.

You can use a sump pump in your yard to minimize pooling water and landscape damage, but it’s best used in conjunction with other drainage systems. This can include French drains, trench drains, underground downspouts, and other equipment. Proper lawn care, such as soil aeration and native plants, also aids with drainage.

The New City, NY homeowners’ guide to sump pump repair or replaces

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles