Top-rated asphalt shingle roofing installers and replacers.

Get matched with top asphalt shingle roofing installers and replacers in your area

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Asphalt shingle roofing installers and replacers in Key West

Gary the Carpenter Construction, Inc.
800 Simonton Street
New on HomeAdvisorNew on Angi
Approved Pro
Gary the Carpenter Construction, Inc.
800 Simonton Street
New on AngiNew on HomeAdvisor
Approved Pro
124 local quotes requested
5 years of experience

Looking for expert carpentry and woodworking services in Florida? Look no further than Gary the Carpenter Construction, Inc. Our skilled team sets us apart from the competition, delivering top-notch craftsmanship and attention to detail. Contact us today for all your home project needs!

Looking for expert carpentry and woodworking services in Florida? Look no further than Gary the Carpenter Construction, Inc. Our skilled team sets us apart from the competition, delivering top-notch craftsmanship and attention to detail. Contact us today for all your home project needs!


Avatar for ASP SuperHome
ASP SuperHome
3400 NW 114th Ave
4.75(
401
)
Approved Pro
ASP SuperHome
3400 NW 114th Ave
4.75(
401
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
5607 local quotes requested

South Florida's leading professionals in impact windows and doors. Call us at 888.782.8342 for a FREE quote. Our second showroom is now open: 12762 SW 88 ST, Miami, FL 33186. *Services offered by our business: Storm Impact Windows / Storm Impact Doors / Roof / Solar Panels *Services NOT offered by our business: Shutters/ Interior Doors / Repairs

"100% garantizados, trabajo Profecional y muy rapido"

Roger P on June 2025

South Florida's leading professionals in impact windows and doors. Call us at 888.782.8342 for a FREE quote. Our second showroom is now open: 12762 SW 88 ST, Miami, FL 33186. *Services offered by our business: Storm Impact Windows / Storm Impact Doors / Roof / Solar Panels *Services NOT offered by our business: Shutters/ Interior Doors / Repairs

"100% garantizados, trabajo Profecional y muy rapido"

Roger P on June 2025


Avatar for Roof Systems Unlimited, Inc
Roof Systems Unlimited, Inc
13850 SE 98th St
4.67(
3
)
Approved Pro
Roof Systems Unlimited, Inc
13850 SE 98th St
4.67(
3
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
1865 local quotes requested

We are the type of company that will go the extra step to get the job done and keep your home safe. Don't be fooled by other company's that say they are going to do something and don't. We explain the extra steps we take to process your job, and keep you in the "Know" of what is happening from start to finish. As always we offer "Free Estimates" and "Emergency Response". Additional email - trevon@roofsystemsunlimited.net

We are the type of company that will go the extra step to get the job done and keep your home safe. Don't be fooled by other company's that say they are going to do something and don't. We explain the extra steps we take to process your job, and keep you in the "Know" of what is happening from start to finish. As always we offer "Free Estimates" and "Emergency Response". Additional email - trevon@roofsystemsunlimited.net


Comfort Cover Systems, Inc.
711 Turner St
1.00(
3
)
Comfort Cover Systems, Inc.
711 Turner St
1.00(
3
)
41 years of experience

Mobile Home Roofing Single ply membrane with Lifetime Warranty

"My mother hired Comfort Cover Systems to replace the roof on her home in Sarasota after Hurricane Milton. While the roof replacement itself was completed, their workers caused significant damage to the lanai carport roof by walking on it, which resulted in buckling and structural issues. Instead of taking responsibility for their actions, the company has repeatedly tried to downplay the damage and shift the cost of repairs onto my mother, a senior citizen. Despite multiple follow-ups and visits from their representatives, their proposed "solution" is completely inadequate. They cut off protruding screws and offered to paint over the damage, but this does nothing to fix the underlying structural issues or the buckling they caused. To make matters worse, their response tried to blame the lanai’s condition on pre-existing wear and tear from the hurricane, even though the damage was clearly caused by their workers during installation. This attempt to avoid accountability is both insulting and unprofessional. When we informed them that we would withhold the final $12,000 payment until the damage was resolved, they responded with vague promises but no real action plan to repair the roof. They also made communication unnecessarily difficult by asking who the "decision-maker" was, despite being told multiple times that all correspondence would go through me and my mother. A reputable company would stand behind their work and resolve such issues promptly, but that has not been the case here. I strongly urge anyone considering Comfort Cover Systems Inc. to look elsewhere. If they damage your property, you can expect excuses, deflection, and an unwillingness to take responsibility. My family is now left with no choice but to escalate this matter to the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation and the Florida Roofing and Sheet Metal Contractors Association. Save yourself the frustration and find a company that values its customers and takes pride in doing the right thing."

Margie P on January 2025

Mobile Home Roofing Single ply membrane with Lifetime Warranty

"My mother hired Comfort Cover Systems to replace the roof on her home in Sarasota after Hurricane Milton. While the roof replacement itself was completed, their workers caused significant damage to the lanai carport roof by walking on it, which resulted in buckling and structural issues. Instead of taking responsibility for their actions, the company has repeatedly tried to downplay the damage and shift the cost of repairs onto my mother, a senior citizen. Despite multiple follow-ups and visits from their representatives, their proposed "solution" is completely inadequate. They cut off protruding screws and offered to paint over the damage, but this does nothing to fix the underlying structural issues or the buckling they caused. To make matters worse, their response tried to blame the lanai’s condition on pre-existing wear and tear from the hurricane, even though the damage was clearly caused by their workers during installation. This attempt to avoid accountability is both insulting and unprofessional. When we informed them that we would withhold the final $12,000 payment until the damage was resolved, they responded with vague promises but no real action plan to repair the roof. They also made communication unnecessarily difficult by asking who the "decision-maker" was, despite being told multiple times that all correspondence would go through me and my mother. A reputable company would stand behind their work and resolve such issues promptly, but that has not been the case here. I strongly urge anyone considering Comfort Cover Systems Inc. to look elsewhere. If they damage your property, you can expect excuses, deflection, and an unwillingness to take responsibility. My family is now left with no choice but to escalate this matter to the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation and the Florida Roofing and Sheet Metal Contractors Association. Save yourself the frustration and find a company that values its customers and takes pride in doing the right thing."

Margie P on January 2025


LynnLee Construction Group
3139 Scotty Dr.
No reviews
LynnLee Construction Group
3139 Scotty Dr.
No reviews
20 years of experience

Licensed trade professionals that Design, Build Custom, Historical Renovations, Remodel, Repairs Residential & Commercial Construction, New Construction, Commercial Build-out, Restaurants Building Yesterday's Dreams and Tomorrow's Memories

Licensed trade professionals that Design, Build Custom, Historical Renovations, Remodel, Repairs Residential & Commercial Construction, New Construction, Commercial Build-out, Restaurants Building Yesterday's Dreams and Tomorrow's Memories


Collis Roofing
485 Commerce Way
3.71(
162
)
Collis Roofing
485 Commerce Way
3.71(
162
)
Customers say: Quality work
31 years of experience

Collis Roofing is the highest rated and largest roofing contractor in Florida serving 17 counties in Florida with residential and commercial home improvement needs! Collis Roofing goes beyond the regular roofing companies that you'll run into because we can offer things smaller roofing companies can't such as financing, windows and doors, solar energy solutions, and warranties that will be there if you should ever need it. We offer financing for those who qualify from 6 Months same as Cash to 10 Year Fixed Loans, so any home improvement dream from new windows, solar or more can become a reality! After all, Collis Roofing has been around for over 20 years, and you can trust will be here for the next 20 years and beyond!

"So much stalling, false information, and various other nonsense. It took them forever to do a small metal roof."

Andria C on November 2024

Collis Roofing is the highest rated and largest roofing contractor in Florida serving 17 counties in Florida with residential and commercial home improvement needs! Collis Roofing goes beyond the regular roofing companies that you'll run into because we can offer things smaller roofing companies can't such as financing, windows and doors, solar energy solutions, and warranties that will be there if you should ever need it. We offer financing for those who qualify from 6 Months same as Cash to 10 Year Fixed Loans, so any home improvement dream from new windows, solar or more can become a reality! After all, Collis Roofing has been around for over 20 years, and you can trust will be here for the next 20 years and beyond!

"So much stalling, false information, and various other nonsense. It took them forever to do a small metal roof."

Andria C on November 2024


Elite Roofing
713 NE 5th St.
4.13(
8
)
Elite Roofing
713 NE 5th St.
4.13(
8
)
Customers say: Terrific value
19 years of experience

We are a Florida licensed roofing contractor dealing with all types of roofing.

We are a Florida licensed roofing contractor dealing with all types of roofing.


A. Palmer Roofing Inc
9700 SW 168th St
4.66(
150
)
A. Palmer Roofing Inc
9700 SW 168th St
4.66(
150
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers

Please call our office 305-232-9211or e-mail us (apalmerroofing@bellsouth.net) to schedule an appointment for a free estimate. (Coupons must be presented at time of estimate, and cannot be combined). We are fully licensed and Insured, A+ rated BBB, and GAF Master Elite contractors. Additional phone - (305) 232-3774. Additional DBA - Andrew Palmer Roofing Inc.

"The company had repaired leaks in my 1996 barrel tile roof after the 2005 hurricane season. Other leaks occurred with the recent hurricane, so I decided to go with a metal roof. I knew that barrel tile roofs do not prevent rain infiltration onto the underlayment, allowing water flows into valleys to erode the underlayment, causing the leaks and rot. The code underlayment quoted (2 separate layers) is more robust now, but I ordered at extra cost an even more robust underlayment. The company contact was more than helpful in arranging for "custom" installation. The installation team was meticulous in doing the custom work, very professional, the company contact checked in every day, my property was cleaner when they left, the office answered all my inquiries within 24 hours, a real homeowner-friendly contractor. If I lived further inland, I have no doubt I would have been equally happy with the standard installation."

Raymond L on April 2022

Please call our office 305-232-9211or e-mail us (apalmerroofing@bellsouth.net) to schedule an appointment for a free estimate. (Coupons must be presented at time of estimate, and cannot be combined). We are fully licensed and Insured, A+ rated BBB, and GAF Master Elite contractors. Additional phone - (305) 232-3774. Additional DBA - Andrew Palmer Roofing Inc.

"The company had repaired leaks in my 1996 barrel tile roof after the 2005 hurricane season. Other leaks occurred with the recent hurricane, so I decided to go with a metal roof. I knew that barrel tile roofs do not prevent rain infiltration onto the underlayment, allowing water flows into valleys to erode the underlayment, causing the leaks and rot. The code underlayment quoted (2 separate layers) is more robust now, but I ordered at extra cost an even more robust underlayment. The company contact was more than helpful in arranging for "custom" installation. The installation team was meticulous in doing the custom work, very professional, the company contact checked in every day, my property was cleaner when they left, the office answered all my inquiries within 24 hours, a real homeowner-friendly contractor. If I lived further inland, I have no doubt I would have been equally happy with the standard installation."

Raymond L on April 2022


GENERAL CONSTRUCTION & ENGINEERING SERVICES, INC
1590 W 73 ST
3.00(
2
)
GENERAL CONSTRUCTION & ENGINEERING SERVICES, INC
1590 W 73 ST
3.00(
2
)
18 years of experience

Florida State Certified General Contractor and Plumbing Contractor. We offer start-to-finish solutions for every project. We also offer full design services. Our customers enjoy high quality craftsmanship, trustworthiness and personalized service.

"Alexis Lopez and his incompetent assistant Oliver Schlecht failed miserably. We have filed a six-page complaint against them at the Florida DBPR and Attorney General."

Matthew P on May 2019

Florida State Certified General Contractor and Plumbing Contractor. We offer start-to-finish solutions for every project. We also offer full design services. Our customers enjoy high quality craftsmanship, trustworthiness and personalized service.

"Alexis Lopez and his incompetent assistant Oliver Schlecht failed miserably. We have filed a six-page complaint against them at the Florida DBPR and Attorney General."

Matthew P on May 2019


Solis Roofing
1033 SW Dalton Ave
5.00(
1
)
Solis Roofing
1033 SW Dalton Ave
5.00(
1
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Family own and operated. Additional email - solisj@comcast.net. Additional DBA - Solis Roofing Contractors Inc.

Family own and operated. Additional email - solisj@comcast.net. Additional DBA - Solis Roofing Contractors Inc.

...
Showing 1-10 of 133

FAQs for asphalt shingle roofing installation and replacement projects in Key West, FL

Architectural shingles last 25 to 30 years, while standard 3-tab asphalt shingles last 15 to 20 years. This extended lifespan results from their thicker construction and higher-quality materials. Environmental factors such as extreme temperatures, strong winds, and heavy precipitation can affect longevity in any region. Regular maintenance, including clearing debris and addressing minor issues promptly, helps maximize the service life of either shingle type.

Architectural shingles justify their additional cost through superior longevity, enhanced durability, and better aesthetics. While they cost 20% to 40% more than standard 3-tab options, their longer lifespan (25 to 30 years versus 15 to 20) means fewer replacements over time. 

They also offer better resistance to wind and weather, a more attractive dimensional appearance, and stronger manufacturer warranties. For most homeowners, these benefits provide good value despite the higher initial investment.

30-year architectural shingles cost between $250 and $1,000 per square (100 square feet) installed. Premium brands tend toward the higher end of this spectrum, while more economical options fall in the lower range. These figures represent complete installation costs and don't include potential expenses for removing existing roofing materials, which can add disposal fees of $40 to $60 per ton.

Architectural shingles do require specific installation methods to ensure proper performance and warranty coverage. Their heavier weight and dimensional profile necessitate particular attention to underlayment quality, fastener placement, and overlap measurements. Manufacturer specifications must be followed precisely to maintain warranty protection. 

Professional installers understand these requirements and have the proper tools and training to implement them correctly. Improper installation can compromise both performance and warranty coverage, making professional installation particularly important for this premium roofing material.

The Key West, FL homeowners’ guide to asphalt shingle roofing installations and replacements
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
professional installing flat roof on home
Jun 17, 2025
Jun 17, 2025
Flat roof replacement costs are based on factors such as roof type, material, potential repairs, labor, and accessibility. See how much you could spend on this project.
A home's roof with red shingles and windows
Apr 14, 2025
Apr 14, 2025
Learn how much a metal roof costs to install. Discover how factors like size, pitch, style, coatings, type, and labor rates affect the price.
standing seam metal roof on a house
Apr 30, 2025
Apr 30, 2025
Budget for standing seam metal roof costs based on factors such as roof size, metal type, lock type, panel width, accessibility, permits, labor, and more.
flat roof home with rubber membrane roofing installed
Apr 29, 2025
Apr 29, 2025
Budget for rubber roof costs based on factors such as roof size, pitch, membrane type, labor, permits, accessibility, installation system, removal, and more.
professional spreading sealant on flat roof with roller
Apr 25, 2025
Apr 25, 2025
Roof coating costs depend on the type of coating you choose. Options include silicone, bitumen, acrylic, and liquid rubber, among others.
A dark roof on a brick house
Apr 22, 2025
Apr 22, 2025
Budget for spray foam roofing costs based on factors such as foam density, cell type, materials, permits, overages, labor, and more.
Share project details to get started.