Top-rated small animal pest control pros.

Get matched with top small animal pest control pros in your area

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Small animal pest control pros in New Albany

Avatar for Shield Pest Solutions, LLC.
Shield Pest Solutions, LLC.
930 Bunty Station Rd
5.00(
2
)
Approved Pro
Shield Pest Solutions, LLC.
930 Bunty Station Rd
5.00(
2
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
19 local quotes requested
Free onsite estimate

No Gimmicks, Just Results. Tired of battling pests? At Shield Pest Control LLC, we provide honest, effective, and pet-safe pest control solutions for homes and businesses across Central Ohio. As a locally owned and operated company, we know exactly how to handle the toughest infestations without the gimmicks or hidden fees.

"Paul was very helpful and knowledgeable and I could not have asked for anyone better!"

Faith S on May 2025

No Gimmicks, Just Results. Tired of battling pests? At Shield Pest Control LLC, we provide honest, effective, and pet-safe pest control solutions for homes and businesses across Central Ohio. As a locally owned and operated company, we know exactly how to handle the toughest infestations without the gimmicks or hidden fees.

"Paul was very helpful and knowledgeable and I could not have asked for anyone better!"

Faith S on May 2025


Avatar for Riverstone Wildlife Removal LLC
Riverstone Wildlife Removal LLC
6540 McCurdy Road
5.00(
10
)
Approved Pro
Riverstone Wildlife Removal LLC
6540 McCurdy Road
5.00(
10
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Free onsite estimate
Emergency services offered

We have a single mission: Complete Customer Satisfaction! We have consistently focused on the needs of our customers, providing personalized attention and a stress-free experience. You will find us to be competitively priced with close attention to the details. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job. We look forward to building a lasting relationship and guarantee your satisfaction!

"Came promptly and removed my issue!"

Diana S on June 2025

We have a single mission: Complete Customer Satisfaction! We have consistently focused on the needs of our customers, providing personalized attention and a stress-free experience. You will find us to be competitively priced with close attention to the details. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job. We look forward to building a lasting relationship and guarantee your satisfaction!

"Came promptly and removed my issue!"

Diana S on June 2025


Access Ohio Wildlife Services, LLC
31 Carstairs Road Southeast
4.60(
5
)
Approved Pro
Access Ohio Wildlife Services, LLC
31 Carstairs Road Southeast
4.60(
5
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
338 local quotes requested

We trap, remove, and/or exclude for wildlife as well as remediate the damage.

"Very professional! Quick response. Explained everything throughly! Had this out my attic and entrances boarded from start to finish in less than one week!"

Tamika O on April 2025

We trap, remove, and/or exclude for wildlife as well as remediate the damage.

"Very professional! Quick response. Explained everything throughly! Had this out my attic and entrances boarded from start to finish in less than one week!"

Tamika O on April 2025


Avatar for Critter Removal, LLC
Critter Removal, LLC
.
4.83(
6
)
Approved Pro
Critter Removal, LLC
.
4.83(
6
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
228 local quotes requested

Welcome to Critter Removal Ohio - Your trusted experts in wildlife and critter management. Our specialization lies in safely evicting bats, squirrels, raccoons, and various other unwelcome wildlife guests. We pride ourselves on offering humane and effective solutions to all wildlife-related challenges. With a certified team at the helm and years of hands-on experience, we stand by our commitment to 100% customer satisfaction. Whether it's your home or business, we're here to ensure it remains critter-free. Reach out to us for an all-inclusive wildlife solution.

"They initially helped us find and plug holes where mice were getting in. Then, they set traps and came back and checked them, adjusting as needed."

Beth R on August 2023

Welcome to Critter Removal Ohio - Your trusted experts in wildlife and critter management. Our specialization lies in safely evicting bats, squirrels, raccoons, and various other unwelcome wildlife guests. We pride ourselves on offering humane and effective solutions to all wildlife-related challenges. With a certified team at the helm and years of hands-on experience, we stand by our commitment to 100% customer satisfaction. Whether it's your home or business, we're here to ensure it remains critter-free. Reach out to us for an all-inclusive wildlife solution.

"They initially helped us find and plug holes where mice were getting in. Then, they set traps and came back and checked them, adjusting as needed."

Beth R on August 2023


Avatar for Buckeye Wildlife Solutions
Buckeye Wildlife Solutions
19 Gruber St
4.94(
249
)
Approved Pro
Buckeye Wildlife Solutions
19 Gruber St
4.94(
249
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers
428 local quotes requested

Our main objective at Buckeye Wildlife Solutions is to provide each customer with excellent and humane wildlife removal services. We specialize in wildlife removal in Columbus - Delaware Ohio and surrounding areas. Firstly, we identify safety as a primary concern, so our team of experts is certified to perform all manners of wildlife removal, damage repair, animal prevention, attic restoration and pest control. With a combined 20 years of both education and in-the-field experience, Buckeye Wildlife Solutions exceeds expectations in both customer service and wildlife & pest management.

"I called because of a racoon and babies living under the floor of my mobile home. They came out and put a deterrent under the home and charged me $300. No results after a week. They then set a trap for another week. No results. They basically told me "sorry" and if I called them again, it would be another $300."

Catherine F on June 2025

Our main objective at Buckeye Wildlife Solutions is to provide each customer with excellent and humane wildlife removal services. We specialize in wildlife removal in Columbus - Delaware Ohio and surrounding areas. Firstly, we identify safety as a primary concern, so our team of experts is certified to perform all manners of wildlife removal, damage repair, animal prevention, attic restoration and pest control. With a combined 20 years of both education and in-the-field experience, Buckeye Wildlife Solutions exceeds expectations in both customer service and wildlife & pest management.

"I called because of a racoon and babies living under the floor of my mobile home. They came out and put a deterrent under the home and charged me $300. No results after a week. They then set a trap for another week. No results. They basically told me "sorry" and if I called them again, it would be another $300."

Catherine F on June 2025


Avatar for Joseph’s Pest Control
Joseph’s Pest Control
1850 Jackson Rd
4.89(
9
)
Approved Pro
Joseph’s Pest Control
1850 Jackson Rd
4.89(
9
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
79 local quotes requested

You don't like bugs? We don't either! We treat for everyday pest including but not limited to termites, ants, stinging insects, flying insects, roaches, bed bugs, rodents, ticks and fleas and much more! We guarantee your satisfaction, and won't leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we perform. We treat each home as we are treating our own. Call or click for your FREE estimate today! Locally owned and operated. Fully licensed and insured.

"Amazing! We received clear & accurate information as well as guidance to resolve our cockroach problem."

Luke W on November 2024

You don't like bugs? We don't either! We treat for everyday pest including but not limited to termites, ants, stinging insects, flying insects, roaches, bed bugs, rodents, ticks and fleas and much more! We guarantee your satisfaction, and won't leave until the job is done right. We pride ourselves on the quality work we perform. We treat each home as we are treating our own. Call or click for your FREE estimate today! Locally owned and operated. Fully licensed and insured.

"Amazing! We received clear & accurate information as well as guidance to resolve our cockroach problem."

Luke W on November 2024


Avatar for 1st Response Pest Management
1st Response Pest Management
10346 Sawmill Rd
4.94(
646
)
Approved Pro
1st Response Pest Management
10346 Sawmill Rd
4.94(
646
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers
604 local quotes requested

10 employees. No subs. Cost is determined by the job. Award winning. We offer all Insect Control and Prevention: Termites, Bees, Wasps, Ants, Spiders, Bed Bugs (with Heat Remediation Bed Bugs Gone in 1 Day), Animal Control, Rodent Control, FHA & VA Inspections. Additional DBA - First Response Pest Management. Family owned. Additional Email - jay@1stresponsellc.com.

"Bobby inspected the house especially the basement and outside the house as I showed him the trouble spot where there was a swarm of ants. He was personable and transparent about what the process would be and the exact chemicals to be used. The environmental and health impacts were very important to us as our pet dog had recently been diagnosed with cancer. We had been resigned that there would be toxic chemicals involved. Bobby was very open to talking about it and showing us what would be used. It turned out there would be a very dilute spray of fipronil the main ingredient of the pet flea and tick preventative Frontline that would be sprayed around the outside of the house. This seemed to be as non-toxic as one could hope for so we went ahead. Booby immediately performed the treatment. The application was guaranteed and if it didn't work within 7-10 days I should call them and they would come back out. 5 days later all the ants were gone! It seems the work done was a bit pricey, but Bobby came out within 2 days of my contacting the company, everything was guaranteed and I don't know what the competition charges. And very importantly it was effective."

RICH L on October 2022

10 employees. No subs. Cost is determined by the job. Award winning. We offer all Insect Control and Prevention: Termites, Bees, Wasps, Ants, Spiders, Bed Bugs (with Heat Remediation Bed Bugs Gone in 1 Day), Animal Control, Rodent Control, FHA & VA Inspections. Additional DBA - First Response Pest Management. Family owned. Additional Email - jay@1stresponsellc.com.

"Bobby inspected the house especially the basement and outside the house as I showed him the trouble spot where there was a swarm of ants. He was personable and transparent about what the process would be and the exact chemicals to be used. The environmental and health impacts were very important to us as our pet dog had recently been diagnosed with cancer. We had been resigned that there would be toxic chemicals involved. Bobby was very open to talking about it and showing us what would be used. It turned out there would be a very dilute spray of fipronil the main ingredient of the pet flea and tick preventative Frontline that would be sprayed around the outside of the house. This seemed to be as non-toxic as one could hope for so we went ahead. Booby immediately performed the treatment. The application was guaranteed and if it didn't work within 7-10 days I should call them and they would come back out. 5 days later all the ants were gone! It seems the work done was a bit pricey, but Bobby came out within 2 days of my contacting the company, everything was guaranteed and I don't know what the competition charges. And very importantly it was effective."

RICH L on October 2022


Precision Pest Inspections Inc
PO Box 21089
4.90(
42
)
Precision Pest Inspections Inc
PO Box 21089
4.90(
42
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Unlike many pest companies we're not going to make you sign a year long contract! We don't to service agreements of any sort; we are a one time treatment service. We are family owned & operated. Cost is determined by the job. Phone is the best way to reach us so please don't hesitate to give us a call!!! Additional contact names - Robert Eunice, Pat Keaton, John Eunice. We also do V.A. termite inspections and treatment.

"PPI was quick to return our call and very friendly. We had a woodpecker making holes in our trim and they thought from the description over the phone that it was looking for carpenter bee larva. When John came out he was immediately able to tell that it was in fact prospecting for a nest. He gave great advise on how to remove the (protected) woodpecker safely and had no charge for the consult. PPI will definitely be our go-to company for any future pest problems."

MEGAN T on November 2020

Unlike many pest companies we're not going to make you sign a year long contract! We don't to service agreements of any sort; we are a one time treatment service. We are family owned & operated. Cost is determined by the job. Phone is the best way to reach us so please don't hesitate to give us a call!!! Additional contact names - Robert Eunice, Pat Keaton, John Eunice. We also do V.A. termite inspections and treatment.

"PPI was quick to return our call and very friendly. We had a woodpecker making holes in our trim and they thought from the description over the phone that it was looking for carpenter bee larva. When John came out he was immediately able to tell that it was in fact prospecting for a nest. He gave great advise on how to remove the (protected) woodpecker safely and had no charge for the consult. PPI will definitely be our go-to company for any future pest problems."

MEGAN T on November 2020


NexGreen LLC
2069 Builders Place
4.43(
42
)
NexGreen LLC
2069 Builders Place
4.43(
42
)
Customers say: Super punctual
13 years of experience

We are a unique Lawn, Tree, and Pest company that combines a naturally based Bio- Nutrient program with a traditional inputs. We reduce fertilizer and pesticide use by up to 50% while providing superior results for your lawn, landscape, and home. This is accomplished by using bio-nutrient supplements and targeted pest controls. Your program is customized to create a beautiful, green, weed free lawn, a healthy and beautiful landscape, and healthy home living area.

"I normally don’t do this but I am EXTREMELY disappointed in this company. Their back office administration is atrocious. I was a faithful customer for more than a year. I received invoices about half the time, was never notified when service was planned, payments made online were not easy and the left hand didn’t seem to ever know what the right hand was doing. I was in the process of selling my house when a technician came out to my house. The gentleman knocked on the door and asked if I still wanted service since he saw a for sale sign in the yard. I told him yes but this would be the last one since we were moving. Thereafter, I tried calling the office to tell them I needed to discontinue my service but could never get through - had to leave a voicemail message where I advised on the recording I was discontinuing my service. When I didn’t get a response, I submitted an inquiry through their website, again telling them I was discontinuing my service. Fast forward several weeks and I get a sign in my yard that a service was rendered that day! I AGAIN call the office and left a message that I needed someone to call me back immediately because they are not hearing me. A few days later, I get a call from the office. I explained my issue and the lengths to which I tried to cancel my service. She apologized and said she would close the account and waive the charges for my last unwelcomed service. I move….several months go by and I start to get calls from this company. We play phone tag for awhile and I leave return messages more than once that I had discontinued my service, spoke to office personnel and was told this matter had been resolved. Well, last week escalated to a whole new level when I get a letter from a collection agency! I am not going to fight with these people any more over $56. Clearly they need it more than I do. While I will begrudgingly pay this, I will also use my voice to warn other would be customers of my experience. I do not recommend NexGreen. Their lawn service is mediocre, at best and their customer service was BIG negative for me."

Julie S on November 2024

We are a unique Lawn, Tree, and Pest company that combines a naturally based Bio- Nutrient program with a traditional inputs. We reduce fertilizer and pesticide use by up to 50% while providing superior results for your lawn, landscape, and home. This is accomplished by using bio-nutrient supplements and targeted pest controls. Your program is customized to create a beautiful, green, weed free lawn, a healthy and beautiful landscape, and healthy home living area.

"I normally don’t do this but I am EXTREMELY disappointed in this company. Their back office administration is atrocious. I was a faithful customer for more than a year. I received invoices about half the time, was never notified when service was planned, payments made online were not easy and the left hand didn’t seem to ever know what the right hand was doing. I was in the process of selling my house when a technician came out to my house. The gentleman knocked on the door and asked if I still wanted service since he saw a for sale sign in the yard. I told him yes but this would be the last one since we were moving. Thereafter, I tried calling the office to tell them I needed to discontinue my service but could never get through - had to leave a voicemail message where I advised on the recording I was discontinuing my service. When I didn’t get a response, I submitted an inquiry through their website, again telling them I was discontinuing my service. Fast forward several weeks and I get a sign in my yard that a service was rendered that day! I AGAIN call the office and left a message that I needed someone to call me back immediately because they are not hearing me. A few days later, I get a call from the office. I explained my issue and the lengths to which I tried to cancel my service. She apologized and said she would close the account and waive the charges for my last unwelcomed service. I move….several months go by and I start to get calls from this company. We play phone tag for awhile and I leave return messages more than once that I had discontinued my service, spoke to office personnel and was told this matter had been resolved. Well, last week escalated to a whole new level when I get a letter from a collection agency! I am not going to fight with these people any more over $56. Clearly they need it more than I do. While I will begrudgingly pay this, I will also use my voice to warn other would be customers of my experience. I do not recommend NexGreen. Their lawn service is mediocre, at best and their customer service was BIG negative for me."

Julie S on November 2024


Helmick's Exterminating Co
1172 Mt Vernon Rd
2.17(
6
)
Helmick's Exterminating Co
1172 Mt Vernon Rd
2.17(
6
)
65 years of experience

Locally owned and operated. We do it right the first time. Additional address - 10 North Mulberry St Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050. Additional contact - Richard Amore. Additional email - ramore@alink.com.

Locally owned and operated. We do it right the first time. Additional address - 10 North Mulberry St Mt. Vernon, Ohio 43050. Additional contact - Richard Amore. Additional email - ramore@alink.com.

...
Showing 1-10 of 149

FAQs for small animal pest control service projects in New Albany, OH

Common signs of fox activity include sightings at dawn or dusk, distinctive musky odors, small paw prints with four toes and visible claw marks, scattered garbage, damage to gardens or small livestock, fox droppings that resemble small dog waste but contain fur or seeds, and high-pitched barking or screaming sounds at night. If you notice several of these indicators, you likely have foxes visiting or living on your property.

While foxes avoid human contact, they can pose risks in certain situations. Healthy foxes rarely attack people but may become defensive if cornered or protecting their young. Small pets like cats, rabbits, and guinea pigs may be vulnerable to fox predation. 

The primary concern with foxes is disease transmission, including rabies and parasites like mange. Professional assessment can determine whether foxes on your property present genuine safety concerns.

Wildlife regulations vary significantly between states and even counties. Many jurisdictions require special permits for trapping and relocating foxes, while others prohibit relocation entirely due to disease concerns. 

Professional wildlife removal specialists often maintain all necessary permits as part of their services. Before attempting any fox removal yourself, check with your state's wildlife agency about specific requirements in your area.

The timeline for fox removal varies depending on several factors, including the number of animals, their wariness around traps, weather conditions, and whether young are present. Professional wildlife specialists will continue monitoring and trapping until they're confident all foxes have been removed from your property, ensuring a complete solution to your wildlife problem.

Yes, you can prevent foxes from returning with proper preventative measures. Effective strategies include removing food sources by securing garbage and pet food, eliminating potential den sites by screening off areas under decks and outbuildings, maintaining fences with underground extensions to prevent digging, and using deterrents like motion-activated lights or sprinklers. A comprehensive approach that addresses both attractants and access points provides the best long-term protection against fox problems.

The New Albany, OH homeowners’ guide to small animal pest control services
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
professional inspecting crawlspace of house for termites and pests
Apr 30, 2025
Apr 30, 2025
Budget for termite inspection costs based on factors such as treatment type, property size, inspection type, severity, documentation, and more.
Exterminator sprays treatment on window.
Apr 30, 2025
Apr 30, 2025
Budget for pest control costs based on factors such as pest type, infestation severity, service frequency, accessibility, labor, treatment type, and more.
A mouse coming out of a wall
Apr 29, 2025
Apr 29, 2025
Budget for rat extermination costs based on factors such as the severity of your infestation and the method your pro uses to eliminate the rats.
An exterminator spraying pesticide in a kitchen
Apr 15, 2025
Apr 15, 2025
Ant exterminator costs depend on the ants’ location, the size of the infestation, and the type of pest. This guide breaks down what you need to know to budget for an exterminator.
Woman organizing clothes in her closet
Apr 15, 2025
Apr 15, 2025
Budget for moth exterminator costs based on factors such as treatment method and type, infestation severity, accessibility, exterminator rates, and more.
An american robin on the rooftop of a house
Apr 14, 2025
Apr 14, 2025
Need to remove a bird nest? Here’s how much it costs, what factors affect cost, and what to expect.
Share project details to get started.