Top-rated water heater installers and replacers.

Get matched with top water heater installers and replacers in Island Park, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Top-Rated Water heater installers and replacers in Island Park - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc.
Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc.
4.5(
464
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Island Park, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2005

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Chris was incredibly responsive. He actually came to the house on a Saturday to see the hot water heater. I thought it was leaking and had to be replaced, but he pointed out it was the expansion tank partially relieving and he did a maintenance on the heater rather than take an opportunity to install a new tank-about a $6000 job. Talk about integrity!!!!"
american standard tub
007 ciculators
kitchen faucet pull out spray
amican standard
american standard

+137

Response time5 hrs
Recommended by76%of homeowners
Barnagat Plumbing Inc
4.7(
212
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Island Park, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1980

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Barbara installed a new kitchen faucet and strainer plus had to make some changes under the sink with pipes/connections. (Just had new sink and countertops installed) We have used Barnagat Plumbing several times. She listens when you tell her the problem and then offers options - some times only an adjustment is needed and not a total replacement. We are 100% satisfied with her work and appreciate her honesty when it comes to providing options for fixing a plumbing problem."
Response time1 day
Response rate100%
Recommended by95%of homeowners
Avatar for All Weather Heating & Cooling
All Weather Heating & Cooling
4.5(
70
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Island Park, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1969

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I called All Weather to give me a quote for replacing my gas boiler. They set up a time for their salesperson to come over and give me a quote. The appointment was only a few days later and a man named Joe showed up on time. He spent some time with me, I told him I was looking for a new boiler and a new hot water heater, but I wanted to see what options I have (since I was debating going to a tankless water heater). He told me going indirect hot water tank is the best option and they always use this brand that's the "best one out there". Even though he may have been right, he didn't tend to my questions or concerns very well. I felt like he was getting annoyed that I had questions and eventually I just let him run the show just to get him out of my house faster. Especially when he gave me a quote of $8600, it was much higher than I was anticipating. One thing I really didn't like was when he said I'd have to get a permit since I live in an incorporated village, which would be an extra $500, meanwhile I already had another plumber tell me a permits only $200. So I went with another company. So even though I can't rate All Weather on their work quality, I didn't get a good feeling from their salesperson."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+13

Response time3 days
7 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by94%of homeowners
Avatar for Premier HVAC Services
Premier HVAC Services
4.3(
229
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Island Park, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2016

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"It’s hard to find a good reliable HVAC company in NYC when you have your small business and not get scammed or overcharged. I have been dealing with Premier for a couple of years now and all I can say that those guys are the right fit for me. They always on time, fixing my units or performing maintenance, always nice and polite. I really like to deal with them and hope to continue our relationships in future."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+38

Response time1 day
Response rate100%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Integrated Plumbing & Heating
Integrated Plumbing & Heating
4.7(
68
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Island Park, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2011

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Roberto and his company Integrated Heating did an excellent job on the replacement of my father in lawâ s 40 year old furnace and hot water heater, including a new chimney liner that required a new exit via a very solid foundation (no small task)! He was courteous, prompt, cleaned up all, and offered the most competitive price of the seven quotes we received for the work requested. I would highly recommend his company for your furnace and hot water heater replacement needs! Thank you Integrated Heating once again."
Response time12 hrs
11 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by84%of homeowners
Avatar for FM Plumbing and Heating
FM Plumbing and Heating
4.6(
41
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Island Park, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2012

Free estimates

Small jobs welcome

"FM plumbing is the best and most reliable, Mr. Felix install a brand new boiler and a brand new water heater at a comfortable price, I was having some difficulties with my gas meter and Mr. Felix guide me thru the process and solve the issue I highly recommend him if anyone needs plumbing work."
FM Plumbing and Heating
Response time3 hrs
Response rate96%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Benitez Plumbing, Heating & Cooling Systems
Benitez Plumbing, Heating & Cooling Systems
5.0(
13
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Island Park, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2021

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Benitez Plumbing did an outstanding job on my oil hot water heater. The workers who came were professional neat and clean. Pricing for the work was very fair, I highly recommend this company to hire. I will continue using them going forward. What a great find in this company."
Response time8 hrs
Response rate89%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
...
Showing 1-10 of 237

The Island Park, NY homeowners’ guide to water heater installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.