Top-rated garage builders.

Get matched with top garage builders in Middletown, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Garage builders in Middletown

All-Star Contractors of Hunterdon County, LLC
4.9(
30
)

Serving Middletown, NY and surrounding areas

Angi Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 1970

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"The owner is very knowledgeable and talks you through the whole process and works with you every step of the way . His worker Joel was very knowledgeable and will answer all of your questions he was great to work with very neat and a hard worker and at the end my basement was cleaner than it's ever been i would definitely hire them again. "
Response time3 days
Response rate100%
2 neighbors recently requested a quote
JLR Construction
5.0(
11
)

Serving Middletown, NY and surrounding areas

Angi Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2014

Free estimates

Offers commercial services

"We hired this contractor to renovate our bathroom. From start to finish we were very pleased with the quality of the work and the business model. We were given an approximate start date & they followed up while we waited. They started when promised and worked every day till completed. We are very pleased with the finished product & there were no hidden costs or surprises. We highly recommend this very professional and qualified contractor! "
Siding prep
Siding finished
Prep work
Finished wall
Front Porch

+8

Response time4 hrs
Response rate89%
12 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for D & J CONSTRUCTION
D & J CONSTRUCTION
5.0(
30
)

Serving Middletown, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1988

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Dominick from D&J Construction just finished a screened-in, covered 20’x20’ deck for us. It’s amazing! We couldn’t be happier. Dominick deserves a lot of credit for persevering through the pandemic, which led to substantial labor shortages for him. He would usually have multiple crews going, and was down to himself and one other person through most of the construction, and did much of this work himself. Thank you Dominick! We definitely appreciate your sticking with us through this pandemic and finding a way to get this done. Dominick also dealt with significant material shortages, having to run to another state at times just to pick up additional material. Dominick does a great job in treating his customers right; he listens, is courteous, friendly and was accommodating of what we were wanting to do as well as some last-minute changes. The quality of the work was terrific, and we really appreciated Dominick’s attention to detail. We couldn’t be happier with the end result, and the inspectors were pretty impressed as well. Dominick’s quote was very competitive, and he managed really well to that budget. Dominick is very capable, and handled a pretty large job for us from soup to nuts. He arranged an architect for us to work with, and took care of permits, inspections, managing multiple sub-contractors, and construction from footings to framing to finish work. We’ve struggled with general contractors who’ve put us in the middle of working with sub-contractors; Dominick definitely does not do that; he manages the job end to end. I’d highly recommend Dominick to anyone, especially for bigger jobs where you need an extremely capable contractor."
Recommended by96%of homeowners
Avatar for LDR Design+Build+Renovate
LDR Design+Build+Renovate
4.8(
88
)

Serving Middletown, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1993

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Jeff and his team are very thorough, communicative, skilled, extremely knowledgeable and committed to excellence. He guided us from design and engineering and applications, researching materials and finding subcontractors ,through construction. He solved problems as they arose. He kept work moving despite covid, snowstorms and holidays! Recommend highly!"
Recommended by94%of homeowners
Avatar for Bright Construction Stone Inc
Bright Construction Stone Inc
4.9(
29
)

Serving Middletown, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2010

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Fernando and Francisco were fantastic! Professional, punctual and reasonably priced. They did a beautiful job rebuilding some stone pillars for us and replacing damaged fencing. Also power washing. Could not have been more satisfied with the work."
Recommended by93%of homeowners
Credence Development Inc
4.8(
20
)

Serving Middletown, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1980

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Mateo built a 1 room 150 sf addition that resulted in a leaky foundation with water and mold inside. There were 6+ gaps/holes in the CMU walljoints that were 2”- 3+” deep where water easily penetrated. Also his tape and sheet rocking has cracked/gapped on all walls and the vaulted ceiling. The worst part was Mateo refused to stand behind his work and I had to get another contractor to remedy his work."
Recommended by95%of homeowners
Avatar for PAVOLONY CONSTRUCTION INC
PAVOLONY CONSTRUCTION INC
4.8(
36
)

Serving Middletown, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1987

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Bought a house that required a bunch of minor repairs. Finding a contractor that was willing to do the work was a chore. Dave and his company were willing to do the work. They were awesome. From the many many forms for the mortgage company to inspections they are top notch. The crew was great and punctual. I can not say enough about the back office support. This project was a nightmare from the beginning but Dave and Bonnie got us through it. None of the problems came from them. This was a 203k mortgage and is very paperwork intensive. They got everything i needed done in a timely manor. I dont think i would have made it without them. Hopefully my next project will be less stressfull, i am sure Dave and crew will make it happen."
Recommended by94%of homeowners
...
Showing 1-10 of 566
FAQs for garage building service projects in Middletown, NY

A well‑constructed, properly permitted detached garage adds between $12,000 and $36,000 to a home’s resale value. Buyers appreciate the secure parking, extra storage, and flexible workspace, so appraisers often bump the property’s value accordingly. The exact return depends on the garage’s size, finishes, and how well it matches the main house, but most homeowners see a strong ROI when the build meets local codes and passes inspection.

Yes—once it meets local building codes and you secure the proper permits, a detached garage can be converted into living space. Finishing the interior, adding climate control, and ensuring safe egress effectively increase your usable square footage, though it may not always count toward the official listing. Skipping permits can trigger fines and even force you to undo the work, so always clear plans with your city first.

Most homeowners policies cover a detached garage under the “other structures” provision, but coverage limits vary. Review your declarations page and ask your agent how much protection you have for separate structures. If the limit is lower than the garage’s replacement cost, you can raise it for a modest premium. Confirming the details now prevents headaches if you ever need to file a claim.

The Middletown, NY homeowners’ guide to garage building services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

  • stone home with double garage doors

    Need to replace your garage door? Here’s how much it costs, what factors affect cost, and what to expect.

  • new garage built onto house

    How much does it cost to build a garage? Explore cost factors, budgeting tips, and how a garage adds to your home’s value with our detailed cost guide.

  • Walkout patio with concrete floor

    Wondering who seals concrete? Learn who to hire, when DIY makes sense, and how pros seal driveways and garage floors—start your search now