Top-rated exterior trim installers and replacers.

Get matched with top exterior trim installers and replacers in Monticello, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Top-Rated Exterior trim installers and replacers in Monticello - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Luna Siding & Roofing
Luna Siding & Roofing
4.9(
61
)
Exterior Trim - Install or Replace

Serving Monticello, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2004

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"April brought lots of heavy rain and strong winds causing damage to our roof ridge. Luna Siding and Roofing came immediately, climbed up to inspect the roof and provided an assessment. They took a few pictures which we reviewed together after which they provided us with numerous options including roof replacement. We opted for the roof replacement and although a permit was required before starting the job, they were nice enough to temporarily patch up the roof ridge with a protective cover to prevent any water damage. They arrived first thing in the morning and finished the job in one day, carefully placing our outside furniture away from the house and cleaning up all the debris around our property along with our adjacent neighbors. We also had Luna clean our gutters and install gutter guards. All the work was done efficiently and to our satisfaction. Luna is trustworthy, answering all of our questions promptly and in a professional manner. I highly recommend Luna!"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+150

Recommended by100%of homeowners
Castle - The Window People
3.6(
178
)
Exterior Trim - Install or Replace

Serving Monticello, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1986

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Overall - good quality work, organized, stress free process, a bit pricey but within reason. We had at least 4 or 5 companies come give us an estimate for the 10 windows we needed replaced in our home. Castle's price was not the highest, but also not the lowest. We wanted quality without breaking our bank, so we decided to go with them. The lifetime guarantee was also appealing to us. The sales pitch took a while, but he wasn't our first one, so we knew what to expect. Overall, the salesman was polite and respectful to us the whole time he was over. The scheduling / installation / payment process was almost all very stress free and smooth - they showed up when they were supposed to and worked very efficiently and mostly cleaned up after themselves. Their installers are very well trained. All ten windows were supposed to be done in one day. At the speed their installers were working at, it would have happened. However, they told us that 2 of the 10 windows we ordered came the wrong size and they couldn't finish the job that day (they send their people to come measure the windows.... so it was entirely their mistake). Though it was an inconvenience to us - we had to expect them a second day at our house - the correction was seamless and they took full responsibility for the mistake. We did not pay a penny more over this. A few notes - *The salesman said that the installation would be done completely from the outside of the house. That was not the case. Some of it was done from the inside. Some furniture had to be moved, etc... but again, they left minimal mess. *Strangely, as soon as the windows are manufactured and taken to their warehouse, they call you and can be rather pushy about setting an installation date as soon as possible without much warning ahead of time. That happened to us during the first installation. For the last two windows they were much more accommodating about our schedule. *We had an old bay window replaced with a garden window (much cheaper than a bay window) and though the window itself looks wonderful, they put new trim around the window, seems we are responsible for the sealing / painting of the wood trim and surface. The very same day they installed the windows, we were able to set our heater thermostat 1 to 2 degrees lower and still feel just as warm in the house - definitely proves that the windows are energy efficient. We've had the windows a few months now - all is well. Our only complaint is that in my son's room, where the heater and humidifier are on all night, on extremely cold mornings, there is some condensation on the inside of the window.... that's not supposed to be good.... we did not follow up on it with the company yet, but it only happened in his room a few times during the winter."
Recommended by80%of homeowners
Avatar for Hudson Valley Roofing LLC
Hudson Valley Roofing LLC
4.1(
30
)
Exterior Trim - Install or Replace

Serving Monticello, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1989

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"As I said above it looked nice.  On a minor note, I was told they have some tool to remove all of the extra nails off the ground.  I ended up finding at least a dozen after they were gone....but that was really no big deal.
OK...ready?  After a year or two it became evident to me that there was a leak in the one finished room in my basement (both on the ceiling and the outside wall), so I called them back.  Randy sent his brother who charged me a few hundred dollars to fix it.  His brother put up some sort of (fire and ice?) paper on the part of the roof which is right under the front deck.  He put up a second row of it lower than the first, but the top of the second row was over the bottom of the row below it.  W**?  Who does that?  Anyhow, he insisted that would work.  A year or two later it became evident to me the water stain in that basement room was getting bigger.  
I ended up calling a different contractor who charged me a lot of money to finally fix the problem.  
Because of my experience, I would never hire Hudson Valley Roofers again.
"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+18

Recommended by81%of homeowners
Avatar for Castle "The Window People"
Castle "The Window People"
3.5(
172
)
Exterior Trim - Install or Replace

Serving Monticello, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1977

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Made an appt. with Castle Rep, James, for 17 windows and vinyl siding. He spent 1 hour talking about how great his company and windows are before finally getting down to the issue. We were told that CASTLE makes and services their own window, with all the best technology and technicians available. The price per window for energy efficient came out to over $1,200 per double-hung window! And since they make their own products, we could not find a way to compare quality and price with other manufacturers. But his per-window price exceeds the average price of $500-700 by A LOT! When we balked, he made a call to his "manager" to see if we qualified for a "special promotional" discount. If we were to commit right there on the spot, we would get an additional 10% off! Still way to high. We said we would think about it (he got sad and snippy), and that we wanted to hear about the vinyl siding quote before we made any decisions. He told us he could not give us a siding quote until his company did an "eagle view" measurement, which would require another appointment! We had no intention of sitting through ANOTHER high-pressure appointment. High pressure, long-drawn out presentation and he would not leave us with anything in writing! No brochures, prices, nothing! He refused to put anything in writing and we could not have a break down of labor and costs. I even asked him if I could have a copyhh of the window warranty and he said "only if you purchase right now." And they did not come prepared with references or previous job locations! When we further researched the company, we found they did make very excellent products, but the #1 complaint was by far that they did not honor their lifetime warranty and that customer service was horrible. In the end, we chose not to do business.."
Before
After
Recommended by70%of homeowners
...
Showing 1-10 of 68
FAQs for exterior trim installation and replacement projects in Monticello, NY

Depending on the job complexity, you can hire a handyperson or local siding contractor to replace exterior window trim. Handypeople are often more cost-effective, charging $60 to $65 an hour, while siding contractors charge anywhere from $50 to $150 per hour.

The cost to replace an entire window ranges from $300 to $2,100, with most paying an average of $850. The total price depends on your chosen window size, type, and material. Labor fees for window replacement typically range from $100 to $800 per window.

Exterior trim can be installed on many parts of the home, including the windows and doors, around the siding, the roof, and under the eaves. Project costs vary greatly depending on the material, style, and job complexity.

The Monticello, NY homeowners’ guide to exterior trim installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.