Top-rated natural slate roofing installers and replacers.

Get matched with top natural slate roofing installers and replacers in Poynette, WI

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Top-Rated Natural slate roofing installers and replacers in Poynette - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Aguilar 1 Construction LLC
Aguilar 1 Construction LLC
5.0(
9
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2014

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Thanks to Saul and his crew we have a new Roof . They did an amazing job and in a short time frame . They even helped fix some siding while they were here . WILL definitely recommend and keep in mind for future work."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+66

4 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Metal Roofs Direct
Metal Roofs Direct
5.0(
12
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

In business since 2010

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Chad and his crew were absolutely amazing. From the first sales call, until the last nail of completion, I knew we could count on him. He had been referred, and we immediately felt comfortable with Chad, as he patiently explained the value in a significant undertaking - this roof will be there another 200 years, the quality is just that good! The work was on-time, professional, and the crew did a great job of cleaning up when they are done. We plan to use Metal Roofs Direct for other roofs when the time comes!"
Door County Roofs
Randolph Church
Door County Roofs
Door County Roofs
Door County Roofs

+16

6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by85%of homeowners
Avatar for Diaz Roofing Co LLC
Diaz Roofing Co LLC
4.6(
45
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1994

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"He was very honest and upfront and said may be 6-8 weeks before could do the roof when awarded work as was very busy. After calling on 10/2 to get update on when might do he ended up being able to do it yesterday or less than 4 weeks. I was very impressed they did job for price and in one day with full tear off finding no nails or anything left laying on ground. He is very honest person with hard working crew and was less expensive than anyone else. I could tell right away he was honest person which is so very important when getting work done on your home. The overall quality of his work is very....very..... good for a very fair price. You might find another roofing company that may get graded excellent on overall quality but you will also be paying three to five thousand dollars more for this same job."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Response time10 mins
Response rate100%
5 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for RMZ Enterprises, LLC
RMZ Enterprises, LLC
4.8(
27
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

In business since 1988

"Awesome! The person that we worked with was willing to go above and beyond to help us. I have a feeling this is true with the company in general. Very personable and professional at the same time. Flexible, hard working, knowledgeable, and they seem to be honest. While we haven't had any work done as of yet, RMZ is definitely the first place I will call for all matters relating to my roof and gutters!
"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+100

Recommended by90%of homeowners
Avatar for Metal Roofing Systems
Metal Roofing Systems
4.5(
53
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

In business since 1990

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Slow process (4 weeks) due to dormers, roof angles and the required "cutting to fit" but the installers did a great job of sticking with it to get it done as quickly, professionally & efficiently as possible. We were always informed by the installers as to any issues and what options & solutions were available to complete the work. It was appreciated that they asked us if we had any questions at the end of each day & summarized what the next day would entail. We also appreciated that they always cleaned up after themselves each day. Our new roof looks very nice & we've gotten several good comments from our neighbors. Thank you for beautifying & increasing the value of our home."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+14

Recommended by90%of homeowners
Avatar for GF Company
GF Company
4.6(
152
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

In business since 1974

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"They were very helpful on advising on specifications. In general, I found roofers specifying roof replacement the cheapest way possible rather than what is most cost effective long-term. Once, I got multiple contractors matching on specs, GF was clearly cost competitive, particularly given no subcontractor usage. Actual install was smooth except for two things. It took more time than they budgeted for, but they handled that well and didn't try to ask for extra payment. Second, they discovered that the backing of the house's original aluminum siding was rotten when they were installing new flashing. Understandably, they didn't want to put it back up as is (which I can appreciate). Thankfully, they were able to provide a cost effective answer regarding new siding, as I didn't want to have to big that out with everything already torn up."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+19

Recommended by93%of homeowners
Avatar for Dans Exteriors
Dans Exteriors
4.7(
13
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

In business since 2002

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Dan and his team installed 2 exterior doors and I couldn't be happier! On time, professional, cleaned up after the job and went over with me on what was all done. Next project is new windows and look forward to working with them again!"
Commercial & Residential Projects
Commercial & Residential Projects
Commercial & Residential Projects
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+23

Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for VM Contracting LLC
VM Contracting LLC
4.6(
16
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

"We had VM contracting do the roof on our home a couple years ago and the work was stellar! When we needed the windows replaced we had Mr. Vinney come back for this job. 10 windows and a large bay window. The work, once again, was very well done! Very competitive pricing and on time completion. We will use them in the next year or so when we we do the siding our home! Highly recommended!"
Additional Photos
Recommended by92%of homeowners
Avatar for Watry Homes LLC
Watry Homes LLC
4.8(
403
)
Natural Slate Roofing - Install or Replace

Serving Poynette, WI and surrounding areas

In business since 1994

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"

After reading Watry Homes reviews on this site, we contacted them in March. I had reached the point where I no longer wanted to maintain the house, and after researching siding options and speaking to other home owners, was seeking a contractor to install what I believed was the best siding solution, Hardy Plank. It was our intention to have the work done before the summer months, to avoid the disruption and scheduling conflicts which inevitably happen in high season.

Scott Watry came out and inspected/measured the house on March 17, presented window options and gave an overview of the process. Within a week we had an estimate and we gave him the commitment assuming the work would begin as soon as materials were received within a few weeks. The project did not get underway, however, until June 4th, the day I was leaving for two weeks of travel. My wife provided daily updates in my absence, and glowing reviews of Scott's workers, specifically, Paul and Rob who came in and installed the windows and doors. I met these guys later and they are true professionals who pay close attention to detail. The siders were also efficient and meticulous in their work, and cleaned up every day. The crew had a few guys, but Roberto, who appeared to be their lead, was very responsive to every question or request, and went out of his way to be accommodating. Splattered paint on a portion of our patio and sill appeared to be their only misstep.

In the end, we have a job that met our expectations in terms of quality, fit and finish. It was the punch list of several small items and requests which was emailed to Scott in mid-June that made the final conclusion of the project a little rocky. It turned out that part of the roof over our den did not receive adequate flashing necessary to prevent a leak that ensued after five days of rain. Scott insisted that it was the result of layers of caulk installed by someone else, inadequately sealing an inside corner of the roof. Dan, who was sent out later to make the repair, said the caulk and sealing had been done by their siders, and was still wet. Scott agreed to place a drywall patch in the interior ceiling where there was water damage, but I spent the better part of a day painting the ceiling, trim and walls to original condition once this was done. This put a damper on an otherwise great experience with Watry.

We totally respect Watry's workers and the diligence they exemplified every day. My feelings about Scott with him not taking ownership of the leak and the damage it caused was unfortunate because it would have been so easy to simply do so without casting blame on others. I also feel it would have been appropriate to personally stop by at the project's conclusion (today), to ensure he had a satisfied customer. As it was, he called and asked me to give a check for final payment to his worker before he left, without asking me if I was completely satisfied. In my view, the size and scope of our project would dictate that he do so. 

However, I would not be hesitant to recommend them as a reference primarily because of his crews.




"
Additional Photos
HardiPlank and Hardie Shakes
All Hardie Shakes
HardiPlank and Hardie Shakes
HardiPlank Siding

+14

Recommended by95%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 29
FAQs for natural slate roofing installation and replacement projects in Poynette, WI

A slate roof features thin tiles of natural stone installed over a solid deck and underlayment. Formed under intense heat and pressure, slate is exceptionally durable and delivers a distinctive, high-end look. Because the material weighs far more than asphalt, most homes need added structural support before installation. 

While upfront costs are higher and routine inspections are a must, many homeowners choose slate for its unmatched longevity and curb appeal.

Slate stands out for its 50- to 200-year life span, low maintenance, and classic aesthetic. It’s fire-resistant, energy-efficient, and often boosts resale value. 

On the flip side, slate runs far more per square foot than asphalt, weighs up to four times as much, and demands a contractor who specializes in the material. Tiles can crack on impact, and repairs cost more because the work is slow and precise. If your budget and structure can handle it, slate delivers top-tier performance for generations.

Natural and synthetic slate aim for a premium, stone-like appearance, whereas asphalt focuses on affordability. Real slate runs $10 to $30 per square foot installed and lasts up to 200 years; synthetic slate costs $10 to $15 and tops out at 50 to 100 years. 

Standard asphalt averages $3 to $8 per square foot and needs replacement every 20 to 30 years. If you want the slate look without the full price tag—or extra roof weight—synthetic is a solid middle ground.

With routine inspections and prompt repairs, a natural slate roof can last well beyond 100 years; some hard-slate installations reach the 200-year mark. Soft slate falls in the 50- to 125-year range, and synthetic products last 50 to 100 years. 

Remember, flashing, fasteners, and the underlying structure may need attention sooner than the stone itself. Severe hail or fallen limbs can also shorten life span, so schedule periodic checkups with a slate-qualified roofer.

If you plan to stay in your home long term—or want a standout selling point—slate delivers strong value. Although installation costs are high, owners often recoup 60% to 70% at resale and enjoy lower replacement cycles than asphalt. The stone’s durability, energy efficiency, and timeless curb appeal also appeal to eco-conscious buyers because fewer roofs end up in landfills. Just be sure your framing can handle the weight and that you budget for occasional specialty repairs.

Skip the DIY climb if you have a slate roof. Slate may be tough against the weather, but a single misplaced step can crack a tile and create a leak path. The surface also turns slick when wet, upping the risk of injury. Professional crews use staging and hook ladders that spread weight across multiple slates, protecting both the roof and the worker. To inspect or repair slate, call a roofer who specializes in the material.

The Poynette, WI homeowners’ guide to natural slate roofing installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.