Top-rated water heater installers and replacers.

Get matched with top water heater installers and replacers in Garden City, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Top-Rated Water heater installers and replacers in Garden City - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for David Drain and Sewer
David Drain and Sewer
4.4(
136
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2020

Emergency services offered

Warranties offered

"David replaced our old water heater with an efficient heater that saved us hundreds of dollars. He was friendly and very respectful as he explained our issue and how he would solve it. Ps. David also removed our old water heater with no problem. He did the entire job in a timely manner."
Recent Work
Recent Work
Recent Work
Recent Work
Recent Work

+10

Response time4 hrs
Response rate99%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Dacstar
Dacstar
5.0(
176
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2008

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Excellent service on Sunday.Steve was on time, explained me the cost of the service and he was punctual. Cost was reasonable.Steve helped me to get the warranty credit from Home Depot, I really appreciated his help. My water heater was replaced and new water heater installed by him, up and running. I liked working with him."
Water heater replacement
Water heater replacement
Hybrid waterheater
Water heater replacement
2022

+3

Response time4 hrs
Response rate100%
Recommended by82%of homeowners
Avatar for Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc.
Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc.
4.5(
464
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2005

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Chris was incredibly responsive. He actually came to the house on a Saturday to see the hot water heater. I thought it was leaking and had to be replaced, but he pointed out it was the expansion tank partially relieving and he did a maintenance on the heater rather than take an opportunity to install a new tank-about a $6000 job. Talk about integrity!!!!"
american standard tub
007 ciculators
kitchen faucet pull out spray
amican standard
american standard

+137

Response time5 hrs
Recommended by76%of homeowners
Barnagat Plumbing Inc
4.7(
212
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1980

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Barbara installed a new kitchen faucet and strainer plus had to make some changes under the sink with pipes/connections. (Just had new sink and countertops installed) We have used Barnagat Plumbing several times. She listens when you tell her the problem and then offers options - some times only an adjustment is needed and not a total replacement. We are 100% satisfied with her work and appreciate her honesty when it comes to providing options for fixing a plumbing problem."
Response time1 day
Response rate100%
Recommended by95%of homeowners
Avatar for Reliable Plumbing & Heating
Reliable Plumbing & Heating
4.9(
14
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2004

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I was on the fence in replacing my water heater. I decided to get some quotes from plumbers. I came across Reliable Plumbing. I read their customer reviews, which were highly favorable. Then I spoke to Jerry. Which was like talking to an old friend. Jerry's honesty and professionalism won me over. Paul the plumber came 2 days later, did a great job. Paul was professional. Pollite and explained everything to me. I was extremely happy with the price, the service and the honesty. I will be using Reliable Plumbing going forward"
6 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for All Weather Heating & Cooling
All Weather Heating & Cooling
4.5(
70
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1969

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Installers arrived on time and everything went smoothly. Had to have them back a couple of times to balance out the rooms. Some were not cooling properly. After the third time they finally got it right. First technician was a younger guy who was not keen on going into the attic since it was hot up there. He didn't know what he was doing. Second guy the same. Third guy was an older tech that I made a comment about it being hot in the attic and his comment was that this was his job no matter the conditions. Very professional. Should have sent him the first time."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+13

Response time3 days
7 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by94%of homeowners
Avatar for 5DS Plumbing and Heating
5DS Plumbing and Heating
4.6(
70
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2013

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"I am very happy with their service.They installed my Tankless water heater combination system.I am satisfied his installation and customer service. Anytime I need anything Raj always answers phone and resolve the issue. Raj is very experienced plumber and I will recommend his company 5DS plumbing to hire for your project with confidence and you will not loose."
Response time2 hrs
Response rate94%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Premier HVAC Services
Premier HVAC Services
4.3(
229
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2016

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I had a great experience with Premier HVAC replacing my old and leaking water heater. I was impressed that they were able to respond quickly and start working on the same day as my call, especially given the severely cold weather and other plumbers being busy replacing freezing pipes. The plumber was able to work with my very tight kitchen space and narrow hallways, and without having to remove the countertop in my kitchen. I am satisfied with the installation and would definitely consider Premier HVAC for future plumbing needs."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+38

Response time1 day
Response rate100%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Varsity Home Service Company, Inc.
Varsity Home Service Company, Inc.
4.5(
245
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Garden City, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1962

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Our home central air conditioning system needed to be replaced. After reviewing and getting estimates from several companies, we decided, due to their outstanding reviews, to use Varsity Home Service to replace our entire central air conditioning system. There is no question that we made the right choice to use this company. From the pleasant attitude of the receptionist to the sales people and technical support, they showed concern as to what system would be best for our needs without pressure to upsell items. They came to our house on time and evaluated our house and made recommendations as to what they felt was the appropriate replacement system to satisfy our needs. Everyone we dealt with made our experience a most pleasant one, explained what we needed and helped us make the right decision regarding the system that would be best for us. Their estimate and cost for the system we chose was competitive. After making the decision to use their services, they came on time, the technicians were knowledgeable and efficient in replacing our system, they answered all questions to our satisfaction, explained an reviewed the function of the system, tested out the system, and they removed all debris and the old system from the premises. The following people were outstanding to deal with and helpful in guiding us to use their company and services (Anna Cinquemani, Depree Weeks, Eric, Mario Castro, Matthew Accattato, Ryan Kierych, Ryan Oâ Malley, and Santiago Ocassio as well as several others) everyone that I dealt with in the company was pleasant, concerned, knowledgeable, receptive, and efficient. There is no question that I would recommend to anyone who needed air conditioning services, installation, or replacement that they use Varsity Home Service."
Shower Fixtures
Installation
Truck
Best of L.I. Winner 2024
Angi 2022 Super Service Award Winner

+86

Response time11 hrs
120 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by83%of homeowners
...
Showing 1-10 of 365

The Garden City, NY homeowners’ guide to water heater installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.