Top-rated water heater installers and replacers.

Get matched with top water heater installers and replacers in Lancaster, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Top-Rated Water heater installers and replacers in Lancaster - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Halter Plumbing & Water Works
Halter Plumbing & Water Works
4.9(
99
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2019

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"My wife and I just purchased our first home. We knew before we closed that the water heater seen better days and the previous owner put it in a really tight spot, also backwards. After taking two showers, the water heater set off our carbon monoxide detector, having two kids this worried us a bunch. Halter Plumbing & Heating came out at 8:00 pm to help us, got it all figured out, and stuck around for a while to make sure it would be safe for us. Upon fixing it, I decided to go with a new one, like I said in the beginning, the water heater was in a tough spot, a lot of bad pipes, and backwards. He came in with the best price regardless of all the extra things he would have to do to get it in there. Besides that his price was definitely worth it, his willingness to take on the challenge of a backwards, crammed between a wall, and a fernes"
Response time6 hrs
Response rate87%
2 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for T-Mark Plumbing, Heating, Cooling & Electric
T-Mark Plumbing, Heating, Cooling & Electric
4.5(
652
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas

Approved (Corporate)

In business since 1992

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Plumber worked in the freezing cold to unclog my drain successfully. Plumber installed new water heater. Both services were satisfactory. Work area cleaned. I was quite happy with work both times"
Boiler Installed
2 Boilers Installed
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+10

Response time1 day
Response rate100%
5 neighbors recently requested a quote
Norton's Plumbing and Heating, LLC
4.7(
104
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 1979

Free estimates

Small jobs welcome

"i emailed Norton's a week ago in the evening after I found out my water heater needed to be replaced. A competitor gave me a ridiculous price so I was looking around for a better price. The owner called me immediately and set up an appointment for the next day. The crew replaced the old water heater in less than an hour and the price was great!! I will definitely use this company from now on."
Response time2 hrs
Response rate88%
29 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for RA Delregno Enterprises
RA Delregno Enterprises
5.0(
13
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2016

Free estimates

Offers commercial services

"Rick was excellent to work with! He diagnosed the issue with my leaky faucet very quickly, as well as was able to identify a replacement immediately. Even took the time to take the trip to Home Depot to pick it up! Definitely would recommend!"
Dishwasher Install
Dishwasher and Faucet install
Whitewash Fireplace
Painting sunroom
bathroom painting

+5

Response time3 hrs
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Cellino Plumbing
Cellino Plumbing
4.4(
235
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1996

Emergency services offered

Credit card accepted

"Cellino plumbing was very professional. We received a call prior to their arrival. No major issues were found. The technician was pleasant. I would have this company do future plumbing repairs if needed."
.
.
.
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+12

Response time7 hrs
Response rate100%
1 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Cellino Plumbing, Heating and Cooling
Cellino Plumbing, Heating and Cooling
4.0(
71
)
Water Heater - Install or Replace

Serving Lancaster, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1995

Emergency services offered

Small jobs welcome

"Cellino did an excellent job. After calling five plumbers to fix a shower head spewing hot water and none of them could come for 4-5 days. I got hold of Cellino who came in a few hours and corrected the problem. The tech was very knowledgeable and had the job done in no time. Excellent job and of course 5 stars. Had I waited I probably would have had a lot of damage to my bathroom."
Sewer Camera Inspection
Excavator Digging the Exterior Hole
Fusing the New Sewer Line
Attaching the Bursting Head to the New Sewer Line
Sewer Bursting Machine in the Exterior Hole

+18

Response time11 hrs
Recommended by86%of homeowners
...
Showing 1-10 of 61

The Lancaster, NY homeowners’ guide to water heater installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.