Top-rated water heater installers and replacers.

Get matched with top water heater installers and replacers in New Paltz, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Water heater installers and replacers in New Paltz

Avatar for Quality Home Services Plumbing Heating & Air Conditioning

Quality Home Services Plumbing Heating & Air Conditioning

5.00(
6
)
Approved Pro

Quality Home Services Plumbing Heating & Air Conditioning

5.00(
6
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
10 years of experience

We are dedicated to providing our clients with the very best in installation, service and repair for every heating and cooling need. Our company is built on honesty and integrity. We specialize in heating and furnace systems, in addition to a variety of plumbing and HVAC related projects. We take pride in the quality of our work and our commitment to outstanding results & look forward to building long-term relationships with our clients. We guarantee your satisfaction. We install heat pumps, boilers, central ac systems, ductless ac systems, pool heaters and gas fireplaces. Fully licensed and insured

"This company should be called "High" Quality Home Services Plumbing Heating and AC. Large AC install done at a reasonable price with no hassles. Highly recommended."

Anthony N on April 2023

We are dedicated to providing our clients with the very best in installation, service and repair for every heating and cooling need. Our company is built on honesty and integrity. We specialize in heating and furnace systems, in addition to a variety of plumbing and HVAC related projects. We take pride in the quality of our work and our commitment to outstanding results & look forward to building long-term relationships with our clients. We guarantee your satisfaction. We install heat pumps, boilers, central ac systems, ductless ac systems, pool heaters and gas fireplaces. Fully licensed and insured

"This company should be called "High" Quality Home Services Plumbing Heating and AC. Large AC install done at a reasonable price with no hassles. Highly recommended."

Anthony N on April 2023


"Happy with work."

LAMOYA B on December 2025

I pride myself on my professionalism, as well as my ability to complete every job to the homeowner's total satisfaction. I never leave a job unfinished, or a homeowner not 100% satisfied with my level of service - Call today!

"Happy with work."

LAMOYA B on December 2025


Avatar for Polar Plumbing, Heating, & Air Conditioning

Polar Plumbing, Heating, & Air Conditioning

4.84(
117
)
Approved Pro

Polar Plumbing, Heating, & Air Conditioning

4.84(
117
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 91% of Angi customers
Recommended by 91% of HomeAdvisor customers
416 local quotes requested

With 30 years of combined experience, Polar Plumbing, Heating and Air Conditioning is your #1 choice for plumbing, heating, water treatment and air conditioning needs in the Mid-Hudson Valley. So call or text 845-522-5112! Visit our website at www.callpolarpete.com to learn about the Polar experience.

"Thank you very helpful"

Brian H on July 2025

With 30 years of combined experience, Polar Plumbing, Heating and Air Conditioning is your #1 choice for plumbing, heating, water treatment and air conditioning needs in the Mid-Hudson Valley. So call or text 845-522-5112! Visit our website at www.callpolarpete.com to learn about the Polar experience.

"Thank you very helpful"

Brian H on July 2025


Avatar for JSP Plumbing & Heating, Inc.

JSP Plumbing & Heating, Inc.

4.13(
24
)
Approved Pro

JSP Plumbing & Heating, Inc.

4.13(
24
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
53 local quotes requested
20 years of experience

At JSP Home Services, their Kingston plumbers and HVAC technicians are dedicated to providing excellent customer service and will get the job done right the first time. They have over 50 years of combined experience helping individuals with matters such as bursting pipes, leaking toilets, backed sewage, broken HVAC systems, and more. They understand that emergencies can happen at any time, which is why they’re available 24/7. The Better Business Bureau gave JSP Home Services an A+ rating, while Home Advisor named them as an “Elite Service.” They can work on any make or model and have an indoor air quality specialist on their team. Call (845) 250-6470 to learn how their Kingston plumbers and technicians can help your home or business.

"DO NOT JOIN THE JSP Home Care Club! In 2024 they began billing me twice every month for my membership in the Home Care Club; this continued into 2025. When I realized this a few months later, I contacted them and spoke to Robin who promised to refund the money--they owed me over $300--he did not refund all of it. Through several back and forths (this has been going on since August 2025) I have gotten a little more back but not the entire amount. Had to get the NYS Division of Consumer Affairs involved. My advocate managed to get a few more bucks out of them. I disputed the charges with my bank; JSP forked over a bit more, but still not all of it.They owe me $135. They do not respond in a timely fashion, if at all. They have a bot taking calls, so speaking with an actual human being is virtually impossible. I did receive one unsigned email from someone telling me to "check my records". I have informed them that I will be taking them to court. "

Norma H on January 2026

At JSP Home Services, their Kingston plumbers and HVAC technicians are dedicated to providing excellent customer service and will get the job done right the first time. They have over 50 years of combined experience helping individuals with matters such as bursting pipes, leaking toilets, backed sewage, broken HVAC systems, and more. They understand that emergencies can happen at any time, which is why they’re available 24/7. The Better Business Bureau gave JSP Home Services an A+ rating, while Home Advisor named them as an “Elite Service.” They can work on any make or model and have an indoor air quality specialist on their team. Call (845) 250-6470 to learn how their Kingston plumbers and technicians can help your home or business.

"DO NOT JOIN THE JSP Home Care Club! In 2024 they began billing me twice every month for my membership in the Home Care Club; this continued into 2025. When I realized this a few months later, I contacted them and spoke to Robin who promised to refund the money--they owed me over $300--he did not refund all of it. Through several back and forths (this has been going on since August 2025) I have gotten a little more back but not the entire amount. Had to get the NYS Division of Consumer Affairs involved. My advocate managed to get a few more bucks out of them. I disputed the charges with my bank; JSP forked over a bit more, but still not all of it.They owe me $135. They do not respond in a timely fashion, if at all. They have a bot taking calls, so speaking with an actual human being is virtually impossible. I did receive one unsigned email from someone telling me to "check my records". I have informed them that I will be taking them to court. "

Norma H on January 2026


Avatar for Fajardo Plumbing

Fajardo Plumbing

4.92(
6
)
Approved Pro

Fajardo Plumbing

4.92(
6
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
60 local quotes requested
8 years of experience

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"Removed broken water heater and replaced all in the same day we contacted them- very satisfied with the experience Would strongly recommend them"

Tim L on August 2025

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"Removed broken water heater and replaced all in the same day we contacted them- very satisfied with the experience Would strongly recommend them"

Tim L on August 2025


Avatar for JSP Home Services

JSP Home Services

4.41(
106
)
Approved Pro

JSP Home Services

4.41(
106
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
20 local quotes requested
20 years of experience

At JSP Home Services, their Kingston plumbers and HVAC technicians are dedicated to providing excellent customer service and will get the job done right the first time. They have over 50 years of combined experience helping individuals with matters such as bursting pipes, leaking toilets, backed sewage, broken HVAC systems, and more. They understand that emergencies can happen at any time, which is why they're available 24/7. The Better Business Bureau gave JSP Home Services an A+ rating, while Home Advisor named them as an Elite Service. They can work on any make or model and have an indoor air quality specialist on their team. Call (845) 331-8473 to learn how their Kingston plumbers and technicians can help your home or business.

"August 26 called JSP out to check on my xtrol pressure water tank because it was making a clicking noise that was coming from the power switch. Came out same day said the bladder ruptured would need a new tank. I agreed because the tank was 12 years old. Installed was a flex lite tank which he said was better. I'm a senior and a widow took his word for it. I paid $2172.66. It was not itemized. He gave me a $50 discount. He told me I would get water bursts for a while coming from faucets. Well he was right, however I lost pressure in my kitchen and bathroom faucets and the toilet was rumbling when filling and flushed. I called them out to check. He did not go under the sinks to clear the lines, instead he said it must be your faucets. He quoted me a price of $1303.48 for kitchen faucet if they picked it out fully installed or $756 if I bought the faucet myself. 3 strikes your out. Didnt fix problem. Found out I was over charged for flex tank $1200 instead."

karen K on September 2025

At JSP Home Services, their Kingston plumbers and HVAC technicians are dedicated to providing excellent customer service and will get the job done right the first time. They have over 50 years of combined experience helping individuals with matters such as bursting pipes, leaking toilets, backed sewage, broken HVAC systems, and more. They understand that emergencies can happen at any time, which is why they're available 24/7. The Better Business Bureau gave JSP Home Services an A+ rating, while Home Advisor named them as an Elite Service. They can work on any make or model and have an indoor air quality specialist on their team. Call (845) 331-8473 to learn how their Kingston plumbers and technicians can help your home or business.

"August 26 called JSP out to check on my xtrol pressure water tank because it was making a clicking noise that was coming from the power switch. Came out same day said the bladder ruptured would need a new tank. I agreed because the tank was 12 years old. Installed was a flex lite tank which he said was better. I'm a senior and a widow took his word for it. I paid $2172.66. It was not itemized. He gave me a $50 discount. He told me I would get water bursts for a while coming from faucets. Well he was right, however I lost pressure in my kitchen and bathroom faucets and the toilet was rumbling when filling and flushed. I called them out to check. He did not go under the sinks to clear the lines, instead he said it must be your faucets. He quoted me a price of $1303.48 for kitchen faucet if they picked it out fully installed or $756 if I bought the faucet myself. 3 strikes your out. Didnt fix problem. Found out I was over charged for flex tank $1200 instead."

karen K on September 2025


Avatar for Black Bear Fuel Oil, Plumbing, Heating and A/C

Black Bear Fuel Oil, Plumbing, Heating and A/C

4.91(
66
)
Approved Pro

Black Bear Fuel Oil, Plumbing, Heating and A/C

4.91(
66
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
28 local quotes requested
19 years of experience

Locally owned and operated by lifetime Sullivan County resident Bob Mapes and his family, Black Bear Fuel Oil provides one-stop convenience with a personal touch for all your home comfort and commercial service needs. Whether you need heating oil for your home or business, plumbing or HVAC maintenance and installations, or 24/7/365 emergency service, Black Bear will be there when and where you need us. You can rely on Black Bear for: ∎honest, prompt and courteous service ∎full-service home comfort and commercial fuel support ∎trained, knowledgeable technicians ∎24/7/365 emergency coverage ∎individual attention ∎reliable supply and quality products

"Highly recommended! Their furnace proposal was fairly priced. Arrival was very punctual and installation was neatly and professionally done. Very satisfied with Black Bear service."

Michael E W on August 2025

Locally owned and operated by lifetime Sullivan County resident Bob Mapes and his family, Black Bear Fuel Oil provides one-stop convenience with a personal touch for all your home comfort and commercial service needs. Whether you need heating oil for your home or business, plumbing or HVAC maintenance and installations, or 24/7/365 emergency service, Black Bear will be there when and where you need us. You can rely on Black Bear for: ∎honest, prompt and courteous service ∎full-service home comfort and commercial fuel support ∎trained, knowledgeable technicians ∎24/7/365 emergency coverage ∎individual attention ∎reliable supply and quality products

"Highly recommended! Their furnace proposal was fairly priced. Arrival was very punctual and installation was neatly and professionally done. Very satisfied with Black Bear service."

Michael E W on August 2025


Avatar for Archibald Heating & Air Conditioning

Archibald Heating & Air Conditioning

4.65(
33
)
Approved Pro

Archibald Heating & Air Conditioning

4.65(
33
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
88 years of experience

Archibald Heating & Air Conditioning has been providing top quality work for homeowners and Commercial Property owners in the Ulster and Dutchess County Area since 1938. Archibald Heating and Air conditioning was established in 1938 by my Grandparents William P. and Marvel Archibald. My Grandfather's vision of a strong contractor that can be "trusted" begins to take shape. He creates the Archibald Heating and Air Conditioning "Mission Statement". My Grandfather operated the company until his retirement in 1959 when my Father Wayne G. took over daily operations. I received ownership of the company in1989 with my Fathers retirement. The staff of Archibald Heating and Air Conditioning to this day strives to continue the vision of my Grandfather and Father. Never polluted by corporate buy-outs, driven soley by numbers or strictly profit oriented, we are truly driven by the commitment of a lasting and healthy relationship with you the client. We are currently training generation number four to receive the gift of daily operations inside one of the Hudson Valleys premier HVAC Contracting companies. We specialize in certifications, cleaning, installation, repair & maintenance of all makes & models of Furnaces & Central Air Conditioning units for your home. We welcome the opportunity to show you what experience, expertise & quality products can mean for the value of your home. Whether it�s small repair work or complete installation, we can handle any task with ease. We stand committed to getting the job done with highest quality workmanship a priority. We are a referral based company. People refer their friends and family to us because of the trust we've earned here in the Ulster and Dutchess County Area. We believe in open communication & up front pricing with no hidden surprises. We will be happy to provide a list of satisfied customers who will give reference to the quality of our work, upon request. Call Archibald Heating & Air Conditioning for the comfort of your family & the value of your home. Thank you for taking the time out of your busy schedule to review our company profile. We hope that you seek in your job the quality and service that this company can provide. Thank you for considering us as a potential supplier for your mechanical construction and service needs. DeWitt J. Archibald President

"Family owned business who shows up when they say they will, does excellent work at a very fair price. Honest, personable, and most of all reliable, stand behind their work. Highly recommend this business. They have also cleaned and maintained my furnace in the home I reside in, excellent people to work with."

Margaret A on October 2023

Archibald Heating & Air Conditioning has been providing top quality work for homeowners and Commercial Property owners in the Ulster and Dutchess County Area since 1938. Archibald Heating and Air conditioning was established in 1938 by my Grandparents William P. and Marvel Archibald. My Grandfather's vision of a strong contractor that can be "trusted" begins to take shape. He creates the Archibald Heating and Air Conditioning "Mission Statement". My Grandfather operated the company until his retirement in 1959 when my Father Wayne G. took over daily operations. I received ownership of the company in1989 with my Fathers retirement. The staff of Archibald Heating and Air Conditioning to this day strives to continue the vision of my Grandfather and Father. Never polluted by corporate buy-outs, driven soley by numbers or strictly profit oriented, we are truly driven by the commitment of a lasting and healthy relationship with you the client. We are currently training generation number four to receive the gift of daily operations inside one of the Hudson Valleys premier HVAC Contracting companies. We specialize in certifications, cleaning, installation, repair & maintenance of all makes & models of Furnaces & Central Air Conditioning units for your home. We welcome the opportunity to show you what experience, expertise & quality products can mean for the value of your home. Whether it�s small repair work or complete installation, we can handle any task with ease. We stand committed to getting the job done with highest quality workmanship a priority. We are a referral based company. People refer their friends and family to us because of the trust we've earned here in the Ulster and Dutchess County Area. We believe in open communication & up front pricing with no hidden surprises. We will be happy to provide a list of satisfied customers who will give reference to the quality of our work, upon request. Call Archibald Heating & Air Conditioning for the comfort of your family & the value of your home. Thank you for taking the time out of your busy schedule to review our company profile. We hope that you seek in your job the quality and service that this company can provide. Thank you for considering us as a potential supplier for your mechanical construction and service needs. DeWitt J. Archibald President

"Family owned business who shows up when they say they will, does excellent work at a very fair price. Honest, personable, and most of all reliable, stand behind their work. Highly recommend this business. They have also cleaned and maintained my furnace in the home I reside in, excellent people to work with."

Margaret A on October 2023


Avatar for Cassidy Plumbing and Heating, Inc

Cassidy Plumbing and Heating, Inc

4.72(
25
)
Approved Pro

Cassidy Plumbing and Heating, Inc

4.72(
25
)
Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
14 local quotes requested
34 years of experience

We are a fully licensed and insured plumbing and heating service offering comprehensive services for plumbing and heating in Westchester NY, Putnam NY, Southern Dutchess and the surrounding areas. Our services include toilet repair, hot water heaters, leak repair, drain cleaning, boiler services and much more. A complete listing of the services offered by our professional plumbers can be found on our website. In addition to plumbing and heating services for existing homes and new construction, we offer 24-hour emergency service for plumbing emergencies. Check our website www.cassidyplumbinginc.com for our specials.

"Came quick Completed "

Jessica A on December 2025

We are a fully licensed and insured plumbing and heating service offering comprehensive services for plumbing and heating in Westchester NY, Putnam NY, Southern Dutchess and the surrounding areas. Our services include toilet repair, hot water heaters, leak repair, drain cleaning, boiler services and much more. A complete listing of the services offered by our professional plumbers can be found on our website. In addition to plumbing and heating services for existing homes and new construction, we offer 24-hour emergency service for plumbing emergencies. Check our website www.cassidyplumbinginc.com for our specials.

"Came quick Completed "

Jessica A on December 2025


Avatar for Mr. Rooter of Poughkeepsie

Mr. Rooter of Poughkeepsie

4.56(
9
)
Approved Pro

Mr. Rooter of Poughkeepsie

4.56(
9
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
16 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

If your overflowing toilet causing your wallet to drain, contact Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Poughkeepsie today. Our highly trained plumbers in Poughkeepsie have the tools and technology to not only accurately diagnose the cause and root of the problem but to create lasting solutions. We understand your time is precious, which is why we work quickly and efficiently. Our team is available 24/7 to handle everything from broken pipes to clogged drains.

"Good work- well done"

Fred R on November 2024

If your overflowing toilet causing your wallet to drain, contact Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Poughkeepsie today. Our highly trained plumbers in Poughkeepsie have the tools and technology to not only accurately diagnose the cause and root of the problem but to create lasting solutions. We understand your time is precious, which is why we work quickly and efficiently. Our team is available 24/7 to handle everything from broken pipes to clogged drains.

"Good work- well done"

Fred R on November 2024

...
Showing 1-10 of 554

The New Paltz, NY homeowners’ guide to water heater installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.