Top-rated water heater repair or service pros.

Get matched with top water heater repair or service pros in Carthage, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Top-Rated Water heater repair or service pros in Carthage - Updated Nov 2026

Avatar for Summers Plumbing Heating & Cooling - Greenfield
Summers Plumbing Heating & Cooling - Greenfield
4.4(
27
)
Water Heater - Repair or Service

Serving Carthage, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 2013

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Same-day service. I found an online coupon for $99 clean out special which they honored. I wasn't charged a service fee. The man took his time, was very thorough, very friendly, and helpful. He explained everything and offered to have someone come out tomorrow and run a free diagnosis service with a camera to see if there would be a problem with anymore blockage. Very nice company."
Tankless Water Heater install day!
Always a welcoming face to help with your HVAC and Plumbing Needs
Yard Sign
Spring AC Check
24 Hour Service

+9

Response time1 day
Response rate100%
Recommended by85%of homeowners
Avatar for Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Indianapolis & Central Indiana
Mr. Rooter Plumbing of Indianapolis & Central Indiana
4.1(
463
)
Water Heater - Repair or Service

Serving Carthage, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1970

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"The water heater in a rental unit that I own finally bit the dust.  My tentant didn't have hot water (obviously) so I was in a hurry to replace it.  I purchased the deal on Angie's List Thursday night hoping that i would be able to call the next day and get it done the same day.  I called Mr. Rooter first thing the next morning and they were able to schedule me for the that evening.  They arrived on time and got right to work.  They even went the extra mile and rerouted the pressure release with PEX because of the odd configuration of the utility closet.
$879 for a new water heater with installation is obviously more than it would cost me to do it myself, but it's still reasononable.  I couldn't rope someone into helping me install a new one on such short notice on a Friday night, and this was an emergency.  Mr. Rooter came through, and I have no complaints.
"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+5

Recommended by78%of homeowners
Avatar for Cook & Perry Plumbing
Cook & Perry Plumbing
5.0(
6
)
Water Heater - Repair or Service

Serving Carthage, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 2024

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"It was awesome the guy that came was there the same day within an hour or two very quick with all of it really not just showing up he pretty much knew what needed fixed just by what I told him so after he tested it he was correct on it and he changed both parts not just the one that was bad on my water heater so I wouldn’t have issues a week from now to I would recommend them and use them again in a minute"
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+7

Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Choice Home Warranty
Choice Home Warranty
4.0(
5,680
)
Water Heater - Repair or Service

Serving Carthage, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 2008

Emergency services offered

Credit card accepted

"I specified that it was a tankless water heater, yet not surprisingly I was referred to a plumber who didn't know anything about tankless heaters, resulting in a waste of a couple of days. The second person did know about them, and so far the repair is working (fingers crossed). I wish CHW would pay attention to the details in my claim."
Recommended by81%of homeowners
Avatar for American Home Shield – Home Warranty
American Home Shield – Home Warranty
3.5(
5,689
)
Water Heater - Repair or Service

Serving Carthage, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1971

Credit card accepted

"AHS is ok. They cover repairs of most everything under the roof of your house. The companies that contract with them are not always the best. You call AHS with the issue, they send a fax to the repair company and give you the contact info. If they don't contact you within 24 hours, you call them. Sometimes they answer, sometimes they don't. When they arrive (usually three days or so later), they service the item. if it has issues within the 90 days, you call AHS again, they are sent out with no charge. If the serviceman decides the unit is unrepairable, AHS will allow you to choose a replacement from their listing (usually not as good as what you have) they will install and remove your old item, or give you wholesale amount to buy and install your own. Prices vary on what you want covered and what you want the copay to be, plus where you live. For me it is 49.99 per month with a 75.00 time of service order. You can have more than one item serviced at the same time under the same fee. If you have a SEAR product the repair guys are great. Not that wild about the other ones they send out. But it is a big savings compared to calling someone on your own. The cost of service is only the 75.00 copay."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+2

Recommended by65%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 18
FAQs for water heater repair or service projects in Carthage, IN

Warning signs include fluctuating water temperatures, a pilot light that repeatedly goes out, unusual noises from the tank, or complete heating failure. You might also detect a rotten egg smell, indicating a potential gas leak, or notice water that never reaches the proper temperature. If your water heater is over eight years old and displaying these symptoms, the gas valve is a likely culprit. Professional inspection is recommended, especially if gas odors are present.

Water heater gas valves are not universally interchangeable. Each valve must match your specific water heater's make, model, and specifications. Important compatibility factors include gas type (natural gas vs. propane), BTU rating, connection types, and physical dimensions. Using an incorrect valve can result in poor performance, premature failure, or dangerous gas leaks. Always consult your water heater's documentation or a professional plumber to identify the appropriate replacement valve for your unit.

The Carthage, IN homeowners’ guide to water heater repair or services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.