Top-rated water heater repair or service pros.

Get matched with top water heater repair or service pros in Hightstown, NJ

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Water heater repair or service pros in Hightstown

Avatar for Carney All Seasons

Carney All Seasons

1100 Industrial Blvd
New on HomeAdvisorNew on HomeAdvisor
•Approved Pro

Carney All Seasons

1100 Industrial Blvd
New on HomeAdvisorNew on HomeAdvisor
•Approved Pro
23 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Weare dedicated to providing our clients with the very best in service, installation, and repair for all phases of your plumbing needs. We specialize in a variety of residential services and take pride in the attention to detail put into each of the projects were involved with. Were known for our quality work and the integrity of our business. We look forward to building long-term relationships with our clients, and guarantee your satisfaction.

Weare dedicated to providing our clients with the very best in service, installation, and repair for all phases of your plumbing needs. We specialize in a variety of residential services and take pride in the attention to detail put into each of the projects were involved with. Were known for our quality work and the integrity of our business. We look forward to building long-term relationships with our clients, and guarantee your satisfaction.

Avatar for Hutchinson Plumbing Heating Cooling, LLC

Hutchinson Plumbing Heating Cooling, LLC

621 Chapel Ave
4.26(
82
)
•Approved Pro

Hutchinson Plumbing Heating Cooling, LLC

621 Chapel Ave
4.26(
82
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
84 local quotes requested
77 years of experience

If it is 2 am and your air conditioner just broke, then Hutchinson is here to help. Our company has trained Customer Service Representatives waiting to take your call, with technicians ready to fix your air conditioner 24/7. Whether you are in Gloucester County NJ or Delaware County PA, our fully-stocked repair vehicles contain all of the parts we need to get you cool again; TODAY!

"well there were delays but i forgive that. they did NOT get permits. a new hot water heater was brought and hooked up. But connections were loose and made it inoperable! its taken another plumber and an Electrician to fix what was wrong to actually get hot water. the original cost was $2500. Now add the $500 for 2nd plumber to reinstall the emergency shut off box that was installed improperly. AND an Electrician for $800 To fix the rest. They have not responded to email requesting attention. Technician was great - altho did not know everything necessary to complete my job. this has been a two week nightmare! i am NOT happy!"

Rian M on June 2024

If it is 2 am and your air conditioner just broke, then Hutchinson is here to help. Our company has trained Customer Service Representatives waiting to take your call, with technicians ready to fix your air conditioner 24/7. Whether you are in Gloucester County NJ or Delaware County PA, our fully-stocked repair vehicles contain all of the parts we need to get you cool again; TODAY!

"well there were delays but i forgive that. they did NOT get permits. a new hot water heater was brought and hooked up. But connections were loose and made it inoperable! its taken another plumber and an Electrician to fix what was wrong to actually get hot water. the original cost was $2500. Now add the $500 for 2nd plumber to reinstall the emergency shut off box that was installed improperly. AND an Electrician for $800 To fix the rest. They have not responded to email requesting attention. Technician was great - altho did not know everything necessary to complete my job. this has been a two week nightmare! i am NOT happy!"

Rian M on June 2024

Avatar for Ben Franklin Plumbing of Ocean County

Ben Franklin Plumbing of Ocean County

1130 SHIP AVE
4.55(
371
)
•Approved Pro

Ben Franklin Plumbing of Ocean County

1130 SHIP AVE
4.55(
371
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
175 local quotes requested
30 years of experience

At Benjamin Franklin Plumbing® of Ocean County, we are dedicated to helping families throughout Toms River and all of Ocean County and Monmouth resolve their plumbing problems. We have developed strong relationships with our customers because we prioritize their individual and unique needs. Whether you need us to repair, replace, maintain, or install a new plumbing system or appliance in your home, we are ready to help you. Our team also provides sump pump and sewer line services in addition to water heater, boiler and tankless repairs, installs and replacements. We give you more than promises! We guarantee 100% satisfaction. We know that plumbing problems can disrupt your home, so we are happy to offer emergency plumbing services, convenient online scheduling and several finance options.No job too big or too small. We are available to assist you when it matters most.

"Expensive Damaged my hardwood floor when he knocked his big heavy tool off the toilet onto the floor leaving 2 deep dents in the wood"

Robert R on August 2025

At Benjamin Franklin Plumbing® of Ocean County, we are dedicated to helping families throughout Toms River and all of Ocean County and Monmouth resolve their plumbing problems. We have developed strong relationships with our customers because we prioritize their individual and unique needs. Whether you need us to repair, replace, maintain, or install a new plumbing system or appliance in your home, we are ready to help you. Our team also provides sump pump and sewer line services in addition to water heater, boiler and tankless repairs, installs and replacements. We give you more than promises! We guarantee 100% satisfaction. We know that plumbing problems can disrupt your home, so we are happy to offer emergency plumbing services, convenient online scheduling and several finance options.No job too big or too small. We are available to assist you when it matters most.

"Expensive Damaged my hardwood floor when he knocked his big heavy tool off the toilet onto the floor leaving 2 deep dents in the wood"

Robert R on August 2025

Avatar for Gold Medal Service, LLC (South)

Gold Medal Service, LLC (South)

11 Cotters Lane
4.35(
311
)
•Approved Pro

Gold Medal Service, LLC (South)

11 Cotters Lane
4.35(
311
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
58 local quotes requested
47 years of experience

Gold Medal Services, LLC, warrants and guarantees to the original purchaser, that should Customer accept and purchase Gold Medal's recommended repair, such repair shall be free from defect in materials and workmanship under normal use and conditions for as long as the Customer owns the residence in which the recommended repair was provided or until the Unit in which the Covered Repair was performed, if applicable, is replaced.

"Gold Medal really helped out after our sewer line backed up into our basement. The other pros all wanted us to pay for a camera view first for several hundred. Then the actual cleaning of the line was $500 and up depending on the results of the camera. Gold Medal had a fixed price for cleaning out a sewer line. They came and quickly diagnosed the problem and cleaned it out. Our technician Brett was awesome and even put us in touch with DryTech to assist cleaning up the water damage."

Adam S on July 2024

Gold Medal Services, LLC, warrants and guarantees to the original purchaser, that should Customer accept and purchase Gold Medal's recommended repair, such repair shall be free from defect in materials and workmanship under normal use and conditions for as long as the Customer owns the residence in which the recommended repair was provided or until the Unit in which the Covered Repair was performed, if applicable, is replaced.

"Gold Medal really helped out after our sewer line backed up into our basement. The other pros all wanted us to pay for a camera view first for several hundred. Then the actual cleaning of the line was $500 and up depending on the results of the camera. Gold Medal had a fixed price for cleaning out a sewer line. They came and quickly diagnosed the problem and cleaned it out. Our technician Brett was awesome and even put us in touch with DryTech to assist cleaning up the water damage."

Adam S on July 2024

Avatar for Horizon Services, Inc. (NJ)

Horizon Services, Inc. (NJ)

17 Roland Ave
4.75(
10
)
•Approved Pro

Horizon Services, Inc. (NJ)

17 Roland Ave
4.75(
10
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
72 local quotes requested

Experience The Horizon Difference. On-Time Service. Up-Front Pricing. And The Job Done Right and Clean the First Time. GUARANTEED! Horizon Services is the regions largest and most well respected plumbing, heating and air conditioning company, with nearly 600 employees serving tens of thousands of homeowners throughout Delaware, Southeastern Pennsylvania, Southern New Jersey, and Northeastern Maryland. After a quarter of a century in business, Horizons Services remains fully committed to setting the industry standard for customer service, installation, and focusing on things that are important to busy homeowners: respect for their time, their home and their property; up-front pricing, and an unconditional 100% money back guarantee.

"A"

Michael G on September 2023

Experience The Horizon Difference. On-Time Service. Up-Front Pricing. And The Job Done Right and Clean the First Time. GUARANTEED! Horizon Services is the regions largest and most well respected plumbing, heating and air conditioning company, with nearly 600 employees serving tens of thousands of homeowners throughout Delaware, Southeastern Pennsylvania, Southern New Jersey, and Northeastern Maryland. After a quarter of a century in business, Horizons Services remains fully committed to setting the industry standard for customer service, installation, and focusing on things that are important to busy homeowners: respect for their time, their home and their property; up-front pricing, and an unconditional 100% money back guarantee.

"A"

Michael G on September 2023

Avatar for Gold Medal Service, LLC (East)

Gold Medal Service, LLC (East)

45 Park Rd.
4.05(
125
)
•Approved Pro

Gold Medal Service, LLC (East)

45 Park Rd.
4.05(
125
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
32 local quotes requested
47 years of experience

Gold Medal Plumbing, Inc., warrants and guarantees to the original purchaser, that should Customer accept and purchase Gold Medal's recommended repair, such repair shall be free from defect in materials and workmanship under normal use and conditions for as long as the Customer owns the residence in which the recommended repair was provided or until the Unit in which the covered repair was performed, if applicable, is replaced.

"Great advice and excellent service"

Albert F on August 2025

Gold Medal Plumbing, Inc., warrants and guarantees to the original purchaser, that should Customer accept and purchase Gold Medal's recommended repair, such repair shall be free from defect in materials and workmanship under normal use and conditions for as long as the Customer owns the residence in which the recommended repair was provided or until the Unit in which the covered repair was performed, if applicable, is replaced.

"Great advice and excellent service"

Albert F on August 2025

Avatar for Len The Plumber, LLC.

Len The Plumber, LLC.

2091 SPRINGDALE RD
2.75(
4
)
•Approved Pro

Len The Plumber, LLC.

2091 SPRINGDALE RD
2.75(
4
)
•Approved Pro
356 local quotes requested
29 years of experience

Len The Plumber, LLC. is a leading plumbing and drain company serving New Jersey. Our certified professional plumbers are available same day to assist residential customers in Burlington County and Camden County. Our knowledgeable plumbers have years of experience dealing with a wide variety of plumbing issues including plumbing repairs, drain cleaning, water heaters, well systems, heating systems, sewer, water, and gas lines. We’re open 7 days a week with no extra charge on evenings or weekends!

"Did not go well at all with Len the Plumber was over charged and feel scammed, Len the Plumber, Technician Len Feldman started approx. 12pm until 3pm most of time going over the cost, taking pictures and finding everything possible that needed to be done and presented 10-page contract. Len Feldman (Technican) assessed the problem that was a leaking outside faucet that he explained froze over the winter and needed to be replaced. While water was leaking he did not turn off the inside valve and requested to have water company (Trenton Water Works) come out and turn off water by the main water line. TWW came out several times but could not find the line and sent out a third construction worker to locate the water line. Meantime Len left his personal contact # and promised to return as soon as the main water line was shut off. When Water Works returned on 6/25 could not reach Len, but was able to locate the main water line Len finally called back and said it would be ok he would be able to turn the water off was currently in Mays Landing that is approx. 65 miles away and could not return 6/25 but would be at my home to complete the job 6/26 am. After 9am no call no Len, I called again several times when finally able to reach him at around 9:30am, said he spoke to Supervisor and could not do anything until the main water line was completely shut off. I called Len the Plumber office spoke to Office Manager Cathy#610-616-3377 she said would try to get someone out asap, by later in the afternoon no return call from Cathy. At this point and 2 days later for an emergency it was time to find another Plumber and I cancelled everything at Len the Plumber. The Plumber came out Friday 6/27 completed the entire job within 1 hour, turned off the inside valve connected to the outside leak immediately as well as water to install the same job Len the Plumber contracted to do that, Len said would take at least 6 hours. Main Water Line never had to be touched!!! I am appalled with Len the Plumber that I could trust thru Angi's List with a good reliable repetition. This company had no consideration about leaving me and my family including my 88-year-old handicapped mother without running water for days, all he was concerned about was how much commission he could make off someone in a vulnerable situation."

sharon c on July 2025

Len The Plumber, LLC. is a leading plumbing and drain company serving New Jersey. Our certified professional plumbers are available same day to assist residential customers in Burlington County and Camden County. Our knowledgeable plumbers have years of experience dealing with a wide variety of plumbing issues including plumbing repairs, drain cleaning, water heaters, well systems, heating systems, sewer, water, and gas lines. We’re open 7 days a week with no extra charge on evenings or weekends!

"Did not go well at all with Len the Plumber was over charged and feel scammed, Len the Plumber, Technician Len Feldman started approx. 12pm until 3pm most of time going over the cost, taking pictures and finding everything possible that needed to be done and presented 10-page contract. Len Feldman (Technican) assessed the problem that was a leaking outside faucet that he explained froze over the winter and needed to be replaced. While water was leaking he did not turn off the inside valve and requested to have water company (Trenton Water Works) come out and turn off water by the main water line. TWW came out several times but could not find the line and sent out a third construction worker to locate the water line. Meantime Len left his personal contact # and promised to return as soon as the main water line was shut off. When Water Works returned on 6/25 could not reach Len, but was able to locate the main water line Len finally called back and said it would be ok he would be able to turn the water off was currently in Mays Landing that is approx. 65 miles away and could not return 6/25 but would be at my home to complete the job 6/26 am. After 9am no call no Len, I called again several times when finally able to reach him at around 9:30am, said he spoke to Supervisor and could not do anything until the main water line was completely shut off. I called Len the Plumber office spoke to Office Manager Cathy#610-616-3377 she said would try to get someone out asap, by later in the afternoon no return call from Cathy. At this point and 2 days later for an emergency it was time to find another Plumber and I cancelled everything at Len the Plumber. The Plumber came out Friday 6/27 completed the entire job within 1 hour, turned off the inside valve connected to the outside leak immediately as well as water to install the same job Len the Plumber contracted to do that, Len said would take at least 6 hours. Main Water Line never had to be touched!!! I am appalled with Len the Plumber that I could trust thru Angi's List with a good reliable repetition. This company had no consideration about leaving me and my family including my 88-year-old handicapped mother without running water for days, all he was concerned about was how much commission he could make off someone in a vulnerable situation."

sharon c on July 2025

Avatar for Horizon Services

Horizon Services

17 Roland Avenue
4.42(
76
)
•Approved Pro

Horizon Services

17 Roland Avenue
4.42(
76
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
1571 local quotes requested
38 years of experience

Horizon Services is the region’s largest and most well respected plumbing, heating and air conditioning company, with nearly 600 employees serving tens of thousands of homeowners throughout Delaware, Southeastern Pennsylvania, Southern New Jersey, and Northeastern Maryland. After a quarter of a century in business, Horizon Services remains fully committed to setting the industry standard for customer service, installation, and focusing on things that are important to busy homeowners: respect for their time, their home and their property; up-front pricing, and an unconditional 100% money back guarantee.

"Peter was exceptional at his job, very knowledgeable. Inform me each step of the way during the process, very professional."

Keisha W on August 2025

Horizon Services is the region’s largest and most well respected plumbing, heating and air conditioning company, with nearly 600 employees serving tens of thousands of homeowners throughout Delaware, Southeastern Pennsylvania, Southern New Jersey, and Northeastern Maryland. After a quarter of a century in business, Horizon Services remains fully committed to setting the industry standard for customer service, installation, and focusing on things that are important to busy homeowners: respect for their time, their home and their property; up-front pricing, and an unconditional 100% money back guarantee.

"Peter was exceptional at his job, very knowledgeable. Inform me each step of the way during the process, very professional."

Keisha W on August 2025

EDDIE B PLUMBING INC

PO BOX 3054
4.24(
93
)
•Approved Pro

EDDIE B PLUMBING INC

PO BOX 3054
4.24(
93
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
948 local quotes requested
37 years of experience

Looking for reliable plumbing services in Philadelphia? Look no further than Eddie B Plumbing Inc! Our team of experts specializes in water heaters and is fully licensed (State Lic. #7274). Contact us today for all your plumbing needs! Additional phone: 856-303-8151

"it was a 5. it was excellent. because we had that issue the night before i called him 7:30 he called back after 30 mins and have a guy came out after 15 mins."

MARIETTA A on April 2023

Looking for reliable plumbing services in Philadelphia? Look no further than Eddie B Plumbing Inc! Our team of experts specializes in water heaters and is fully licensed (State Lic. #7274). Contact us today for all your plumbing needs! Additional phone: 856-303-8151

"it was a 5. it was excellent. because we had that issue the night before i called him 7:30 he called back after 30 mins and have a guy came out after 15 mins."

MARIETTA A on April 2023

Avatar for Special Construction LLC

Special Construction LLC

2106 Wainwright Rd
4.85(
41
)
•Approved Pro

Special Construction LLC

2106 Wainwright Rd
4.85(
41
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers
839 local quotes requested

Angie's List MEMBERS only special - $250 off any remodeling or flooring project $5,000 or more! We specialize in kitchen, basement, and bathroom remodeling. Additionally we refinish and install hardwood, laminate, and tile floors. All work is completed to the customers satisfaction. No job too big or too small. Call us today for a FREE QUOTE!

"Was great and did a really good job on my Garage. Very prompt and responsive."

Jeff M on August 2025

Angie's List MEMBERS only special - $250 off any remodeling or flooring project $5,000 or more! We specialize in kitchen, basement, and bathroom remodeling. Additionally we refinish and install hardwood, laminate, and tile floors. All work is completed to the customers satisfaction. No job too big or too small. Call us today for a FREE QUOTE!

"Was great and did a really good job on my Garage. Very prompt and responsive."

Jeff M on August 2025

...
Showing 1-10 of 970
FAQs for water heater repair or service projects in Hightstown, NJ

Warning signs include fluctuating water temperatures, a pilot light that repeatedly goes out, unusual noises from the tank, or complete heating failure. You might also detect a rotten egg smell, indicating a potential gas leak, or notice water that never reaches the proper temperature. If your water heater is over eight years old and displaying these symptoms, the gas valve is a likely culprit. Professional inspection is recommended, especially if gas odors are present.

Water heater gas valves are not universally interchangeable. Each valve must match your specific water heater's make, model, and specifications. Important compatibility factors include gas type (natural gas vs. propane), BTU rating, connection types, and physical dimensions. Using an incorrect valve can result in poor performance, premature failure, or dangerous gas leaks. Always consult your water heater's documentation or a professional plumber to identify the appropriate replacement valve for your unit.

The Hightstown, NJ homeowners’ guide to water heater repair or services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles