Top-rated appraisal real estate pros.

Get matched with top appraisal real estate pros in Indianapolis, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Appraisal real estate pros in Indianapolis

Pierce Appraisal, Inc.

5437 Indermuhle Lane
4.79(
21
)
•Approved Pro

Pierce Appraisal, Inc.

5437 Indermuhle Lane
4.79(
21
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers
24 years of experience

With over 10 years of experience helping both homeowners and lenders, I can help with any residential appraisal services you may require! Whether it is insurance, property tax, settlements, or real estate. I make it as easy as possible for the homeowner! For a knowledgeable quick and easy service done right the first time, please call today! We DO NOT appraise commercial properties or do land surveys, both of which require additional licensing.

"Professional, knowledgeable, pleasant to work with, and very punctual. Bryan showed up before our appointment to get the work started. He worked quickly and was extremely helpful. The appraisal was delivered exactly when he said it would have. Overall happy that I worked with him."

James P on July 2024

With over 10 years of experience helping both homeowners and lenders, I can help with any residential appraisal services you may require! Whether it is insurance, property tax, settlements, or real estate. I make it as easy as possible for the homeowner! For a knowledgeable quick and easy service done right the first time, please call today! We DO NOT appraise commercial properties or do land surveys, both of which require additional licensing.

"Professional, knowledgeable, pleasant to work with, and very punctual. Bryan showed up before our appointment to get the work started. He worked quickly and was extremely helpful. The appraisal was delivered exactly when he said it would have. Overall happy that I worked with him."

James P on July 2024

Avatar for Core Redevelopment

Core Redevelopment

No reviews yet

Core Redevelopment

No reviews yet
35 years of experience

Core Redevelopment provides Apartments in Indianapolis, IN . Core Redevelopment was started in 2009 by an experienced industry professional seeking to pursue fun and creative real estate solutions in today’s tumultuous market. Core is a licensed general contractor, property manager, and a member of The National Association of Home Builders. Core Redevelopment is your premier property management company. Our priority is our residents and our mission is to bring the best services to each of our beautiful communities.

Core Redevelopment provides Apartments in Indianapolis, IN . Core Redevelopment was started in 2009 by an experienced industry professional seeking to pursue fun and creative real estate solutions in today’s tumultuous market. Core is a licensed general contractor, property manager, and a member of The National Association of Home Builders. Core Redevelopment is your premier property management company. Our priority is our residents and our mission is to bring the best services to each of our beautiful communities.

ADVANCED BILLIARD SERVICES

Noblesville
5.00(
3
)

ADVANCED BILLIARD SERVICES

Noblesville
5.00(
3
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

OWNER OPERATED, USES SUBS FOR LABOR, COST DETERMINED BY THE JOB. TRAVEL CHARGES MAY APPLY.

OWNER OPERATED, USES SUBS FOR LABOR, COST DETERMINED BY THE JOB. TRAVEL CHARGES MAY APPLY.

Avatar for Indiana Hotel Appraisal

Indiana Hotel Appraisal

4981 N. Franklin Road
No reviews yet

Indiana Hotel Appraisal

4981 N. Franklin Road
No reviews yet
20 years of experience

Hotel appraisals for full-service, select-service, and limited-service properties in Indiana. Guaranteed on-time delivery. In-depth local market expertise and prior experience in all major metropolitan areas.

Hotel appraisals for full-service, select-service, and limited-service properties in Indiana. Guaranteed on-time delivery. In-depth local market expertise and prior experience in all major metropolitan areas.

Avatar for G Thrapp Jewelers

G Thrapp Jewelers

5609 N Illinois
4.84(
38
)

G Thrapp Jewelers

5609 N Illinois
4.84(
38
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

In 1984 Gary Thrapp established G. Thrapp Jewelers in Indianapolis at the corner of 56th and Illinois. Built on the premise of creating a welcoming environment for clients to shop, a visit to G. Thrapp Jewelers is more like visiting an old friend with a warm, comforting, homey feel that includes two fireplaces. G. Thrapp Jewelers carries an extensive selection of bridal and fashion jewelry lines as well as an extensive collection of estate pieces. We are a totally dedicated custom design jeweler under the extraordinary guidance of one of the nations very best designers, Ellen Bower, who is our Vice-President and head of the G. Thrapp Design Studio.

In 1984 Gary Thrapp established G. Thrapp Jewelers in Indianapolis at the corner of 56th and Illinois. Built on the premise of creating a welcoming environment for clients to shop, a visit to G. Thrapp Jewelers is more like visiting an old friend with a warm, comforting, homey feel that includes two fireplaces. G. Thrapp Jewelers carries an extensive selection of bridal and fashion jewelry lines as well as an extensive collection of estate pieces. We are a totally dedicated custom design jeweler under the extraordinary guidance of one of the nations very best designers, Ellen Bower, who is our Vice-President and head of the G. Thrapp Design Studio.

ROBERT J BROWN APPRAISAL SERVICES

PO BOX 19446
5.00(
3
)

ROBERT J BROWN APPRAISAL SERVICES

PO BOX 19446
5.00(
3
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

1 EMPLOYEE. CHARGES BY THE JOB.

1 EMPLOYEE. CHARGES BY THE JOB.

JEWEL BOX JEWELERS

100 S MAIN ST
4.10(
20
)

JEWEL BOX JEWELERS

100 S MAIN ST
4.10(
20
)
Customers say: Terrific value
52 years of experience

2 FULL & 2 PART-TIME EMPLOYEES. SUBS USED FOR WAX MODEL MAKING & CUSTOM JEWELRY CONSTRUCTION. ALTERNATE E-MAIL ADDRESS: SALES@JEWELBOXJEWELERS.NET

"I took a ring into the Jewel Box recently to have it rebuilt and make the band a 2-mil. When I picked up the ring, it was only 1-mil. but they tried to charge me for a 2-mil band. I asked for the back shaft of my old ring back and they told me they typically don?t give the unused gold back? When I insisted, they gave me the back shaft of a size 5 ring when I brought in a 7.5 size. My ring was not rebuilt as agreed, they just took my original gold ring and put the diamond in a new setting. Now I?m worried if they gave me my original diamond back. The Jewel Box was a jeweler you could trust for decades but the new ownership is questionable. "

Reasa P on October 2025

2 FULL & 2 PART-TIME EMPLOYEES. SUBS USED FOR WAX MODEL MAKING & CUSTOM JEWELRY CONSTRUCTION. ALTERNATE E-MAIL ADDRESS: SALES@JEWELBOXJEWELERS.NET

"I took a ring into the Jewel Box recently to have it rebuilt and make the band a 2-mil. When I picked up the ring, it was only 1-mil. but they tried to charge me for a 2-mil band. I asked for the back shaft of my old ring back and they told me they typically don?t give the unused gold back? When I insisted, they gave me the back shaft of a size 5 ring when I brought in a 7.5 size. My ring was not rebuilt as agreed, they just took my original gold ring and put the diamond in a new setting. Now I?m worried if they gave me my original diamond back. The Jewel Box was a jeweler you could trust for decades but the new ownership is questionable. "

Reasa P on October 2025

Avatar for Mike Murgatroy CrossCountry Mortgage

Mike Murgatroy CrossCountry Mortgage

900 NW 17TH AVE
4.94(
503
)

Mike Murgatroy CrossCountry Mortgage

900 NW 17TH AVE
4.94(
503
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Mike Murgatroy has 24 years of lending experience and is an Angi Super Service Award recipient 2012-2022. Mike is also ranked in the top 1% mortgage originators in the United States. With integrity at the core of his values, you can rest assured that Mike Murgatroy will give you informed detailed mortgage advice, the same he would recommend to his own family. We pride ourselves on having a transparent process which we will walk you through every step of the way. Start your application process today by visiting themurgteam.com and find out why so many others continue to bring their business to Mike Murgatroy. NMLS ID# 60099; http://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org

"It went great again. I am a repeat customer. They are professional, organized, and they perform like a well oiled machine. From the application process to the closing A+++++++ They do what they say they are going to do in a timely manner. I cannot say enough about this team. Thank you for another great experience Michael, Peter, Monica, and Connie."

joseph v on March 2022

Mike Murgatroy has 24 years of lending experience and is an Angi Super Service Award recipient 2012-2022. Mike is also ranked in the top 1% mortgage originators in the United States. With integrity at the core of his values, you can rest assured that Mike Murgatroy will give you informed detailed mortgage advice, the same he would recommend to his own family. We pride ourselves on having a transparent process which we will walk you through every step of the way. Start your application process today by visiting themurgteam.com and find out why so many others continue to bring their business to Mike Murgatroy. NMLS ID# 60099; http://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org

"It went great again. I am a repeat customer. They are professional, organized, and they perform like a well oiled machine. From the application process to the closing A+++++++ They do what they say they are going to do in a timely manner. I cannot say enough about this team. Thank you for another great experience Michael, Peter, Monica, and Connie."

joseph v on March 2022

Appraisal Source Inc

PO Box 17486
4.95(
98
)

Appraisal Source Inc

PO Box 17486
4.95(
98
)
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 97% of Angi customers
Recommended by 97% of HomeAdvisor customers

Owner-Operated. No Subs. Cost Is Determined By The Job. No Travel Charges.

"Stacie Johnting, with Appraisal Source, Inc., was very professional and knowledgeable. She explained her process clearly, answered all my questions and completed her appraisal in just a few days. The documents she sent were thorough and succinct. She was great to work with and I will definitely hire her again. I've been recommending her to friends as well."

Marcia R on September 2022

Owner-Operated. No Subs. Cost Is Determined By The Job. No Travel Charges.

"Stacie Johnting, with Appraisal Source, Inc., was very professional and knowledgeable. She explained her process clearly, answered all my questions and completed her appraisal in just a few days. The documents she sent were thorough and succinct. She was great to work with and I will definitely hire her again. I've been recommending her to friends as well."

Marcia R on September 2022

Nick Rodgers

753 E. Water Street
No reviews yet

Nick Rodgers

753 E. Water Street
No reviews yet
12 years of experience

Born and raised in Madison County and ready to serve you with all of your central Indiana real estate needs. With my 9 years of online advertising sales, marketing, negotiating contracts, & managing clients. I have what it takes to either help you market, sell, or purchase your next home. My passion for real estate is why I got in this business. My goal is to make everyone satisfied, and most importantly get the best deal for you. No one is more poised and ready for your call. Call Nick Today any time and let’s talk: Toll Free: 1-877-CALL-NICK Cell: 765-623-9641

Born and raised in Madison County and ready to serve you with all of your central Indiana real estate needs. With my 9 years of online advertising sales, marketing, negotiating contracts, & managing clients. I have what it takes to either help you market, sell, or purchase your next home. My passion for real estate is why I got in this business. My goal is to make everyone satisfied, and most importantly get the best deal for you. No one is more poised and ready for your call. Call Nick Today any time and let’s talk: Toll Free: 1-877-CALL-NICK Cell: 765-623-9641

...
Showing 1-10 of 129
FAQs for appraisal real estate service projects in Indianapolis, IN

The appraisal timeline begins with scheduling, which may take three to five days, depending on local appraiser availability. The on-site evaluation requires one to three hours based on property size and complexity. Following the inspection, appraisers need two to five days for research, analysis, and report preparation. The entire process takes seven to 10 days, though complex properties or government-backed loans may extend this timeframe.

The value of home appraisals extends beyond their immediate expense. They protect buyers from overpaying and help lenders ensure appropriate loan amounts. By providing independent market value verification, home appraisals help prevent potential financial missteps in major property transactions. This protection justifies the upfront cost for most real estate scenarios.

Home appraisers evaluate numerous property elements, including square footage, floor plan functionality, overall condition, and specific features. They document improvements, necessary repairs, and distinctive amenities. These observations are compared against similar properties recently sold in the neighborhood. Appraisers also consider location factors, current market conditions, and relevant zoning or property restrictions.

Yes, home appraisal fees are collected before the final closing. Since lenders require completed home appraisal reports before finalizing loan approvals, this cost occurs earlier in the transaction process. While buyers usually cover this expense, payment methods vary—some pay directly to the appraiser while others include it in closing costs.

Some property owners successfully use recent appraisals when challenging tax assessments. However, tax-assessed values often differ from market valuations. The appeal process involves submitting your appraisal as evidence that the tax authority's valuation exceeds actual market value. Success rates vary by jurisdiction, and the process may require patience and persistence.

From the buyer's perspective, appraisals verify they aren't overpaying for a property. Lenders won't approve financing that exceeds appraised value, potentially requiring buyers to renegotiate or contribute additional cash. Appraisal findings can also inform future improvement planning and investment decisions.

For sellers, preparation makes a difference. Clean, well-maintained properties present better during appraisal evaluations. Some sellers obtain pre-listing appraisals to establish appropriate asking prices, though most rely on the buyer's lender-ordered appraisal during the transaction process.