Top-rated garage door installers and replacers.

Get matched with top garage door installers and replacers in Ithaca, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Garage door installers and replacers in Ithaca

Overhead Door
4.9(
9
)

Serving Ithaca, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1945

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"I called at 8:30 in the morning after coming out and finding the spring had snapped. The door was opened so I removed the car and manually closed the door. I phoned and spoke to a very pleasant receptionist who explained it probably would be a day or two. As it was not an emergency I told them that was fine. When I got home that evening they had already been there and done the repair. They did everything that was necessary and I thought the price was more than fair...especially since I never asked them for a quote. By the way I selected this company based upon the reviews here on Angie's List. <br />"
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Garage Door Supply Co
Garage Door Supply Co
4.9(
7
)

Serving Ithaca, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 2008

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"It went pretty good but there are/were problems with the install. The astragal on the bottom of the door continues to roll-up as the door closes. A crew returned to address this issue but it still exists."
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Art's Overhead Doors
Art's Overhead Doors
5.0(
6
)

Serving Ithaca, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1946

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"These guys were great. The installation went flawless and the guys were on time. I had three overhead doors installed and they looked great. I had a problem with the door (hit the bottom panel with tractor) and they ordered the Panel and it was installed the same week. Great service and highly recommend them. Any issues I had they fixed. Had a spring break two days ago and they came out right on time and fixed it no charge. Thanks guys."
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Baker's Garage Doors Inc
Baker's Garage Doors Inc
5.0(
3
)

Serving Ithaca, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1988

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"Baker's was excellent from the very first phone conversation I had with them.  They provided a selection of quotes that same day by e-mail, the quotes were very detailed and even provided pictures of the product the quote was for.  I compare this with Overhead Door, who took over a week to get a single quote out to us, only after I called and bugged them about it.  Baker's was prompt on the installation day and did a fantastic job!  The door looks and works great!  They showed us that they wanted our business and lived up to that as well. <br />"
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Genson Overhead Door Inc
4.8(
5
)

Serving Ithaca, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1979

Free estimates

Warranties offered

"We had a new overhead garage door  and garage door opener installed. After ordering the new door a spring on the old garage door broke down. They came promptly and replaced the broken spring, but with a wrong size of spring. The door and the garage door opener broke down completely shortly after the wrong spring was installed. The new garage door and opener work fine now and we are very happy with it.  <br />"
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Overhead Door Company of Cortland Inc
5.0(
3
)

Serving Ithaca, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1931

"We were having problems with the automatic garage door openers. I wanted a local business to help us. The business owner returned my first call promptly (after 5pm!) and made an appointment for the next day. The day of the appointment he had to reschedule our appointment, but he was easily reached by cell phone. Arriving promptly, the technician evaluated the problems, and working step by step through the issues. He had all supplies and parts needed in his truck. He checked all rollers, wires, springs and lubricated all during the inspection. He answered all my questions and fixed the problems."
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Genson Overhead Door, Inc.
5.0(
1
)

Serving Ithaca, NY and surrounding areas

"They came out for the quote, arrived on time and gave honest advice (we were thinking of combining the 2 doors into one, but after they checked the area, recommended against it for structural reasons). They scheduled us with-in the time frame we requested and were prompt, efficient, and cleaned up after themselves when done, taking away the old doors and old opener as well. Additional info: 11 months into their 1 year warranty, one of the garage door tracks started sparking when opening/closing it. They promptly answered our email and sent a workman to check it out. He admitted they've never seen this problem before (he had checked with some more experienced colleagues who also never heard of it happening). He checked out everything he could think of and suggested having the wiring checked out. We were able to have that done the same night and all was fine there. The next morning, Genson workmen came out again (fortunately the electrician was also here) and they worked together to discover the problem. Over the 11 months, one of the lag bolts holding up the brackets for the opener, from normal vibrations, had clipped a power line for the lights. There was no way to know the power line was there at installation as it was 2"+ up from the end of the joist, behind the sheetrock ceiling. Genson took responsibility and covered the repair. Very professional, apologized for having to open up the ceiling and the mess that was made in doing so, but they were very careful when removing the sheetrock so that they were able to reuse the same pieces when they were all done. They cleaned up and everything works fine again. Definitely recommend this company to any who need these services!"
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 24
FAQs for garage door installation and replacement projects in Ithaca, NY

Yes, you can replace just one panel if your door is sectional and the damaged panel is available. Most modern residential garage doors have four to six horizontal panels that can be individually replaced. However, finding an exact match becomes challenging for older doors or discontinued styles. For doors over 15 to 20 years old or with multiple damaged panels, a complete door replacement might be more practical and visually consistent.

Minor dents or cosmetic damage can often be repaired without replacing the entire panel, potentially saving you money. However, if the damage affects the door's operation, security, or structural integrity, replacement is often a better investment. 

For extensive damage to multiple panels or older doors where matching is difficult, full door replacement might be more economical in the long run than multiple individual panel replacements.

Your garage door panel might be repairable if the damage is superficial and doesn't affect functionality. Small dents in aluminum panels, minor scratches, or cosmetic issues often don't require full replacement. However, replacement is often necessary if the panel is warped, has large holes, shows extensive rust, or affects how the door operates. A professional garage door technician can evaluate the damage and recommend whether repair or replacement offers the best value and durability.

The Ithaca, NY homeowners’ guide to garage door installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

  • stone home with double garage doors

    Need to replace your garage door? Here’s how much it costs, what factors affect cost, and what to expect.

  • new garage built onto house

    How much does it cost to build a garage? Explore cost factors, budgeting tips, and how a garage adds to your home’s value with our detailed cost guide.

  • Walkout patio with concrete floor

    Wondering who seals concrete? Learn who to hire, when DIY makes sense, and how pros seal driveways and garage floors—start your search now