Top-rated well pump installers and replacers.

Get matched with top well pump installers and replacers in Spencer, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Well pump installers and replacers in Spencer

Nichols Plumbing Services

7266 E County Rd 400 S
5.00(
1
)
Approved Pro

Nichols Plumbing Services

7266 E County Rd 400 S
5.00(
1
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
20 years of experience

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumers needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"Very good service, quick, prompt, and fixed the issue the day after Christmas. Great customer service as well."

Sylvia S on January 2023

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality, and customer service that we provide to meet the consumers needs. It is our mission to provide excellent workmanship and complete customer satisfaction from start to completion of a project. In order to understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety, and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"Very good service, quick, prompt, and fixed the issue the day after Christmas. Great customer service as well."

Sylvia S on January 2023


Avatar for Benjamin Franklin Plumbing - Indianapolis

Benjamin Franklin Plumbing - Indianapolis

5561 W. 74th Street
4.33(
213
)
Approved Pro

Benjamin Franklin Plumbing - Indianapolis

5561 W. 74th Street
4.33(
213
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
487 local quotes requested
40 years of experience

At Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis, we take immense pride in our well-established reputation for delivering dependable plumbing installation services you can rely on. When it comes to plumbing installations, precision and reliability stand as our guiding principles. Our seasoned professional' knowledge of plumbing systems’ ensure that every installation, whether involving new fixtures, water heaters, or piping, is executed correctly. Recognizing that every detail counts, our trained plumbers are focused on every step of the installation process, ensuring a seamless installation and the functionality of your plumbing for years to come. When you opt for Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis for your plumbing installation needs, you're embracing a team that values your satisfaction, respects your time, and channels unwavering dedication to excellence into every project we handle.

"Great work by Brian at Benjamin Franklin plumbing. "

Jerald H on September 2025

At Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis, we take immense pride in our well-established reputation for delivering dependable plumbing installation services you can rely on. When it comes to plumbing installations, precision and reliability stand as our guiding principles. Our seasoned professional' knowledge of plumbing systems’ ensure that every installation, whether involving new fixtures, water heaters, or piping, is executed correctly. Recognizing that every detail counts, our trained plumbers are focused on every step of the installation process, ensuring a seamless installation and the functionality of your plumbing for years to come. When you opt for Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis for your plumbing installation needs, you're embracing a team that values your satisfaction, respects your time, and channels unwavering dedication to excellence into every project we handle.

"Great work by Brian at Benjamin Franklin plumbing. "

Jerald H on September 2025


Avatar for Indiana Well Company

Indiana Well Company

1137 Jody Court
4.60(
5
)
Approved Pro

Indiana Well Company

1137 Jody Court
4.60(
5
)
Approved Pro
11 local quotes requested
1 years of experience

At Indiana Well Company, we pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

"Job got done. Was late and not ready. Not very professional. left behind the water pressure tank ,for me to get rid of. Would not use them again."

Debra P on July 2025

At Indiana Well Company, we pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

"Job got done. Was late and not ready. Not very professional. left behind the water pressure tank ,for me to get rid of. Would not use them again."

Debra P on July 2025


B-Town Maintenance and Renovation

1420 S Walnut
No reviews yet

B-Town Maintenance and Renovation

1420 S Walnut
No reviews yet
25 years of experience

B-town Real Estate is a locally owned and operated company servicing the greater-Bloomington-area. As a broker/owner, Chris Clark leads a team conjoined with B-Town Maintenance & Renovation to provide a full-service real estate experience. If you're looking to buy or sell your home, look no further than B-Town Real Estate. We work well with first-timers as much as seasoned buyers or sellers. Exhausted by all the options and nothing seems perfect? That's what sets us apart from the rest of the brokers. We specialize in making or maintaining efficient and high-quality homes, whether that's through renovation or design services. We lead the way in environmentally-friendly services; every impact counts and we do our part for you. We have raves and reviews to let you know that when you contract us, it's going to be a great experience. And we couldn't do this alone. We operate as a team and love clients who have as creative of style as we do. Give us a call or email today to see what we can do for you.

B-town Real Estate is a locally owned and operated company servicing the greater-Bloomington-area. As a broker/owner, Chris Clark leads a team conjoined with B-Town Maintenance & Renovation to provide a full-service real estate experience. If you're looking to buy or sell your home, look no further than B-Town Real Estate. We work well with first-timers as much as seasoned buyers or sellers. Exhausted by all the options and nothing seems perfect? That's what sets us apart from the rest of the brokers. We specialize in making or maintaining efficient and high-quality homes, whether that's through renovation or design services. We lead the way in environmentally-friendly services; every impact counts and we do our part for you. We have raves and reviews to let you know that when you contract us, it's going to be a great experience. And we couldn't do this alone. We operate as a team and love clients who have as creative of style as we do. Give us a call or email today to see what we can do for you.


Dewey Sizemore/ Dewey Sizemore Excavating & Buildi

2247 Grandma Barnes Rd
5.00(
4
)

Dewey Sizemore/ Dewey Sizemore Excavating & Buildi

2247 Grandma Barnes Rd
5.00(
4
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Dewey Sizemore Excavating & Building is an an owner-operated Excavating company. We have been in business for over 20 years and specialize in more than just Excavating. We offer sewer, water, spigots, drains, basements, coy ponds, driveways, retaining walls, foundations, footers, rough grades, finish grades, demolition, room additions, concrete, and much more! No job too small! Very competitive pricing and free estimates.

"Dewey rebuilt the Bell tower on the historic county Courthouse very professional and payed excellent attention to detail. We will definitely be using him again"

Andy R on September 2019

Dewey Sizemore Excavating & Building is an an owner-operated Excavating company. We have been in business for over 20 years and specialize in more than just Excavating. We offer sewer, water, spigots, drains, basements, coy ponds, driveways, retaining walls, foundations, footers, rough grades, finish grades, demolition, room additions, concrete, and much more! No job too small! Very competitive pricing and free estimates.

"Dewey rebuilt the Bell tower on the historic county Courthouse very professional and payed excellent attention to detail. We will definitely be using him again"

Andy R on September 2019


Wicked Web Design & SEO

1312 North Monroe St. Suite 137
5.00(
7
)

Wicked Web Design & SEO

1312 North Monroe St. Suite 137
5.00(
7
)
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Want an Awesome looking website that also Ranks in the search engines? If you're expecting for it to generate new customers it's vital potential customers find it when they search. This is called Search Engine Optimization. Everyone and their brother are building websites these days, and ironically they are all SEO experts. Most people are smart enough to figure out this isn't true. We are 100% from the United States. Our team is comprised of Graphic Designers, a content writer and one of the Best SEO's in the Country. We have hundreds of #1 Rankings for some of the hardest search terms available. Ask to see some samples. Wicked Web Design is a division of Justin Monk SEO. It became a division to full-fill the entire package. Anyone can build a website, but if the on-page optimization isn’t done correctly the website will never rank. The customer then is forced to pay to have it re-done. Here’s where it gets tricky. Everyone says they are good at SEO, when actually very few are. It definitely isn’t fair to you the customer. Please do your homework and check their rankings. If they don’t have rankings chances are they aren’t very good. We rank in every city we have targeted. Ask to see the list. Awesome web Design mixed with Dominating SEO is a combination any company looking to destroy their competition can’t go without. Please allow extra time for our website (Visit Website) to load, the Demo is displaying all features available which dramatically slow down the loading speed. All the features are displayed so you can choose which ones you want for your website which will be much faster.

Want an Awesome looking website that also Ranks in the search engines? If you're expecting for it to generate new customers it's vital potential customers find it when they search. This is called Search Engine Optimization. Everyone and their brother are building websites these days, and ironically they are all SEO experts. Most people are smart enough to figure out this isn't true. We are 100% from the United States. Our team is comprised of Graphic Designers, a content writer and one of the Best SEO's in the Country. We have hundreds of #1 Rankings for some of the hardest search terms available. Ask to see some samples. Wicked Web Design is a division of Justin Monk SEO. It became a division to full-fill the entire package. Anyone can build a website, but if the on-page optimization isn’t done correctly the website will never rank. The customer then is forced to pay to have it re-done. Here’s where it gets tricky. Everyone says they are good at SEO, when actually very few are. It definitely isn’t fair to you the customer. Please do your homework and check their rankings. If they don’t have rankings chances are they aren’t very good. We rank in every city we have targeted. Ask to see the list. Awesome web Design mixed with Dominating SEO is a combination any company looking to destroy their competition can’t go without. Please allow extra time for our website (Visit Website) to load, the Demo is displaying all features available which dramatically slow down the loading speed. All the features are displayed so you can choose which ones you want for your website which will be much faster.


Water Heater Solutions

6602 W 500 S
3.12(
17
)

Water Heater Solutions

6602 W 500 S
3.12(
17
)
6 years of experience

We are a water heater service and pump replacement company. The company itself is new however I have been a plumbing contractor for 15 years and owned a plumbing company for that long. The difference is we now specialize in water heaters and sump and ejector pumps.

"Please do not use this company!!!!! I was referred to them by my home warranty company. Not only did they not fix the problem, but they had me on a wild goose chase for two weeks and stopped answering my calls or emails. I went without hot water for two weeks! I finally requested another company (Local Plumber) and they came out the next day and got my water heater to work. Water Heater Solutions is horrible to work with. They never answer the phone, didn't provide paperwork to the warranty program, and took my $100 and did nothing."

Rachael T on April 2024

We are a water heater service and pump replacement company. The company itself is new however I have been a plumbing contractor for 15 years and owned a plumbing company for that long. The difference is we now specialize in water heaters and sump and ejector pumps.

"Please do not use this company!!!!! I was referred to them by my home warranty company. Not only did they not fix the problem, but they had me on a wild goose chase for two weeks and stopped answering my calls or emails. I went without hot water for two weeks! I finally requested another company (Local Plumber) and they came out the next day and got my water heater to work. Water Heater Solutions is horrible to work with. They never answer the phone, didn't provide paperwork to the warranty program, and took my $100 and did nothing."

Rachael T on April 2024


FOWLER SEPTIC SVC

6940 S HARMONY RD
No reviews yet

FOWLER SEPTIC SVC

6940 S HARMONY RD
No reviews yet
30 years of experience

No. of employees: 2. In business since 1995. We do not accept credit cards.

No. of employees: 2. In business since 1995. We do not accept credit cards.


Dorian Visionheart Dyer

3560 South Brandon Street
4.83(
6
)

Dorian Visionheart Dyer

3560 South Brandon Street
4.83(
6
)
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

I am a self-taught artist, initially drawn to experiment with pastels and colored pencil, and now working with acrylic on canvas. My art speaks for itself.

I am a self-taught artist, initially drawn to experiment with pastels and colored pencil, and now working with acrylic on canvas. My art speaks for itself.


Barrow Excavating & Concrete Construction

3.00(
4
)

Barrow Excavating & Concrete Construction

3.00(
4
)
20 years of experience

With over 20 years of excavation and construction expertise, you can count on us to do just about any contracting job that you may need done.

"BEWARE!!!!!!!!! David Lantz and Gary Barrows are the absolute worst contractors in Indiana. They stole over $300k in (overcharges) for fraudulent invoices billing for "rock removal" then did not have an excavation plan and we had major water damage due to improper drainage and they did not even connect the perimeter drains. BEWARE, the have done this to many others per other complaints on this site. SEPTIC SYSTEM IMPROPERLY INSTALLED AND LEAKS AS WELL!!!"

MARK L on December 2021

With over 20 years of excavation and construction expertise, you can count on us to do just about any contracting job that you may need done.

"BEWARE!!!!!!!!! David Lantz and Gary Barrows are the absolute worst contractors in Indiana. They stole over $300k in (overcharges) for fraudulent invoices billing for "rock removal" then did not have an excavation plan and we had major water damage due to improper drainage and they did not even connect the perimeter drains. BEWARE, the have done this to many others per other complaints on this site. SEPTIC SYSTEM IMPROPERLY INSTALLED AND LEAKS AS WELL!!!"

MARK L on December 2021

Showing 1-10 of 43
FAQs for well pump installation and replacement projects in Spencer, IN

You'll know your well pump is broken if you notice dirty or cloudy water, loud noises from the pump, inconsistent water pressure, or air sputtering from your faucets. Unexplained increases in your water bills can also indicate a problem. If you experience any of these signs, it's important to consult a professional promptly to prevent further damage.

With regular maintenance, a well pump lasts between 8 and 15 years. Factors such as the pump's quality, level of usage, water sediment levels, and frequency of servicing affect its lifespan. Hard water with high mineral content causes sediment buildup, leading to premature wear. Regular inspections and timely repairs help extend the life of your pump. If your pump is aging or showing signs of trouble, it may be time to consider a replacement.

It depends on the type of pump. A single line shallow pump can pump water 25 feet deep and then into your home. A 3/4 HP submersible pump can draw water from a depth of up to 250 feet. A deep well jet pump can pump water from up to 400 feet below ground.

While it’s important to check your individual homeowners policy, well pumps in need of replacement due to damage from a storm or fire are usually covered by insurance. The costs associated with well pumps that are in need of replacement after reaching their natural lifespan will likely not be covered by homeowners insurance.

Replacing a well pump takes a professional between half a day to a full day to complete. The exact time depends on factors such as the pump type, well depth, and accessibility. Shallow well pumps are quicker to replace, while deep submersible pumps require more time due to extensive piping and wiring. Scheduling with a qualified contractor ensures the replacement is done safely and minimizes disruption to your water supply.

Prevent well pump failure by scheduling regular maintenance, testing water quality, and addressing issues promptly. Install sediment filters to reduce mineral buildup and ensure proper water flow. Avoid overworking the pump by monitoring water usage, especially during dry periods. Installing a low-water cutoff switch prevents the pump from running when the well is low. Proactive care extends the life of your pump and keeps your water system running smoothly.

The Spencer, IN homeowners’ guide to well pump installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.