Top-rated well pump installers and replacers.

Get matched with top well pump installers and replacers in Stillwater, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Well pump installers and replacers in Stillwater

Avatar for Dave's Plumbing

Dave's Plumbing

50 Meadow Rue Pl
4.79(
38
)
•Approved Pro

Dave's Plumbing

50 Meadow Rue Pl
4.79(
38
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers
310 local quotes requested

With over 30 years of experience, I have built a reputation for excellence, professionalism, and reliability. My work speaks for itself—no call-backs, just high-quality plumbing done right the first time. As a dedicated Christian, I believe in using my skills to serve others, which is why I am proud to be associated with Angi, a platform that not only connects homeowners with trusted professionals but also gives back by helping those in need. Whether it’s a routine repair or an urgent plumbing issue, I approach every job with integrity, precision, and a heart for helping people. When you choose Dave's Plumbing, you're not just hiring a plumber—you're partnering with someone who genuinely cares about your home and community.

"He replaced outdoor plumbing for spout and did some took off some siding of the house. He did an excellent job and provided a very reasonable price. He give free estimate and he come back 2 days later and got finished the job . H e was all work and no talk and had no delay. He was spectacular .and He knew how to access 35 year old pipe that was in the siding. It was great. He place everything in perfect edition and I'd even recommended him on the app next door. I even left his name for others to contact for general contracting needs. I plan to call him again."

Eileen M on June 2025

With over 30 years of experience, I have built a reputation for excellence, professionalism, and reliability. My work speaks for itself—no call-backs, just high-quality plumbing done right the first time. As a dedicated Christian, I believe in using my skills to serve others, which is why I am proud to be associated with Angi, a platform that not only connects homeowners with trusted professionals but also gives back by helping those in need. Whether it’s a routine repair or an urgent plumbing issue, I approach every job with integrity, precision, and a heart for helping people. When you choose Dave's Plumbing, you're not just hiring a plumber—you're partnering with someone who genuinely cares about your home and community.

"He replaced outdoor plumbing for spout and did some took off some siding of the house. He did an excellent job and provided a very reasonable price. He give free estimate and he come back 2 days later and got finished the job . H e was all work and no talk and had no delay. He was spectacular .and He knew how to access 35 year old pipe that was in the siding. It was great. He place everything in perfect edition and I'd even recommended him on the app next door. I even left his name for others to contact for general contracting needs. I plan to call him again."

Eileen M on June 2025

Rosick Well Drilling

1175 Farley Rd
5.00(
4
)

Rosick Well Drilling

1175 Farley Rd
5.00(
4
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

We are a family business that has been around for almost 50 years. We install residential and commercial water wells, pump installation and repair, water filtration and geothermal boreholes and system installation.

"These ladies came out today (Saturday of Easter weekend) on an emergency call and determined we needed a new relay. They didn’t try to sell us a new pump but given the fact that the pump was most likely the same vintage (37 years old) we asked them to install a new one. They were professional, knowledgeable and fast! We would highly recommend them to anyone needing well work. The price was reasonable too! Thank you ladies!!"

Constance S on April 2022

We are a family business that has been around for almost 50 years. We install residential and commercial water wells, pump installation and repair, water filtration and geothermal boreholes and system installation.

"These ladies came out today (Saturday of Easter weekend) on an emergency call and determined we needed a new relay. They didn’t try to sell us a new pump but given the fact that the pump was most likely the same vintage (37 years old) we asked them to install a new one. They were professional, knowledgeable and fast! We would highly recommend them to anyone needing well work. The price was reasonable too! Thank you ladies!!"

Constance S on April 2022

Allied Construction

Po Box 220
5.00(
1
)

Allied Construction

Po Box 220
5.00(
1
)
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Allied Construction covers all your construction needs from small renovations to building a home from the ground up. We are a small group of skilled tradesman located in the Capital Region of NY. We deal with customers one on one to make their plans and dreams a reality. We provide free estimates and accept major credit cards.

Allied Construction covers all your construction needs from small renovations to building a home from the ground up. We are a small group of skilled tradesman located in the Capital Region of NY. We deal with customers one on one to make their plans and dreams a reality. We provide free estimates and accept major credit cards.

Quality Stone Works, Inc.

49 Elm Street
1.00(
1
)

Quality Stone Works, Inc.

49 Elm Street
1.00(
1
)
15 years of experience

3 years in business all employees have 10 years plus experience right now we have 5-7 employees we will and can offer sub- contracting as far as billing we accept all major credit cards, checks,etc

"He is the worst and most dishonest contractor you could ever hire. When he came in to quote us the job he sounded very confident and sound he knew what he was doing. So we finally agreed on a price and a 2 weeks timeline for the job. He showed up only on the first few days, my husband and I gave him portion of the money with expectations of the job being done soon. days went by and he didn't showed up. We were calling and texting him everyday and no responses, once he would respond, was always a different excuses. On top of him not showing up anymore, we bought 27 boxes of tile for my laundry, when my husband and I weren't home, he showed up, took 5 boxes and went to the store and returned to get cash back to himself, which technically he was stealing from us. he was always calling back when he wanted money but no job done. I know my husband and I were stupid to give him the money without the job being even half way done.We hired him in the first week of January, with intentions to be done in 2 weeks. Today is March 29TH 2018 and this deadbeat contractor hasn't show up in 2 months... ignoring phone calls, text and any sort of communication that we tried to established with him. On top of stealing my materials for his own gain, everything that he has done is falling apart, tile floor is popping up for being laid down improperly with wrong material, the cabinets are all "crooked" for not being leveled right, he painted the walls the wrong color, all with promises of fixing it afterwards. I had plans to put my house in the market end of march, but as right now, my house is in pieces and this dead beat dishonest contractor hasn't showed up, so now its not only the house problem, he is affecting my ability to sell my house. PLEASE, DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND NEVER EVER HIRE THIS GUY, His name is Jeffrey Owens Sr."

Mariana S on March 2018

3 years in business all employees have 10 years plus experience right now we have 5-7 employees we will and can offer sub- contracting as far as billing we accept all major credit cards, checks,etc

"He is the worst and most dishonest contractor you could ever hire. When he came in to quote us the job he sounded very confident and sound he knew what he was doing. So we finally agreed on a price and a 2 weeks timeline for the job. He showed up only on the first few days, my husband and I gave him portion of the money with expectations of the job being done soon. days went by and he didn't showed up. We were calling and texting him everyday and no responses, once he would respond, was always a different excuses. On top of him not showing up anymore, we bought 27 boxes of tile for my laundry, when my husband and I weren't home, he showed up, took 5 boxes and went to the store and returned to get cash back to himself, which technically he was stealing from us. he was always calling back when he wanted money but no job done. I know my husband and I were stupid to give him the money without the job being even half way done.We hired him in the first week of January, with intentions to be done in 2 weeks. Today is March 29TH 2018 and this deadbeat contractor hasn't show up in 2 months... ignoring phone calls, text and any sort of communication that we tried to established with him. On top of stealing my materials for his own gain, everything that he has done is falling apart, tile floor is popping up for being laid down improperly with wrong material, the cabinets are all "crooked" for not being leveled right, he painted the walls the wrong color, all with promises of fixing it afterwards. I had plans to put my house in the market end of march, but as right now, my house is in pieces and this dead beat dishonest contractor hasn't showed up, so now its not only the house problem, he is affecting my ability to sell my house. PLEASE, DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND NEVER EVER HIRE THIS GUY, His name is Jeffrey Owens Sr."

Mariana S on March 2018

Culligan Water Conditioning of Scotia NY

1 Culligan Dr
4.25(
8
)

Culligan Water Conditioning of Scotia NY

1 Culligan Dr
4.25(
8
)
Customers say: Super punctual
79 years of experience

Culligan is the world’s leading water treatment company. For over 75 years, Culligan has led the way in water treatment technology, providing the most advanced products and solutions for the world’s water problems. Your local Culligan Man is your local water expert. He is dedicated to delivering high-quality water solutions that will improve the lives of his customers. Simply stated, Culligan believes that better water will make life better for you and your family. Today we offer the most technologically advanced products and services available, combined with the personal service of your local Culligan organization. Our entire line of water softeners, water filtration systems, drinking water systems, and whole-house filtration systems set the standard in the water treatment industry. Additional phone - (518) 583-2497.

"Albany NY.....I bought an RO system ran just to the kitchen sink. The tech came on a Friday afternoon. Saturday night I went down and saw all this water on my basement floor. A slow leak so I waited until the next day and reported it to the salesman and 24/7 service along with the fact that I had purchased an extra set of filters which were not left. NO ONE CAME TO LOOK/FIX THE PROBLEM!! So on Monday morning I hired my own plumber to fix it (a nut which was loosened by the tech and not tightened enough) and BLOCKED this company from my phone. If they don't care to hear me then I DON'T CARE TO HEAR THEM ASKING FOR PAYMENT!!!! They are incompetent and thieves. I ignored them for 2+ years and then they brought me to court. Because I didn't respond to the courts I lost out and had to pay them. THEY SUCK!!!! DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THEM."

Wendy T on June 2024

Culligan is the world’s leading water treatment company. For over 75 years, Culligan has led the way in water treatment technology, providing the most advanced products and solutions for the world’s water problems. Your local Culligan Man is your local water expert. He is dedicated to delivering high-quality water solutions that will improve the lives of his customers. Simply stated, Culligan believes that better water will make life better for you and your family. Today we offer the most technologically advanced products and services available, combined with the personal service of your local Culligan organization. Our entire line of water softeners, water filtration systems, drinking water systems, and whole-house filtration systems set the standard in the water treatment industry. Additional phone - (518) 583-2497.

"Albany NY.....I bought an RO system ran just to the kitchen sink. The tech came on a Friday afternoon. Saturday night I went down and saw all this water on my basement floor. A slow leak so I waited until the next day and reported it to the salesman and 24/7 service along with the fact that I had purchased an extra set of filters which were not left. NO ONE CAME TO LOOK/FIX THE PROBLEM!! So on Monday morning I hired my own plumber to fix it (a nut which was loosened by the tech and not tightened enough) and BLOCKED this company from my phone. If they don't care to hear me then I DON'T CARE TO HEAR THEM ASKING FOR PAYMENT!!!! They are incompetent and thieves. I ignored them for 2+ years and then they brought me to court. Because I didn't respond to the courts I lost out and had to pay them. THEY SUCK!!!! DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THEM."

Wendy T on June 2024

Adirondack Contractors & Associates

126 Maple St
No reviews yet

Adirondack Contractors & Associates

126 Maple St
No reviews yet
14 years of experience

4-5 Employees. No subs. Cost is determined by the job. No travel fees. From basement to chimney, we have you covered.

4-5 Employees. No subs. Cost is determined by the job. No travel fees. From basement to chimney, we have you covered.

Roland J Down Service Experts

13 Airport Rd
4.51(
304
)

Roland J Down Service Experts

13 Airport Rd
4.51(
304
)
Customers say: Super punctual
73 years of experience

Roland J Down Service Experts Heating and Air Conditioning was established with the understanding of providing customers with the most excellent heating and cooling practices in the industry.

"James & Ernie installed a new water heater for my dad on 11/27. It was an emergency and Roland J Down came through with expert service and James & Ernie did so with the utmost in professionalism and treated my dad with thoughtfulness and respect. They were there to perform the work needed within an hour when the company my dad always used didn’t know when they could help. Thank you to a new, very happy customer. Mr Harry Loucks"

David L on November 2023

Roland J Down Service Experts Heating and Air Conditioning was established with the understanding of providing customers with the most excellent heating and cooling practices in the industry.

"James & Ernie installed a new water heater for my dad on 11/27. It was an emergency and Roland J Down came through with expert service and James & Ernie did so with the utmost in professionalism and treated my dad with thoughtfulness and respect. They were there to perform the work needed within an hour when the company my dad always used didn’t know when they could help. Thank you to a new, very happy customer. Mr Harry Loucks"

David L on November 2023

Mike Byer Construction

PO Box 427
4.50(
2
)

Mike Byer Construction

PO Box 427
4.50(
2
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

General Contractor (All Phases of residential) whose two owners, Mike and John, have a combined construction experience of over 50 years. Fully insured (liability, vehicles, workers comp). Accept most credit cards.

General Contractor (All Phases of residential) whose two owners, Mike and John, have a combined construction experience of over 50 years. Fully insured (liability, vehicles, workers comp). Accept most credit cards.

Get it Done Contracting

2nd Street
No reviews yet

Get it Done Contracting

2nd Street
No reviews yet
42 years of experience

We are a small family owned business, been in the contracting business fir over 25 years. There is no job too small for us. Being family owned we understand times are tough and you need to be able to get your money's worth. We always try to go that little extra mile to keep our customer happy. We can say we gaurantee our work.

We are a small family owned business, been in the contracting business fir over 25 years. There is no job too small for us. Being family owned we understand times are tough and you need to be able to get your money's worth. We always try to go that little extra mile to keep our customer happy. We can say we gaurantee our work.

HANSON WELL DRILLING & PUMP CO

ROUTE 20 West Nassau
4.89(
9
)

HANSON WELL DRILLING & PUMP CO

ROUTE 20 West Nassau
4.89(
9
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

ADDITIONAL ADDRESSES: 4159 US ROUTE 20, CASTLETON ON HUDSON, NY 12033

"Very good service. +++++"

Adam C on June 2021

ADDITIONAL ADDRESSES: 4159 US ROUTE 20, CASTLETON ON HUDSON, NY 12033

"Very good service. +++++"

Adam C on June 2021

...
Showing 1-10 of 108
FAQs for well pump installation and replacement projects in Stillwater, NY

You'll know your well pump is broken if you notice dirty or cloudy water, loud noises from the pump, inconsistent water pressure, or air sputtering from your faucets. Unexplained increases in your water bills can also indicate a problem. If you experience any of these signs, it's important to consult a professional promptly to prevent further damage.

With regular maintenance, a well pump lasts between 8 and 15 years. Factors such as the pump's quality, level of usage, water sediment levels, and frequency of servicing affect its lifespan. Hard water with high mineral content causes sediment buildup, leading to premature wear. Regular inspections and timely repairs help extend the life of your pump. If your pump is aging or showing signs of trouble, it may be time to consider a replacement.

It depends on the type of pump. A single line shallow pump can pump water 25 feet deep and then into your home. A 3/4 HP submersible pump can draw water from a depth of up to 250 feet. A deep well jet pump can pump water from up to 400 feet below ground.

While it’s important to check your individual homeowners policy, well pumps in need of replacement due to damage from a storm or fire are usually covered by insurance. The costs associated with well pumps that are in need of replacement after reaching their natural lifespan will likely not be covered by homeowners insurance.

Replacing a well pump takes a professional between half a day to a full day to complete. The exact time depends on factors such as the pump type, well depth, and accessibility. Shallow well pumps are quicker to replace, while deep submersible pumps require more time due to extensive piping and wiring. Scheduling with a qualified contractor ensures the replacement is done safely and minimizes disruption to your water supply.

Prevent well pump failure by scheduling regular maintenance, testing water quality, and addressing issues promptly. Install sediment filters to reduce mineral buildup and ensure proper water flow. Avoid overworking the pump by monitoring water usage, especially during dry periods. Installing a low-water cutoff switch prevents the pump from running when the well is low. Proactive care extends the life of your pump and keeps your water system running smoothly.

The Stillwater, NY homeowners’ guide to well pump installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles