Top-rated water heater installers and replacers.

Get matched with top water heater installers and replacers in Garden City, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Water heater installers and replacers in Garden City

Avatar for Dacstar

Dacstar

4.99(
168
)
•Approved Pro

Dacstar

4.99(
168
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
18 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

We are a locally owned and operated company. We value honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. We offer a variety of home improvement services that are customized to each individual project. We pride ourselves on the quality of our work, as well as our commitment to outstanding results. We look forward to building lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction!

"Dacstar did an outstanding job in upgrading and replacing my water heater. I called on Friday evening at 7:30 and explained my issue and Steve was at my doorstep with his helper by 8:30. How is that for fast service. He saw what needed to be done and got the whole job finished within an hour. Steve analyzed what the issue was, had all the tools and equipment, and did a masterful job in the installation. My phone call to Steve was well received, he gave me a very competitive price, and he delivered on his promise to be there within the hour. Steve is knowledgeable, efficient, and explained everything step by step as well as giving me some maintenance tips which he said would help make the water heater last longer than the typical 10-12 years. He was helpful, personable and pleasant to deal with. He is honest, truthful and keeps his word. I would give Steve and his company a high recommendation. You can’t go wrong with his services!"

Bill E on January 2026

We are a locally owned and operated company. We value honesty and integrity in all aspects of our business. We offer a variety of home improvement services that are customized to each individual project. We pride ourselves on the quality of our work, as well as our commitment to outstanding results. We look forward to building lasting relationships with our clients and guarantee your satisfaction!

"Dacstar did an outstanding job in upgrading and replacing my water heater. I called on Friday evening at 7:30 and explained my issue and Steve was at my doorstep with his helper by 8:30. How is that for fast service. He saw what needed to be done and got the whole job finished within an hour. Steve analyzed what the issue was, had all the tools and equipment, and did a masterful job in the installation. My phone call to Steve was well received, he gave me a very competitive price, and he delivered on his promise to be there within the hour. Steve is knowledgeable, efficient, and explained everything step by step as well as giving me some maintenance tips which he said would help make the water heater last longer than the typical 10-12 years. He was helpful, personable and pleasant to deal with. He is honest, truthful and keeps his word. I would give Steve and his company a high recommendation. You can’t go wrong with his services!"

Bill E on January 2026

Barnagat Plumbing Inc

4.90(
177
)
•Approved Pro

Barnagat Plumbing Inc

4.90(
177
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 96% of Angi customers
Recommended by 96% of HomeAdvisor customers
46 years of experience

When it comes to local plumbers, no one else can provide you with great services like Barnagat Plumbing Inc. can. Here at Barnagat Plumbing Inc, we can help take care of all your plumbing needs. We years of experience, we strive to provide you with reliable plumbing services at reasonable prices. So if you have a leaky pipe or complete bathroom plumbing, make sure to give us a call at the office at (516) 225-2854 or (516) 764-0895.

"Fine work very nice"

Michael B on September 2025

When it comes to local plumbers, no one else can provide you with great services like Barnagat Plumbing Inc. can. Here at Barnagat Plumbing Inc, we can help take care of all your plumbing needs. We years of experience, we strive to provide you with reliable plumbing services at reasonable prices. So if you have a leaky pipe or complete bathroom plumbing, make sure to give us a call at the office at (516) 225-2854 or (516) 764-0895.

"Fine work very nice"

Michael B on September 2025

Avatar for Fix All Plumbing

Fix All Plumbing

4.74(
88
)
•Approved Pro

Fix All Plumbing

4.74(
88
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
25 years of experience

Here at Fix All Plumbing, we sustain our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We strongly believe in giving our absolute best in all of our projects. We are experts in our trade and will always keep you educated on your particular task or project.

"Steve was great. Fixed issues and reasonably priced. Would definitely hire him again."

Dan B on January 2025

Here at Fix All Plumbing, we sustain our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We strongly believe in giving our absolute best in all of our projects. We are experts in our trade and will always keep you educated on your particular task or project.

"Steve was great. Fixed issues and reasonably priced. Would definitely hire him again."

Dan B on January 2025

Avatar for Anthony's Any Sewer Any Drain, LLC

Anthony's Any Sewer Any Drain, LLC

4.65(
416
)
•Approved Pro

Anthony's Any Sewer Any Drain, LLC

4.65(
416
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 94% of Angi customers
Recommended by 94% of HomeAdvisor customers
20 years of experience

Welcome to Anthony's Any Sewer Any Drain, LLC We specialize in Root Treatment, Video Inspection ,Drain Cleaning, Hot Water Heaters, Sewer Ejector Pumps, Toilets, High Pressure Water Jetting, Shower Bodies. For RESIDENTIAL and COMMERCIAL Properties Feel free to call or email for any and all plumbing jobs. 347-961.2717 Asdplumbing1660@gmail.com We take pride in what we do and strive to provide the best quality service in the Long Island area and all 5 boroughs. You will not be disappointed. *All Plumbers & Staff are fully vaccinated*

"Did a great job cleaning out my home’s sewer pipe and solved the problem! Definitely recommend"

Alice G on January 2023

Welcome to Anthony's Any Sewer Any Drain, LLC We specialize in Root Treatment, Video Inspection ,Drain Cleaning, Hot Water Heaters, Sewer Ejector Pumps, Toilets, High Pressure Water Jetting, Shower Bodies. For RESIDENTIAL and COMMERCIAL Properties Feel free to call or email for any and all plumbing jobs. 347-961.2717 Asdplumbing1660@gmail.com We take pride in what we do and strive to provide the best quality service in the Long Island area and all 5 boroughs. You will not be disappointed. *All Plumbers & Staff are fully vaccinated*

"Did a great job cleaning out my home’s sewer pipe and solved the problem! Definitely recommend"

Alice G on January 2023

Avatar for Elite Piping Solutions

Elite Piping Solutions

4.80(
41
)
•Approved Pro

Elite Piping Solutions

4.80(
41
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
5 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

We work extremely hard for the owner and always have the owner's best interest at heart. Our long term vision is for us to become a go to general contractor with capabilities to do multiple types of projects.

"Elite Piping Solutions is an amazing company. I wish I could give them a 6-star rating because they are truly exceptional! They were prompt, courteous, and efficient at every step of the process. They followed up on my query within a couple of hours, came to inspect exactly on the dot, did the research to get me the top-of-the-line replacement, and gave me a very competitive estimate. I independently verified the details, and everything was correct and accurate. The crew came when promised, did the installation well within the estimated time and left the place spotless. Not only that, but they also carefully took out parts of the system that could be re-used, neatly packaged, and left them in the basement for me. Other estimates I got were much higher, including extra charges for coming within a day. Another company would not or could not replace my system (which is top of the line) and added additional charges for "adjustments'! This company is the best! "

Runi R on February 2026

We work extremely hard for the owner and always have the owner's best interest at heart. Our long term vision is for us to become a go to general contractor with capabilities to do multiple types of projects.

"Elite Piping Solutions is an amazing company. I wish I could give them a 6-star rating because they are truly exceptional! They were prompt, courteous, and efficient at every step of the process. They followed up on my query within a couple of hours, came to inspect exactly on the dot, did the research to get me the top-of-the-line replacement, and gave me a very competitive estimate. I independently verified the details, and everything was correct and accurate. The crew came when promised, did the installation well within the estimated time and left the place spotless. Not only that, but they also carefully took out parts of the system that could be re-used, neatly packaged, and left them in the basement for me. Other estimates I got were much higher, including extra charges for coming within a day. Another company would not or could not replace my system (which is top of the line) and added additional charges for "adjustments'! This company is the best! "

Runi R on February 2026

Avatar for Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp.

Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp.

4.66(
206
)
•Approved Pro

Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp.

4.66(
206
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: True professional
55 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp. has been trusted and recommended since 1971, and recognized for our superb service. We are family owned and operated, with guaranteed great service. Our company specializes in all types of work, but especially: Plumbing, Gas Heating, Drain Cleaning, Oil to Gas Conversions, NYS RPZ Testing to name a few things. Call & schedule your appointment today! 631-666-9315

"Didn't show up on day scheduled, failed to call. Replaced ~$100 part in about a half hour. Charge was $595"

Bruce M on April 2025

Herber Plumbing & Heating Corp. has been trusted and recommended since 1971, and recognized for our superb service. We are family owned and operated, with guaranteed great service. Our company specializes in all types of work, but especially: Plumbing, Gas Heating, Drain Cleaning, Oil to Gas Conversions, NYS RPZ Testing to name a few things. Call & schedule your appointment today! 631-666-9315

"Didn't show up on day scheduled, failed to call. Replaced ~$100 part in about a half hour. Charge was $595"

Bruce M on April 2025

Avatar for Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc.

Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc.

4.77(
380
)
•Approved Pro

Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc.

4.77(
380
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
21 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc., is dedicated to providing our clients with the very best in service, installation, and repairs to meet your plumbing needs. We specialize in plumbing repairs and a variety of residential services. We take pride in the attention to detail put into each of the projects we're involved with. We're known for our quality work and the integrity of our business. We look forward to building long-term relationships with our clients, and guarantee your satisfaction. We also don't charge extra for emergency services, so please call us if you are in need, my name is chris locrotondo I am the owner and the service tech that will be handling your service call,we base our company on personal service so call and speak with me !!!

"Did a good job. He was on time, knowledgeable and efficient."

Averell C on March 2026

Rapid Plumbing Service, Inc., is dedicated to providing our clients with the very best in service, installation, and repairs to meet your plumbing needs. We specialize in plumbing repairs and a variety of residential services. We take pride in the attention to detail put into each of the projects we're involved with. We're known for our quality work and the integrity of our business. We look forward to building long-term relationships with our clients, and guarantee your satisfaction. We also don't charge extra for emergency services, so please call us if you are in need, my name is chris locrotondo I am the owner and the service tech that will be handling your service call,we base our company on personal service so call and speak with me !!!

"Did a good job. He was on time, knowledgeable and efficient."

Averell C on March 2026

Avatar for Universe Home Services

Universe Home Services

4.73(
402
)
•Approved Pro

Universe Home Services

4.73(
402
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
72 years of experience

Since 1954, Universe Home Services has been proudly serving the Nassau County community and customers throughout the entire region. With Universe Home Services, one call solves it all! Their highly trained technicians offer everything from heating and air conditioning to plumbing to appliance repair and electrical services on Long Island and beyond. Whether you’re dealing with an inefficient heating system, a noisy air conditioner, clogged toilet, broken dishwasher, or outdated electrical service panel, you can get the fast, affordable service you need with Universe Home Services. They go above and beyond to ensure that you’re completely satisfied with the quality of their work, offering service guarantees and parts and labor guarantees on new HVAC installations. As a family owned and operated company, Universe Home Services believes in top-quality customer service. They always treat you and your property with respect, working quickly, cleanly, and efficiently to minimize your inconvenience and leave your home in pristine condition. With more than 60 years of experience under their belt, and a commitment to unmatched quality, honesty, and expertise, Universe Home Services is the trusted name for heating, air conditioning, electrical, plumbing, and appliance repair on Long Island and beyond! Call today!

"Technician was excellent, did come around 10 PM and was a little pricey."

Hugh L on February 2026

Since 1954, Universe Home Services has been proudly serving the Nassau County community and customers throughout the entire region. With Universe Home Services, one call solves it all! Their highly trained technicians offer everything from heating and air conditioning to plumbing to appliance repair and electrical services on Long Island and beyond. Whether you’re dealing with an inefficient heating system, a noisy air conditioner, clogged toilet, broken dishwasher, or outdated electrical service panel, you can get the fast, affordable service you need with Universe Home Services. They go above and beyond to ensure that you’re completely satisfied with the quality of their work, offering service guarantees and parts and labor guarantees on new HVAC installations. As a family owned and operated company, Universe Home Services believes in top-quality customer service. They always treat you and your property with respect, working quickly, cleanly, and efficiently to minimize your inconvenience and leave your home in pristine condition. With more than 60 years of experience under their belt, and a commitment to unmatched quality, honesty, and expertise, Universe Home Services is the trusted name for heating, air conditioning, electrical, plumbing, and appliance repair on Long Island and beyond! Call today!

"Technician was excellent, did come around 10 PM and was a little pricey."

Hugh L on February 2026

Avatar for Resto Presto Inc.

Resto Presto Inc.

5.00(
25
)
•Approved Pro

Resto Presto Inc.

5.00(
25
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: Quick response
6 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Presto means superfast emergency service. Our operators are standing by 24 seven to help you with your water fire sewer or smoke emergency. Call 631 533-3806 serving Queens Nassau, Suffolk County

"Bill and his team were professional and efficient. They even gave me tips on what I can do to avoid future problems. I would highly recommend this company. Thank you again Paul "

Paul S on February 2026

Presto means superfast emergency service. Our operators are standing by 24 seven to help you with your water fire sewer or smoke emergency. Call 631 533-3806 serving Queens Nassau, Suffolk County

"Bill and his team were professional and efficient. They even gave me tips on what I can do to avoid future problems. I would highly recommend this company. Thank you again Paul "

Paul S on February 2026

Avatar for Varsity Home Service Company, Inc.

Varsity Home Service Company, Inc.

4.79(
197
)
•Approved Pro

Varsity Home Service Company, Inc.

4.79(
197
)
•Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
64 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

Practice makes perfect, and Varsity has been at it for over half a century! What began with a Navy veteran’s simple dream — to teach the value of honest, hands-on work to his children — has grown into one of Long Island’s most trusted resource for plumbing, heating and air conditioning services. Varsity’s mission has always been clear: to serve our neighbors with integrity, solve home service challenges with innovative solutions, and provide lasting results. Our dedicated crew is background-checked, rigorously trained in the latest technology, and excited to exceed your expectations. Above all Varsity is here to EARN your trust—not just for today, but for years to come. Let’s tackle your home service needs with the quality and care you deserve!

"I called Varsity on a Sunday night when I realized I had no hot water . It was the day we had the snow storm. The next morning Sean arrived to access the issue with my very old hot water heater. He was extremely knowledgeable and gave me my options. Within a short time Jake and Anthony joined and my new water heater was installed and working. No mess , no stress. They were amazing. Sean even shoveled the skirt of my driveway when the plows came and blocked me in as I was trying to get to work. This team went above and beyond to help any way they could. My utility room look clean and the work done right. I highly recommend Varsity. I feel comfortable knowing the technicians had the right training and were really nice guys to deal with. Thanks to Erica for taking my call so late and to Christine for getting the men out so quickly the next morning. They kept me informed every step of the way. I appreciated that. "

Diane P on March 2026

Practice makes perfect, and Varsity has been at it for over half a century! What began with a Navy veteran’s simple dream — to teach the value of honest, hands-on work to his children — has grown into one of Long Island’s most trusted resource for plumbing, heating and air conditioning services. Varsity’s mission has always been clear: to serve our neighbors with integrity, solve home service challenges with innovative solutions, and provide lasting results. Our dedicated crew is background-checked, rigorously trained in the latest technology, and excited to exceed your expectations. Above all Varsity is here to EARN your trust—not just for today, but for years to come. Let’s tackle your home service needs with the quality and care you deserve!

"I called Varsity on a Sunday night when I realized I had no hot water . It was the day we had the snow storm. The next morning Sean arrived to access the issue with my very old hot water heater. He was extremely knowledgeable and gave me my options. Within a short time Jake and Anthony joined and my new water heater was installed and working. No mess , no stress. They were amazing. Sean even shoveled the skirt of my driveway when the plows came and blocked me in as I was trying to get to work. This team went above and beyond to help any way they could. My utility room look clean and the work done right. I highly recommend Varsity. I feel comfortable knowing the technicians had the right training and were really nice guys to deal with. Thanks to Erica for taking my call so late and to Christine for getting the men out so quickly the next morning. They kept me informed every step of the way. I appreciated that. "

Diane P on March 2026

Showing 1-10 of 38

The Garden City, NY homeowners’ guide to water heater installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.

See all articles