Top-rated water heater repair or service pros.

Get matched with top water heater repair or service pros in Mayfield, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Water heater repair or service pros in Mayfield

Avatar for Capital Region Plumbing and Heating Services, LLC
Capital Region Plumbing and Heating Services, LLC
4.2(
110
)

Serving Mayfield, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

Super Service Award Winner

In business since 2019

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I found out our water heater burst around 6pm, and by 10pm that same night they had a new heater in. Huge help to me and my family, and the Boss crew was very helpful, communicative, and thorough. Definitely would recommend, especially in an emergency."
Response time4 hrs
Response rate95%
31 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Crisafulli Bros. Home Services
Crisafulli Bros. Home Services
4.6(
67
)

Serving Mayfield, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1939

Credit card accepted

Offers commercial services

"Just too expensive for what you get. Feels like a big company nickel and dime move. I get having a trip charge. Which was $109. But then to have the tech who was great btw (not his fault), but was tentative about fixing the problem because of creating more damage. Another $160 for a simple diagnostic charge, again without fixing the problem. I already knew the diagnosis. So he basically did a Band-Aid fix (greased the Knob) and still charged me over $280+ for what equated to be 10 minutes of work. It was ridiculously high for the service provided. Next time I?m going to an independent, local guy."
Response time1 day
36 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by93%of homeowners
Avatar for DRAIN & MAIN PLUMBING CO. LLC
DRAIN & MAIN PLUMBING CO. LLC
4.8(
10
)

Serving Mayfield, NY and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2025

Emergency services offered

Warranties offered

Drain & Main Plumbing Co. is your trusted plumbing company our fully insured plumbers bring years of hands on experience from basic repairs, leak detection, fixture installations, and drain services and expanding to complex waterline and sewer line repair & replacement. Using the latest camera-inspection technology, trenchless methods, and industrial-grade hydro-jetting equipment, we tackle clogs, corrosion, and system failures with precision and minimal disruption to your property.

Sewer Main Replacement
Sewer Main Replacement
Commercial Main Repair
Commercial Main Repair
Response time12 hrs
Response rate88%
15 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Sears Appliance Repair
Sears Appliance Repair
4.8(
22
)

Serving Mayfield, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1956

Credit card accepted

"Technician was great. Timely, neat, friendly and knowledgeable. The person who answered to phone at the call center was awful. Hard to get information across, but had no effect on technician. Price was a bit high. They use a price book, and not consistent with time or labor involved."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+5

Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for A Real Plumber
A Real Plumber
4.0(
422
)

Serving Mayfield, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1973

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"Best. Plumber. Ever.
Winston and his son-in-law were fantastic!  Due to my situation in a condominium, the project was VERY difficult.  What would normally take 1/2 hour or so took almost four hours.  I know some things about construction and most plumbers would have taken one look at the problem and walked away from this job.  Besides being highly skilled, it was like having a good friend over to do the job.  In addition, I was impressed that I wasn't even asked to give them any more money, which they justly deserved.  Please tip them generously!
"
Additional Photos
Recommended by77%of homeowners
Avatar for Mulholland's On Call Plumbing & Heating
Mulholland's On Call Plumbing & Heating
4.2(
41
)

Serving Mayfield, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1969

Emergency services offered

Credit card accepted

"It was a tough getting the spoon out. The service man stayed with it, and finally got it out. Great service, very responsive, pleasant to work with. I was on a time table and they accommodated me. Would highly recommend them to anyone for plumbing needs.
"
Recommended by85%of homeowners
Avatar for A. Johnson Plumbing & Heating, Inc.
A. Johnson Plumbing & Heating, Inc.
3.9(
98
)

Serving Mayfield, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1978

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"It is my daughters house and her furnace went. I was at my daughters house for the installation. They came right out but could not do the job for 2 days being the weekend . They gave her heaters to use for free and did exactly what they said they would. They replaced her furnace and the job was done quickly and the cleanup was excellent. Definitely recommend. Prices were same or less than others we checked out."
Lennox High Efficient Gas hot air system
Untitled Gallery 1
Untitled Gallery 1
Untitled Gallery 1
Untitled Gallery 1

+7

Response time5 hrs
Recommended by93%of homeowners
Avatar for American Home Shield – Home Warranty
American Home Shield – Home Warranty
3.5(
5,688
)

Serving Mayfield, NY and surrounding areas

In business since 1971

Credit card accepted

"AHS is ok. They cover repairs of most everything under the roof of your house. The companies that contract with them are not always the best. You call AHS with the issue, they send a fax to the repair company and give you the contact info. If they don't contact you within 24 hours, you call them. Sometimes they answer, sometimes they don't. When they arrive (usually three days or so later), they service the item. if it has issues within the 90 days, you call AHS again, they are sent out with no charge. If the serviceman decides the unit is unrepairable, AHS will allow you to choose a replacement from their listing (usually not as good as what you have) they will install and remove your old item, or give you wholesale amount to buy and install your own. Prices vary on what you want covered and what you want the copay to be, plus where you live. For me it is 49.99 per month with a 75.00 time of service order. You can have more than one item serviced at the same time under the same fee. If you have a SEAR product the repair guys are great. Not that wild about the other ones they send out. But it is a big savings compared to calling someone on your own. The cost of service is only the 75.00 copay."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+2

Recommended by65%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 35
FAQs for water heater repair or service projects in Mayfield, NY

Warning signs include fluctuating water temperatures, a pilot light that repeatedly goes out, unusual noises from the tank, or complete heating failure. You might also detect a rotten egg smell, indicating a potential gas leak, or notice water that never reaches the proper temperature. If your water heater is over eight years old and displaying these symptoms, the gas valve is a likely culprit. Professional inspection is recommended, especially if gas odors are present.

Water heater gas valves are not universally interchangeable. Each valve must match your specific water heater's make, model, and specifications. Important compatibility factors include gas type (natural gas vs. propane), BTU rating, connection types, and physical dimensions. Using an incorrect valve can result in poor performance, premature failure, or dangerous gas leaks. Always consult your water heater's documentation or a professional plumber to identify the appropriate replacement valve for your unit.

The Mayfield, NY homeowners’ guide to water heater repair or services

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.