Top-rated well pump installers and replacers.

Get matched with top well pump installers and replacers in your area

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Well pump installers and replacers in Columbus

Avatar for Benjamin Franklin Plumbing - Indianapolis
Benjamin Franklin Plumbing - Indianapolis
5561 W. 74th Street
4.34(
208
)
Approved Pro
Benjamin Franklin Plumbing - Indianapolis
5561 W. 74th Street
4.34(
208
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
446 local quotes requested
40 years of experience

At Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis, we take immense pride in our well-established reputation for delivering dependable plumbing installation services you can rely on. When it comes to plumbing installations, precision and reliability stand as our guiding principles. Our seasoned professional' knowledge of plumbing systems’ ensure that every installation, whether involving new fixtures, water heaters, or piping, is executed correctly. Recognizing that every detail counts, our trained plumbers are focused on every step of the installation process, ensuring a seamless installation and the functionality of your plumbing for years to come. When you opt for Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis for your plumbing installation needs, you're embracing a team that values your satisfaction, respects your time, and channels unwavering dedication to excellence into every project we handle.

"One day after I requested my project of Sump Pump replacement through Angie's list, this Benjamin Franklin technician, Matt, visited my house the next day. Matt quoted the cost and completed the project with 2 hours. I am very satisfied with Matt's work. Matt explained the system upon completion to me. "

David C on May 2025

At Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis, we take immense pride in our well-established reputation for delivering dependable plumbing installation services you can rely on. When it comes to plumbing installations, precision and reliability stand as our guiding principles. Our seasoned professional' knowledge of plumbing systems’ ensure that every installation, whether involving new fixtures, water heaters, or piping, is executed correctly. Recognizing that every detail counts, our trained plumbers are focused on every step of the installation process, ensuring a seamless installation and the functionality of your plumbing for years to come. When you opt for Benjamin Franklin Plumbing of Indianapolis for your plumbing installation needs, you're embracing a team that values your satisfaction, respects your time, and channels unwavering dedication to excellence into every project we handle.

"One day after I requested my project of Sump Pump replacement through Angie's list, this Benjamin Franklin technician, Matt, visited my house the next day. Matt quoted the cost and completed the project with 2 hours. I am very satisfied with Matt's work. Matt explained the system upon completion to me. "

David C on May 2025


Avatar for Indiana Well Company
Indiana Well Company
1137 Jody Court
5.00(
4
)
Approved Pro
Indiana Well Company
1137 Jody Court
5.00(
4
)
Approved Pro
1 years of experience
Free onsite estimate

At Indiana Well Company, we pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

"Friendly and professional "

Earl S on March 2025

At Indiana Well Company, we pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

"Friendly and professional "

Earl S on March 2025


Avatar for Hope Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling
Hope Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling
1919 E 52ND ST
4.54(
1,209
)
Approved Pro
Hope Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling
1919 E 52ND ST
4.54(
1,209
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
1427 local quotes requested
18 years of experience

We specialize in working on older homes and those problems that require unique solutions. We offer full service residential plumbing services to customers looking for "long-term" and "efficient" solutions. We work on the following plumbing items - toilets, sinks, water heaters, tankless water heaters, sump pumps, water softeners, faucets, garbage disposals, drains, gas lines, clogged drains, water lines, main lines, and all other non-listed residential plumbing needs.

"They didn’t do anything that I asked of them and they suckered me into some membership. Very disappointed"

Adam H on February 2025

We specialize in working on older homes and those problems that require unique solutions. We offer full service residential plumbing services to customers looking for "long-term" and "efficient" solutions. We work on the following plumbing items - toilets, sinks, water heaters, tankless water heaters, sump pumps, water softeners, faucets, garbage disposals, drains, gas lines, clogged drains, water lines, main lines, and all other non-listed residential plumbing needs.

"They didn’t do anything that I asked of them and they suckered me into some membership. Very disappointed"

Adam H on February 2025


Avatar for C&J Well Drilling and Pump Co
C&J Well Drilling and Pump Co
PO Box 747
4.82(
379
)
Approved Pro
C&J Well Drilling and Pump Co
PO Box 747
4.82(
379
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 95% of Angi customers
Recommended by 95% of HomeAdvisor customers
80 local quotes requested

At C&J Well Co. Service, Pumps, & Drilling, we provide Central Indiana with state-of-the-art well and geothermal drilling and a full-service maintenance team. In addition to drilling, we perform service calls and maintenance checkups and replace pressure tanks and pumps in existing systems. C&J is a family-owned and operated business with a dedicated staff and many satisfied customers. We offer competitive prices without compromising the integrity of our services. Because our wells are drilled using the latest drilling technology, you are ensured to get the most out of your money. C&J Well Company is a member of the BBB, Indiana Ground Water Association, and the Builders Association of Greater Indianapolis. In a quarter of a century, there have been many notable accomplishments, such as opening C and J Water for softeners and treatment, and integrating other local well drilling companies. C&J proudly continues the legacies of Water Wells by Wilhite, Dean Well Drilling, Harness Well Company, and Scobee Well Drilling. Josh and Christy are grateful for their hard-working technicians and strong support staff that led the company through the years.

"They had a good people on the team and were friendly and good to work with. They did supply us with water so well and they answered all our questions."

RICK & JANICE A on December 2024

At C&J Well Co. Service, Pumps, & Drilling, we provide Central Indiana with state-of-the-art well and geothermal drilling and a full-service maintenance team. In addition to drilling, we perform service calls and maintenance checkups and replace pressure tanks and pumps in existing systems. C&J is a family-owned and operated business with a dedicated staff and many satisfied customers. We offer competitive prices without compromising the integrity of our services. Because our wells are drilled using the latest drilling technology, you are ensured to get the most out of your money. C&J Well Company is a member of the BBB, Indiana Ground Water Association, and the Builders Association of Greater Indianapolis. In a quarter of a century, there have been many notable accomplishments, such as opening C and J Water for softeners and treatment, and integrating other local well drilling companies. C&J proudly continues the legacies of Water Wells by Wilhite, Dean Well Drilling, Harness Well Company, and Scobee Well Drilling. Josh and Christy are grateful for their hard-working technicians and strong support staff that led the company through the years.

"They had a good people on the team and were friendly and good to work with. They did supply us with water so well and they answered all our questions."

RICK & JANICE A on December 2024


Avatar for Dirt Worx Of Indiana LLC
Dirt Worx Of Indiana LLC
15022 N 425 E
5.00(
5
)
Approved Pro
Dirt Worx Of Indiana LLC
15022 N 425 E
5.00(
5
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers
147 local quotes requested

CALL us today to get your FREE Estimate on your next excavation project. We are an excavation contractor based out of Hope Indiana. We are committed to excellence and customer service and we can help you attain your goals in various fields of expertise. Including Septic Systems, Grade Work, Drainage, Driveways, Building Pads, Lot Clearing, Bush Hogging, and much more. You can find more information at our Website: WWW.DIRTWORXIN.COM

"No complaints."

Daniel C on October 2024

CALL us today to get your FREE Estimate on your next excavation project. We are an excavation contractor based out of Hope Indiana. We are committed to excellence and customer service and we can help you attain your goals in various fields of expertise. Including Septic Systems, Grade Work, Drainage, Driveways, Building Pads, Lot Clearing, Bush Hogging, and much more. You can find more information at our Website: WWW.DIRTWORXIN.COM

"No complaints."

Daniel C on October 2024


Avatar for Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup
Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup
12034 Exit 5 Pkwy
4.26(
1,204
)
Approved Pro
Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup
12034 Exit 5 Pkwy
4.26(
1,204
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
1624 local quotes requested
90 years of experience

When you need an emergency plumber or a drain cleaner, call Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup. Your fast & reliable plumber can fix any plumbing problem, including sump pumps, toilet repair, faucet repair, faucet replacement, garbage disposals, water heaters, bathtubs, showers, and outside faucets. Roto-Rooter is best known for drain cleaning & sewer cleaning. We fix drain clogs, clogged toilets or sinks, blockage of main sewer lines, slow draining shower and bathtub drains, sewer lines and leaking or burst pipes. We also specialize in water damage restoration & water cleanup services. We can fix and clean up your flooded basement too. Roto-Rooter is a 24-hour plumber near you and provides emergency service.

"They wanted $420 for a one-hour drain clean out. And that was with a $75 "coupon". Ha! I told them to get lost. With one phone call to another plumber and I found same thing for $150. Roto-Rooter must be a group of lawyers who do plumbing in their free time."

Chris M on August 2024

When you need an emergency plumber or a drain cleaner, call Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup. Your fast & reliable plumber can fix any plumbing problem, including sump pumps, toilet repair, faucet repair, faucet replacement, garbage disposals, water heaters, bathtubs, showers, and outside faucets. Roto-Rooter is best known for drain cleaning & sewer cleaning. We fix drain clogs, clogged toilets or sinks, blockage of main sewer lines, slow draining shower and bathtub drains, sewer lines and leaking or burst pipes. We also specialize in water damage restoration & water cleanup services. We can fix and clean up your flooded basement too. Roto-Rooter is a 24-hour plumber near you and provides emergency service.

"They wanted $420 for a one-hour drain clean out. And that was with a $75 "coupon". Ha! I told them to get lost. With one phone call to another plumber and I found same thing for $150. Roto-Rooter must be a group of lawyers who do plumbing in their free time."

Chris M on August 2024


Avatar for Plumbing Heating Paramedics
Plumbing Heating Paramedics
9750 E 150th St
4.64(
2,277
)
Approved Pro
Plumbing Heating Paramedics
9750 E 150th St
4.64(
2,277
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Super punctual
1193 local quotes requested
15 years of experience

Super Service Award Winner for last 7 Years in a Row! 24/7 Service with no overtime charges ever! We will beat any competitor’s price by 10%, and if we can’t, we will give you a $100 gift card for your time (on Furnace and Air Conditioner Equipment). Trane Comfort Specialist-the highest rating awarded to Trane Installers. Two locations to serve you on the North and South side of town. No company is more in touch with the environmental issues, problems, and solutions than one in your own community. PHP is locally owned and operated, which means we can relate better to your needs. FREE ESTIMATES - Most of our estimates are FREE* and free means free. At PHP, there are no strings attached, and no hard sell tactics. EVERY CUSTOMER GETS OUR FREE SERVICE CONTRACT!! OUR GUARANTEE - PHP makes your satisfaction our number one priority. In fact, we confidently make this pledge to every customer: If you are not completely satisfied, PHP will make every effort to make sure you are satisfied. FINANCING AVAILABLE - We know that sometimes it can be easier to spread payments out rather than pay it all now. So, PHP offers 6-12 Months Same As Cash on our services. Call today to find out more. Additional location: 1051 Sloan Drive Franklin, IN 46131 *Not available on regular service issues.

"Disappointed. Their plumbing side did a great job for us 9 years ago, but had a bad experience with their hvac side. They tech didn’t explain what he found clearly and told me I should get a new furnace. 3 days later, I never received a call back to get a quote or my emailed receipt although they did cash my check. I ended up going with another company who fixed my issue by replacing a part."

Michael J on February 2023

Super Service Award Winner for last 7 Years in a Row! 24/7 Service with no overtime charges ever! We will beat any competitor’s price by 10%, and if we can’t, we will give you a $100 gift card for your time (on Furnace and Air Conditioner Equipment). Trane Comfort Specialist-the highest rating awarded to Trane Installers. Two locations to serve you on the North and South side of town. No company is more in touch with the environmental issues, problems, and solutions than one in your own community. PHP is locally owned and operated, which means we can relate better to your needs. FREE ESTIMATES - Most of our estimates are FREE* and free means free. At PHP, there are no strings attached, and no hard sell tactics. EVERY CUSTOMER GETS OUR FREE SERVICE CONTRACT!! OUR GUARANTEE - PHP makes your satisfaction our number one priority. In fact, we confidently make this pledge to every customer: If you are not completely satisfied, PHP will make every effort to make sure you are satisfied. FINANCING AVAILABLE - We know that sometimes it can be easier to spread payments out rather than pay it all now. So, PHP offers 6-12 Months Same As Cash on our services. Call today to find out more. Additional location: 1051 Sloan Drive Franklin, IN 46131 *Not available on regular service issues.

"Disappointed. Their plumbing side did a great job for us 9 years ago, but had a bad experience with their hvac side. They tech didn’t explain what he found clearly and told me I should get a new furnace. 3 days later, I never received a call back to get a quote or my emailed receipt although they did cash my check. I ended up going with another company who fixed my issue by replacing a part."

Michael J on February 2023


Avatar for Knox Septic Sewer Service
Knox Septic Sewer Service
1648 W Ohio St
4.80(
330
)
Approved Pro
Knox Septic Sewer Service
1648 W Ohio St
4.80(
330
)
Approved Pro
Customers say: Quality work
Recommended by 93% of Angi customers
Recommended by 93% of HomeAdvisor customers
607 local quotes requested

Family owned and operated. Septic and city sewer services for domestic, commerical, and industrial facilities. On occasions we use subs for directional boring electrical purposes only. Charges a flat rate. Septic inspections for real estate transactions. All estimates are free. Family owned business since the 1940's

"They did a great job."

Debbie W on July 2024

Family owned and operated. Septic and city sewer services for domestic, commerical, and industrial facilities. On occasions we use subs for directional boring electrical purposes only. Charges a flat rate. Septic inspections for real estate transactions. All estimates are free. Family owned business since the 1940's

"They did a great job."

Debbie W on July 2024


Kirby Brothers Plumbing
301 W. Pierce St.
4.31(
36
)
Kirby Brothers Plumbing
301 W. Pierce St.
4.31(
36
)
Customers say: Super punctual
17 years of experience

Plumbing Company

"Were not careful while installing toilet. Did not do the full job, did not clean. Caused a leak that lead to thousands of dollars of damage to the house and they did not want to take responsibility. If you look at their page, they are not actually Angi approved. They also don’t seem to have the proper licensing. Insurance is covering most of the work, but because of the laziness and dishonesty of this company, we have had workers in the house for days fixing the damage, our insurance rates will go up, and we had to spend our first couple days home from the hospital with our newborn at a hotel (that was when we discovered the leak). Shame on you, Kirby Brothers, for not making it right when you messed up."

Becca L on March 2025

Plumbing Company

"Were not careful while installing toilet. Did not do the full job, did not clean. Caused a leak that lead to thousands of dollars of damage to the house and they did not want to take responsibility. If you look at their page, they are not actually Angi approved. They also don’t seem to have the proper licensing. Insurance is covering most of the work, but because of the laziness and dishonesty of this company, we have had workers in the house for days fixing the damage, our insurance rates will go up, and we had to spend our first couple days home from the hospital with our newborn at a hotel (that was when we discovered the leak). Shame on you, Kirby Brothers, for not making it right when you messed up."

Becca L on March 2025


Dewey Sizemore/ Dewey Sizemore Excavating & Buildi
2247 Grandma Barnes Rd
5.00(
4
)
Dewey Sizemore/ Dewey Sizemore Excavating & Buildi
2247 Grandma Barnes Rd
5.00(
4
)
Customers say: Quick response
Recommended by 100% of Angi customers
Recommended by 100% of HomeAdvisor customers

Dewey Sizemore Excavating & Building is an an owner-operated Excavating company. We have been in business for over 20 years and specialize in more than just Excavating. We offer sewer, water, spigots, drains, basements, coy ponds, driveways, retaining walls, foundations, footers, rough grades, finish grades, demolition, room additions, concrete, and much more! No job too small! Very competitive pricing and free estimates.

"Dewey rebuilt the Bell tower on the historic county Courthouse very professional and payed excellent attention to detail. We will definitely be using him again"

Andy R on September 2019

Dewey Sizemore Excavating & Building is an an owner-operated Excavating company. We have been in business for over 20 years and specialize in more than just Excavating. We offer sewer, water, spigots, drains, basements, coy ponds, driveways, retaining walls, foundations, footers, rough grades, finish grades, demolition, room additions, concrete, and much more! No job too small! Very competitive pricing and free estimates.

"Dewey rebuilt the Bell tower on the historic county Courthouse very professional and payed excellent attention to detail. We will definitely be using him again"

Andy R on September 2019

...
Showing 1-10 of 150

FAQs for well pump installation and replacement projects in Columbus, IN

Most standard insurance policies provide coverage for sudden, unexpected damage from specific causes like electrical surges or lightning strikes. However, policies typically exclude coverage for normal wear and tear or maintenance-related issues. Review your specific policy language carefully, as coverage details vary significantly between insurance providers.

While continuous operation would significantly increase costs, residential well pumps aren't designed to run constantly. Instead, they operate intermittently as needed to maintain pressure, typically running several hours daily rather than continuously. Modern systems use pressure tanks and switches to manage pump cycling efficiently.

Check for features like variable speed operation, modern motor design, and appropriate sizing for your needs. Frequent cycling, unusual noises, or unexpectedly high electric bills may indicate efficiency problems. A professional evaluation from a home energy auditor near you can help identify opportunities for improving system performance.

The Columbus, IN homeowners’ guide to well pump installations and replacements
From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.
A septic system on the backyard
Apr 16, 2025
Apr 16, 2025
If you need to install a new septic system, use our cost guide to budget for this extensive project.
outdoor water lines with backflow preventer
Jun 12, 2025
Jun 12, 2025
Backflow preventer costs depend on type, size, location, and labor costs. This guide breaks down the cost factors to help you budget.
Man inspecting well
Apr 21, 2025
Apr 21, 2025
Discover how factors such as your location, service requirements, labor rates, and add-ons affect well inspection costs.
well pump in borehole water supply system
Apr 16, 2025
Apr 16, 2025
Budget for well pump repair costs based on factors such as parts and components, location, pump type, labor, inspections, and more.
septic tank in yard under repair
Mar 23, 2025
Mar 23, 2025
Budget for septic tank repair costs based on factors including parts, materials, labor, ongoing maintenance costs, and more.
Girl washing her hands in the kitchen
Mar 20, 2025
Mar 20, 2025
Use this guide to budget for a septic system inspection based on cost factors such as inspection type, accessibility, and additional septic services.
Share project details to get started.