Top-rated well pump installers and replacers.

Get matched with top well pump installers and replacers in Shelbyville, IN

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Find Well pump installers and replacers in Shelbyville

Avatar for C&J Well Drilling and Pump Co
C&J Well Drilling and Pump Co
4.8(
390
)

Serving Shelbyville, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 1996

Emergency services offered

Warranties offered

"We were without water due to problems with our old well in which we did not know the location or condition of. It was recommended and agreed that a new well was the best option. They put us at the top of the list due to being without water and got us going with a new well very quickly. I would highly recommend them for service."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+89

Response time10 hrs
Response rate100%
4 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Plumbing Heating Paramedics
Plumbing Heating Paramedics
4.6(
2,376
)

Serving Shelbyville, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2010

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I appreciate everyone at Plumbing Heating Paramedics who was a part of installing my new Trane Heat Pump! What a fantastic team, everyone was professional and respectful and answered my questions and concerns. Skip was especially patient and very knowledgeable on the system and its operation! It shows this company has good leadership who takes care of their employees."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+13

Response time1 day
Response rate91%
30 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Hope Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling
Hope Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling
4.5(
1,262
)

Serving Shelbyville, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2007

Warranties offered

Credit card accepted

"It went extremely well. The technician was professional and thorough. He spend at least 30 minutes with me reviewing the current configuration to ensure that the replacement water heater would meet our needs. We switched from a tank water heater to a tankless water heater and couldn't be happier. The tech did a great job with the installation and left the area clean and organized."
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos
Additional Photos

+17

80 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by87%of homeowners
Avatar for Hamilton Bros, Inc.
Hamilton Bros, Inc.
4.3(
22
)

Serving Shelbyville, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2016

Free estimates

Credit card accepted

"Derick, of Hamilton Brothers, contacted me shortly after my Home Advisor search. He was very willing to answer all my questions. He also came out to look at the job, my well pump was failing. After cost comparison, and the fact that Derick took the time to come out and look at the job, I decided to give him the work. He did explain that the cost could escalate from the estimate due to a verity of factors with the well, pump or well head. My well did have some issues and the price was higher than I expected but within the range of his explanation. I did have a new pump and piping and wiring installed the same day. However, his crew and he were not on the same page as I was expecting a return visit, after the ground hardened up, to pull the old pump, which was stuck in the well. I called Derick, a week later, to discover that removing the old pump was not necessary unless it caused a restriction in water flow. We ll see what the summer holds and if this is a problem as I was first told that the pump had to be removed and now it could stay in place and never cause a problem. Time will tell. I rate the work quality as a 3.0 because the old piping and wiring was left in my yard, as I said the crew thought they were coming back soon. I gave a 4.0 for customer service because Derick was quick to respond and willing to share his knowledge but the communication between his crew, Derick and I could have been better. I gave a 3.5 for valued for the money, as I said the cost was higher than I expected but within the high range we discussed. Overall, I am pleased with the company and the professionalism of the company and would recommend them."
Response time5 hrs
23 neighbors recently requested a quote
Recommended by100%of homeowners
Avatar for Bergen Co, LLC
Bergen Co, LLC
5.0(
6
)

Serving Shelbyville, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

In business since 2025

Emergency services offered

Small jobs welcome

Your trusted partner for comprehensive property solutions\nWe provide homeowners, rental property investors, and apartment complex managers with reliable, high-quality maintenance and repair services. Whether you need ongoing support or a single project, our team is committed to delivering exceptional craftsmanship and professional service.\nOur expertise includes:\n Property Maintenance: From preventative care to emergency repairs, we keep your property in excellent condition.\n Unit Renovations and Turns: We offer efficient and thorough services to prepare your units for new tenants.\n Drywall Services: Our team handles all aspects of drywall installation and repair.\n Clear Outs and Demolition: We manage property cleanouts and selective demolition projects with a focus on efficiency.\n Specialized Projects: We have the skills to execute custom carpentry work, such as built-ins, decks, and other custom designs.\nContact us to see how we can assist with your property's needs.

Home flip
Bathroom ceiling repair
Bathroom ceiling repair
Drywall repair
Drywall repair

+11

Response time1 day
4 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for Mgm pro remodeling
Mgm pro remodeling
New to Angi

Serving Shelbyville, IN and surrounding areas

Approved

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

Hello, I’m Moses. I’m proud to be part of a dedicated and skilled team that truly understands the importance of keeping your home comfortable and safe. We specialize in plumbing, HVAC, and electrical services, and we’re here for you around the clock. Whether it’s a leak, a sewer backup, or an HVAC emergency, you can count on us to respond quickly with care and expertise.\n\nWe recognize that unexpected issues can be stressful, and we strive to alleviate that burden by offering competitive prices because we value your hard-earned money. Our goal is to provide you with not just solutions but also peace of mind. Don’t hesitate to reach out to us; we’re committed to delivering outstanding customer service and high-quality work that you can trust.

2 neighbors recently requested a quote
Avatar for US Water Systems Inc
US Water Systems Inc
4.8(
49
)

Serving Shelbyville, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1997

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"We have a well, and were concerned about water safety. Water smelled, and left colored deposits in sinks, toilets. Clothes from washer lost their newness look and feel. We had our water lab tested, discovered we had E-coli, hardness, iron, and tannin. Mark's company also collected a water sample and their results matched what we already had discovered. Mark Timmons' presentation was so clear and concise, thoroughly explained my options, showed several options. We decided we needed to do everything we could to get safe water, water that tastes good, and did not smell. Installation was no problem, and the installer was very meticulous and neat. Removed all existing containers, etc. Cleaned up everything. He even cleaned out the items stored under kitchen sink to make room for Reverse Osmosis system. After the installation, I had the water analyzed again by the lab, and it was perfect in every way: no E-coli, etc. Water has no taste, great soap lather in shower and kitchen sink soap, shower head has better pressure. Clothes look better. I even use the water dispenser for the clothes iron, and use the water in my CPAP machine. This saves me going to the store and buying distilled water, about a dollar a week savings in that item alone. I think that my salt purchases are down, but can't really substantiate that, didn't keep track of $ spent on previous water softener. We are totally pleased with every aspect of this experience."
Recommended by100%of homeowners
The Plumbing Co Inc
4.3(
47
)

Serving Shelbyville, IN and surrounding areas

In business since 1999

Free estimates

Emergency services offered

"I initially contacted Cindy on 11/12/2012. I had to leave a message and she called me back in a day or 2. I explained what I wanted and she asked if I wanted it done before Thanksgiving. I advised no, but I would like it done by Christmas. She said Chris would need to stop by and see exactly what I wanted and she would check with him and then let us know when he could come by. Christmas came and went and we did not hear back from them. We went on vacation in January and when we returned we called them again the first of February. Chris and his helper did stop by in the next few days and we determined what type of sink and faucet I wanted. Chris said it should be in stock and he would have Cindy call me about setting up a time for the next week. I didn't hear from them that week and when I called the next week Cindy said they had to order the sink and it would be in in 3 weeks which would be 3/11/13. It finally came in later than estimated and Conrad came to install on 3/23/2013. He pulled my old sink and faucets and was putting plumbing together on new sink when he discovered the sink was defective. They said they would have to reorder and would contact me when they received it. Long story long, the new sink was finally delivered and installed on 4/10/2013. We do realize that the defective sink was not their fault but the whole experience was very frustating. In the end, we were pleased with the product and the installation. Conrad did a very nice job installing and cleaning up.
Overall, customer service and communication were not the best.

"
Recommended by90%of homeowners
Showing 1-10 of 43
FAQs for well pump installation and replacement projects in Shelbyville, IN

Signs that your well pressure tank requires replacement include inconsistent water pressure, your pump turning on and off frequently (known as short cycling), visible leaks around the tank, or unusual noises from your well system. Physical damage, corrosion, or a tank that's reached its seven to 10-year expected lifespan may also indicate it's time for replacement. When multiple issues arise simultaneously, replacement often proves more economical than attempting repairs.

The timeframe for professional well pressure tank replacement varies depending on your specific system and any complications that might arise during installation. Factors that can affect installation time include accessibility of your current tank, whether additional components need replacement, and the complexity of your well system. For precise timing expectations, consult with the professional handling your installation.

Attempting to replace your well pressure tank involves several potential risks, including improper pressure calibration that could damage your pump, contamination of your water supply, and physical injury from handling heavy equipment. Additionally, incorrect installation might lead to water leaks, property damage, or system inefficiency. Many manufacturers also specify that professional installation is required to maintain warranty coverage, making the $125 to $200 professional installation fee a worthwhile investment for most homeowners.

The Shelbyville, IN homeowners’ guide to well pump installations and replacements

From average costs to expert advice, get all the answers you need to get your job done.