Top-rated locksmiths.

Get matched with top locksmiths in Bay Shore, NY

Enter your zip and get matched with up to 3 pros

Matching on HomeAdvisor

Share some details icon
Share some details about your home project.
Match with local pros icon
Within moments, match with highly-rated local pros.
Compare quotes icon
Compare quotes and choose the best pro for the job.

Locksmiths in Bay Shore

Avatar for Key Craft LLC

Key Craft LLC

29 HIGHLAND DOWN,
5.00(
4
)
•Approved Pro

Key Craft LLC

29 HIGHLAND DOWN,
5.00(
4
)
•Approved Pro
13 local quotes requested
3 years of experience

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

"I could not be more grateful for this company, I made an emergency phone call after both my keys were stolen while I was out. Antonio was there within 25 minutes and successfully made two new keys that were an exact match to my last keys, price was completely fair and Antonio was courteous, respectful, and friendly. He even became friends with my dog which most people do not! "

Katelyn M on July 2025

We pride our company on reliability, great communication, integrity, and quality work. We are experts in our trade and will do our best to keep you as educated as we can on your particular task or project. We look forward to earning your business!

"I could not be more grateful for this company, I made an emergency phone call after both my keys were stolen while I was out. Antonio was there within 25 minutes and successfully made two new keys that were an exact match to my last keys, price was completely fair and Antonio was courteous, respectful, and friendly. He even became friends with my dog which most people do not! "

Katelyn M on July 2025

America's Key To Security, Inc.

27 Euston Road South
4.84(
543
)
•Approved Pro

America's Key To Security, Inc.

27 Euston Road South
4.84(
543
)
•Approved Pro
Super Service Award
Customers say: True professional
Recommended by 90% of Angi customers
Recommended by 90% of HomeAdvisor customers
84 local quotes requested

We are a security company providing quality service to Homeowners and Businesses in the New York area. We pride ourselves on expert installations. We offer a Lifetime Warranty on all our installations

"Mitch was extremely hard-working, took care in his repair work, and was so easy to talk with. He’s definitely “Old school” in his approach regarding work ethics which is difficult to find in today’s environment. I would definitely recommend Mitch and would be happy to be a reference for others who are considering using his expertise. Laura Sarli"

Laura S on September 2025

We are a security company providing quality service to Homeowners and Businesses in the New York area. We pride ourselves on expert installations. We offer a Lifetime Warranty on all our installations

"Mitch was extremely hard-working, took care in his repair work, and was so easy to talk with. He’s definitely “Old school” in his approach regarding work ethics which is difficult to find in today’s environment. I would definitely recommend Mitch and would be happy to be a reference for others who are considering using his expertise. Laura Sarli"

Laura S on September 2025

Avatar for Pop-A-Lock Locksmith

Pop-A-Lock Locksmith

2 Country Court
5.00(
3
)
•Approved Pro

Pop-A-Lock Locksmith

2 Country Court
5.00(
3
)
•Approved Pro
30 local quotes requested
11 years of experience

Pop-A-Lock provides exceptional service to the surrounding areas. We take pride in all of our services. Our customer satisfaction is our top priority and plan to earn your trust for a lifetime. We can help you with any of your Locksmith needs. Give us a call for a free estimate!

"The owner made good on his promises. "

Marty K on July 2025

Pop-A-Lock provides exceptional service to the surrounding areas. We take pride in all of our services. Our customer satisfaction is our top priority and plan to earn your trust for a lifetime. We can help you with any of your Locksmith needs. Give us a call for a free estimate!

"The owner made good on his promises. "

Marty K on July 2025

Avatar for Unlocked by Ari LLC

Unlocked by Ari LLC

18 Beach Road
4.95(
19
)
•Approved Pro

Unlocked by Ari LLC

18 Beach Road
4.95(
19
)
•Approved Pro
78 local quotes requested
3 years of experience

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality and customer service that we provide to meet every consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent customer service from start to completion of a project. To understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a personal and professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"Ari installed a smart lock and replaced the bottom door knob and lock for me. He did a great job. He was professional, friendly, easy to schedule, and on time. I would highly recommend him for his professionalism and fair prices."

erik l on September 2025

We take great pride in our experience, expertise, quality and customer service that we provide to meet every consumer's needs. It is our mission to provide excellent customer service from start to completion of a project. To understand the needs and expectations of our customers, we take great care to work and communicate with every customer in a personal and professional manner. Our reputation is based on service, safety and quality, regardless of how large or small the job.

"Ari installed a smart lock and replaced the bottom door knob and lock for me. He did a great job. He was professional, friendly, easy to schedule, and on time. I would highly recommend him for his professionalism and fair prices."

erik l on September 2025

Tuckahoe Locksmith Store

21 Columbus Avenue (Suite: D)
No reviews yet

Tuckahoe Locksmith Store

21 Columbus Avenue (Suite: D)
No reviews yet
29 years of experience

Tuckahoe Locksmith Store has been servicing since . It continues to provide the best Locksmith Services and products to help keep people safe and secure in Tuckahoe, NY. From Doors to Cars and from Home Safe installation to simple Key Duplication, Tuckahoe Locksmith Store does it all, and at the right prices too! Call us for more details.

Tuckahoe Locksmith Store has been servicing since . It continues to provide the best Locksmith Services and products to help keep people safe and secure in Tuckahoe, NY. From Doors to Cars and from Home Safe installation to simple Key Duplication, Tuckahoe Locksmith Store does it all, and at the right prices too! Call us for more details.

Spuyten Duyvil NY Locksmith Store

570 Kappock St (Suite: 459H)
No reviews yet

Spuyten Duyvil NY Locksmith Store

570 Kappock St (Suite: 459H)
No reviews yet
28 years of experience

We are a Local Locksmith Company that provides locksmith service in Spuyten Duyvil, NY. We offer our Locksmith service 24 hours a day and 7 days a week to those in need of our assistance.

We are a Local Locksmith Company that provides locksmith service in Spuyten Duyvil, NY. We offer our Locksmith service 24 hours a day and 7 days a week to those in need of our assistance.

Madison NJ Locksmith Store

4 Park Ave
No reviews yet

Madison NJ Locksmith Store

4 Park Ave
No reviews yet
33 years of experience

At Madison NJ Locksmith Store our promise to you and this great community is a great Locksmith Service in Madison, NJ. We offer Locksmith Service at any time 24 hours.

At Madison NJ Locksmith Store our promise to you and this great community is a great Locksmith Service in Madison, NJ. We offer Locksmith Service at any time 24 hours.

Expert Locksmith Shop

231 Black Oak Ridge Road
No reviews yet

Expert Locksmith Shop

231 Black Oak Ridge Road
No reviews yet
37 years of experience

At Expert Locksmith Shop you can find professional Locksmith technicians that are License Bonded and Insured, We provide a 24 Hr Locksmith Service 7 days a week in all the area of Wayne, NJ, For any Locksmith needed Residential, Commercial, Automotive give us a call today.

At Expert Locksmith Shop you can find professional Locksmith technicians that are License Bonded and Insured, We provide a 24 Hr Locksmith Service 7 days a week in all the area of Wayne, NJ, For any Locksmith needed Residential, Commercial, Automotive give us a call today.

Garfield NJ Locksmith Store

59 Outwater Ln
No reviews yet

Garfield NJ Locksmith Store

59 Outwater Ln
No reviews yet
39 years of experience

Garfield NJ Locksmith Store are a full service Locksmith Company, Who proudly provides Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours in Garfield, NJ.

Garfield NJ Locksmith Store are a full service Locksmith Company, Who proudly provides Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours in Garfield, NJ.

Master Locksmith Store

5825 Broadway
No reviews yet

Master Locksmith Store

5825 Broadway
No reviews yet
46 years of experience

Here at Master Locksmith Store We are a full service Locksmith company in Bronx, NY metro area, that proudly provides Locksmith services throughout our fully equipped service vehicles and technicians are available for all your Locksmith needs Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours a day 7 days a week.

Here at Master Locksmith Store We are a full service Locksmith company in Bronx, NY metro area, that proudly provides Locksmith services throughout our fully equipped service vehicles and technicians are available for all your Locksmith needs Residential Commercial and Automotive and Emergency Service 24 hours a day 7 days a week.

...
Showing 1-10 of 755
FAQs for locksmith service projects in Bay Shore, NY

The installation timeframe varies based on door preparation and lock complexity. For doors already prepared with appropriate holes, installation might take 15 to 30 minutes. New installations requiring drilling take one to two hours. First-time DIY installers should allocate additional time to ensure proper alignment and function. Professional locksmiths complete standard installations efficiently due to their specialized tools and experience.

Most residential doors can accommodate deadbolts, but certain door types present challenges. Solid wood and fiberglass doors accept standard deadbolt hardware, while metal doors require specialized drilling equipment. Hollow-core interior doors lack the structural integrity to properly support deadbolts without additional reinforcement. Doors should be at least 1⅜ inches thick to properly house standard deadbolt mechanisms.

Door warranties remain valid when deadbolts are installed according to the manufacturer's guidelines. However, improper installation that damages the door structure might affect warranty coverage. 

Before modifying any door under warranty, review the documentation for specific limitations or requirements regarding hardware installation. Some manufacturers provide templates or guidelines for acceptable lock placement to maintain warranty protection.

Rekeying offers a more economical alternative to complete replacement when you need to change access, but the lock mechanism remains in good condition. This process involves reconfiguring the internal pins to work with a new key while retaining the existing hardware. For homeowners with multiple locks, rekeying provides the convenience of using a single key for all entry points while maintaining security.